Extreme Makeover: Model Edition - 
by J-Unit
The other pairs were Lisa and Ebony, who was described as looking like a dead carcass, not exactly the praise one is looking for, and Kyle and Kim. Kim was worried about how she would compete against Kyle, but they were wearing a pantsuit, and Kim, failing to impress people in a pantsuit is a like a fat person failing to impress you with their cooking. Anyway, here are my favorite shots from this week. (Click an image for a larger version)
Two by two, they brought the girls up and critiqued them. The panel has not been particularly hard this year without Janice and Nolé, and nobody is really interested in telling the girls how horrible they looked when they are in front of them. About the nastiest it got was when Jay Alexander told Ebony that a hair in the face photo is for ugly girls, but then I believe Tyra told her that her face was pretty, so that wasn't even an insult. Jay also told Coryn she had a fashion violation, and Tyra told Kyle that she is "trying too hard" even though she has everything she needs. God, I hope they have some really mean people guest judge later, because this is a little too tame.
When it came time to name the winners, Coryn beat out Sarah, even though James St. James said that Coryn was going for Beyonce but was more Rupaul, which is a PERFECT description of Coryn at this moment, i.e. not top model material. Kim beat Kyle, which surprised her, but looking at their picture, there was no life in Kyle's face, and on a second glance, she is looking dowdy after her makeover. Lisa beat Ebony, and the judges were floored by her pose. She told them that she has been practicing since she was seven and knows every pose in the book. I am sure the other girls wanted to roll their eyes, but considering the high praise Lisa garners each time, they should start practicing in front of the mirror until some of the moves come more naturally to them as well.
In my favorite comparison, Nik beat out Bre and Diane lost out to Nicole. I think Nicole had a good picture, but the judges called it the best of the group. James St. James said her look made him want to do naughty things, like perhaps see a porno movie, with women! Maybe I was expecting a little more couture or something more dramatic with the makeup, but I wasn't blown away. What do you think?
After all of the winners were separated, the rest of the girls that made it this week were called until we were left with Ebony and Diane. Both of these girls had the same problem, which is that they had a lot much energy going into the competition, but it's not showing in any of the pictures. Ebony was confident and obsessed with modeling, but it seemed like she lost her confidence, and started wilting under Lisa's glow. Diane came in with a lot of spunk, but the beauty in her face and body were just not coming across in the photos.
Personally, I thought there was no chance that they were going to choose Diane, but that is exactly what happened. It's not that Diane isn't good looking, but she seems like she is not enjoying herself anymore, although the same could be said for Ebony. Perhaps the judges thought that since Ebony was so young, she would have plenty of chances, and it would give her a chance to mature before she took another stab at the business. I can't really say that I am that crushed, because neither girl really did it for me.
So, after the makeovers, I have to say that my favorites are Lisa, Bre, and Sarah. I also like Nik, but wasn't so hot on the makeover. I think Kyle and Kim will also go far. Who are your favorites? Did the right girl get sent home? Who had the best makeover? Who had the worst?
Previous page | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 ( Comments ) | Discuss In Our Forums



Comments
I wish they would do away with the pretense of including a plus-size model. Especially since in this particular case, I just don't think Diane looks "high fashion" at all, but they're gonna keep her around for a while to seem more inclusive and all that. Don't mind that Ebony got the boot this week, but I do think Ashley was robbed last week seems only on account of her stupid "pretty gene" comment.
btw, has anyone else noticed that Kim actually has a bit of a nasty streak.
Posted by: chronic | September 29, 2005 10:32 AM(#1 of 40)
Great write-up. I do think the right girl went home. She looked least modelish to me, although she has great skin. My favs are Kyle, Bre, and Lisa in that order; they're gorgeous. I think Cassandra looks great with that new hair, but I can totally sympathize with how she felt. If they have it, most women love their long hair. And for those to say oh it'll grow back, well it will take some time to get back to that length. So I was dying when Miss. J said that Coryn was tryin to do Beyonce but got Rupaul! She still looks kinda manly to me. I thought Jayla and Sarah looked better before the make-overs.
Posted by: couchpotato | September 29, 2005 10:41 AM(#2 of 40)
Rumor is Coryn actually IS a guy.
Posted by: EdHill | September 29, 2005 11:18 AM(#3 of 40)
kim looks the same. but there is something about her......
i like sarah, bre, and cassandras makeovers most of all. lisa looks scary. nicole, and jayla look the same. kyle looks washed out.
diane is boring.
i cannot wait until next week for the hook-up!
this show is such a guilty pleasure.
Posted by: angst in my pants | September 29, 2005 11:39 AM(#4 of 40)
Nice write-up, J-Unit. A few thoughts: when James St. James hit the set, I was sure it was Trotter from Upright Citizens Brigade. The way he was acting, I was sure it was a deep infiltration. Good job, Trotter! Second, Cassandra looks like a cross between James Carville and E.T.; well, she looks like James Carville. She is gone soon.
My favorites are lisa, nicole, and kyle. ashley was one of the hottest ones; had she made it past last week she would've been around for a while.
Plus, bring back Nole!
Posted by: ed | September 29, 2005 11:45 AM(#5 of 40)
My favorite is Kim. Mrs. Papercuts! can't understand it. She must have asked me "You REALLY think she's hot?!?!" six times last night.
Posted by: Papercuts! | September 29, 2005 11:49 AM(#6 of 40)
I was going to suggest Coryn/Prince.
Posted by: B-Side | September 29, 2005 11:49 AM(#7 of 40)
Kim's "yessssssssssss" with the arm throwdown made the show.
Posted by: kimlover | September 29, 2005 11:53 AM(#8 of 40)
How did they stand there face to face with James St. James without laughing?
Posted by: callygirl | September 29, 2005 12:08 PM(#9 of 40)
"At least it wasn't a scary clown, unless you consider a large, bald, gay man prancing around Beverly Hills in a Tang-colored outfit frightening, that is."
I'm LMAO in the middle of the office at this shit! I could barely stifle the giggles when a fat asian boy came to ask me where the bathroom was.
In Ep. 1 I thought Nicole was semi-retarded, but she is actually kicking some ass in the photos. I thought hers was the best.
Kimmy is my girl, she IS the show.
Posted by: KW | September 29, 2005 12:24 PM(#10 of 40)
Dude, I love James St. James and I am thrilled that this season, the show seems to actually be putting some character and thought into the challanges and tasks.
They are working with actual living legends, it seems, instead of fame whores like Janice Dickenson and Nole Marin.
I like Kim and Lisa the best. Lisa is annoying as hell but all of those girls should be so prepared. She cracks me up and the others making fun of her cracks me up, too. This is gonna be an awesome season.
Once they get rid of the token idiot beauty queens.
Seriously, who doesn't know what "mod" is? And if Tyra Banks is telling me that she's going to give me a new look, I am going to get home from the salon and hit the Internet to find out what my new look is. If I'm on a show to learn how to be a model and Tyra helped pick a look for me titled Alien Dog Chow, I would learn to f-ing bark, you know?
Gawd, out of curiosity, if nothing else. So Buh-bye dumb girls. I hate you.
As for the guy stuff about Coryn... maybe... but I'm not convinced. I dated Namoli B. for a long time and learned some stuff about gender expression. Coryn seems too natural, in that you don't see her watching the other girls the way I've observed a LOT of M2F people watching girls... you have to remember that with M2F, there's usually a dude mentality that doesn't go away just because the parts are all in place. I would totally think Coryn would seem more "acting" or seem more driven if she was trans.
She just seems too comfortable. But. I don't want to stereo-type anything except myself: Chubby, ex-sorority girls who drink a lot will never be on ANTM!!
Whoo!
Go Me!
Posted by: Sarah | September 29, 2005 12:40 PM(#11 of 40)
I actually thought that Coryn looked a lot like Tyra in the after makeover picture. I didn't see the episode yet though.
Posted by: ali | September 29, 2005 12:51 PM(#12 of 40)
J-Unit I thought of you and the swooning you surely did when they had a long slow shot of Tyra's decolletage during panel.
Kim is my fav. she seems really fun. but what was she saying when she was imitating Lisa? i couldnt' hear
Posted by: Leah3t | September 29, 2005 12:53 PM(#13 of 40)
I like Sarah, but I always seem to root for the big awkward girl who gets nervous and can't walk in heels (last season's Michelle, for example.)
Also, I think they deliberately give the snooty bitchy girl the super dramatic makeover she'll hate on purpose. It's definitely happened before (cycle 2?)
Posted by: UnderSiege | September 29, 2005 1:03 PM(#14 of 40)
Does anyone else think Lisa looks like Rachel from the Road Rules??
Posted by: Deena | September 29, 2005 1:20 PM(#15 of 40)
Leah3t,
As soon as they showed Tyra, I immediately thought "wow, she's not wearing a bra". I guess my quirks are too obvious.
Re: Coryn,
I have been sent the links to the rumors, and they are really just speculation so far. I think Coryn is a woman, she just has a VERY mannish chin.
Posted by: J-Unit | September 29, 2005 1:36 PM(#16 of 40)
i too thought the muppet eagle ended up looking a lot like TYRA in the "after" photo. weird.
Posted by: jash | September 29, 2005 1:39 PM(#17 of 40)
J-Unit, your quirks are obvious and loveable.
Everyone keeps making muppel eagle references here but i think that black guy on this season's apprentice, now he is the real guy who looks like the eagle.
Posted by: Leah3t | September 29, 2005 2:20 PM(#18 of 40)
I agree that Nicole's "Best picture of the night" wasn't all that great, but maybe it's because she sort of reminds me of Winnie from "The Wonder Years", and Winnie doesn't exactly inspire thoughts of high fashion or top-model beauty. Sara is my fave now with her haircut, and Lisa is also up there. You're right about Nik too, her make-over should have been called a make-under (I thought they were supposed to try to make the girls looks better, and not to make them look like skinny lions)...
Posted by: Jess | September 29, 2005 2:40 PM(#19 of 40)
My favorite is Kim... I think she's hot, I'd buy something if she told me to, and she's down to earth. I like Sara too. I think Nik is going to win, because... it seems like who they'd pick, she photographs really well, and the look they picked for her (bohemian chic) is like... super marketable right now. I think it would have been HILARIOUS if they had kicked Cassandra off right after they cut her hair. Because she's crazy and hugely bitchy. I really think that, even though Lisa's okay in pictures, she's just hideous in the rest of the show.
Posted by: Mallory | September 29, 2005 3:23 PM(#20 of 40)
I'm a bit surprised at all the Kim raves. As J-Unit says, "Hmm, Wesleyan, lesbian, short hair, it's her thing all right; she just shares it with a lot of people." I don't dislike her, she's lovely, but I just don't think she's extraordinarly unusual or cool. And her sour grapes at losing that style competition were not cool. I could walk down the street and find loads of girls that look the same if not better pretty easily. Besides, her photos were pretty blah, and I don't see 'em getting better.
Posted by: chronic | September 29, 2005 3:41 PM(#21 of 40)
Great job J-Unit! I think Lisa looks like Sandra Bernhard's little sister yet surprisingly, she photograpghs really well. I think it is because she has definitely done her homework and it shows. I am always surprised when ANTM contestants don't know the names of designers or models. I think the only other girl that could really make it would be Kyle. I cannot stand Cassandra. Although her hair looks great, she doesn't have the style or edge to carry it off. She is not model material.
Posted by: Julie | September 29, 2005 3:49 PM(#22 of 40)
In my opinion, pretty much none of this season's girls are top model quality. I have no idea why they got picked, but for me, no one seems to stand out. Just my two cents!
Posted by: stacey | September 29, 2005 4:37 PM(#23 of 40)
They should have just kicked off both Ebony and Diane and saved us a week, they both sucked. i'm glad that there seems to be more of a competition this season, last season Naima was a runaway favorite from the very beginning.
Posted by: becks | September 29, 2005 8:41 PM(#24 of 40)
I, too, thought Sandra Bernhard. And Stacie J? perfect!! I said to my roommate while we were watching the show, man, Nik reminds me of someone but I can't place it. and there it was. the 'gasm came through.
I have to say I'm in the Kim camp. Every time she makes fun of someone, it's always exactly what everyone was thinking anyway. I also think she's really hot and if I was going to "experiment" with a chick, man, she would be it.
Lisa just pisses me off royally. Sure, she may know a lot, but the way she presents her knowledge is ridiculously condescending. I do really like her pictures though and think she'll go far.
Poor Ebony -- but I have to say I never thought she was very attractive.
Nicole just looks like the pretty girl in the senior class of high school. She wins Homecoming Queen and that's about it. I can't believe they even picked her. She's so vanilla to me.
that's it
Posted by: fycin | September 29, 2005 9:04 PM(#25 of 40)
I am so glad that Ebony went packing. Her voice sounds like any Jim Henson puppet. (take your pick) And her profile is horrible. I can not believe that she made it into the final cut over anyone else! Poor girl. I can not see her becoming successful in modeling EVER!
As for Coryn. They hit it right on with the Rupaul comment.
My favorite three are Cassandra (she is stunning with her new short hair) Nik and Sara.
I am so over Diane and Kim, and hope to see them both go shortly after ManCoryn.
Posted by: usnrnpage | September 29, 2005 9:14 PM(#26 of 40)
Oh no you didn't play the resemblence card!
Lisa looks like that Vulcan on Enterprise, the last Star Trek show. But overall all the girls are fierce this season. Hated to see Ebony go because I think the X-large latina was the worst of the bunch.
God, if I knew club kids could become rich and famous runway trainers, makeup artists and iridescent dressup clowns I would have never focused on my degree and really queened it up.
Posted by: America's Next Top Fan | September 30, 2005 6:03 AM(#27 of 40)
BTW, James St. James was hi-larry-us running down the street screaming in that bullhorn w/his white dress blowing in the wind. I LMAO.
Posted by: America's Next Top Fan | September 30, 2005 6:06 AM(#28 of 40)
Ok i had to look up the word "decolletage". Thanks leah3t for expanding my vocabulary.
Posted by: America's Next Top Fan | September 30, 2005 6:15 AM(#29 of 40)
Where's all the Jayla love? I'm all about her (for now.) I think she'll look even better next week after they chop off some of her extensions.
While they did a better job this season seeking out model types,(unlike the 5'6" Eva), Lisa is still "old," and Diane is "fat."
No, not Old and fat in real life, but in model-world. Props to Bre and the jessica simpson looking woman too.
Posted by: sg-dub | September 30, 2005 10:26 AM(#30 of 40)
Coryn is a man. And with the blond hair it is just undeniable. I paused the Tivo everytime she was on screen and yelled at my roommates, "MAN! She's a MAN!" Because she is a man.
I thought Nik's picture was the best, by far, though Sarah Coryn and Kim took good shots, too. I was CERTAIN that Lisa was the girl that was going to win the whole thing until she started pissing of the other girls.
Lisa, sweetheart, let me tell you a thing or two that I have learned from a few seasons of ANTM. Now unless you are Adrienne Curry, it is not a good idea to piss off all of the other girls! They will drain you of every ounce of self-esteem and confidence you have, and these are your only tools to win the show. Besides, they won't pick a winner that everyone hates. Bitches don't sell copies of Elle Girl. At least not anymore.
And the Muppet Eagle's name is Sam, by the way, kids.
Posted by: EmpressMinnie | September 30, 2005 4:30 PM(#31 of 40)
I can't believe you didn't mention in your recap just who James St James is. He's the guy whose real life Party Monster (the movie with Macauley Culkin) is based on. He's the club kid who killed his dealer in a particularly gruesome and notorious way (hint: drano and dismemberment). It's insane that ANTM could have him on as a "stylist," completely ignoring the fact that he's a vicious former junkie murderer! You know, in addition to wearing dresses.
Posted by: Sweet Fortune | September 30, 2005 11:52 PM(#32 of 40)
Sweet Fortune-- James St James wrote the book that Party Monster is based on.. he is the Seth Green character in the movie, not Michael Alig/Macauley Culkin, the guy who offed the dealer. Though I'm sure his forearm has plenty of scars too.
Posted by: beedub | October 1, 2005 7:05 AM(#33 of 40)
My favorite line in this ep was when kim said "No boy has this hair color!" and someone said "you're not a boy...." HAHAH
Besides that...there are boys with red hair.
Posted by: ali | October 2, 2005 12:55 PM(#34 of 40)
Sweet Fortune
It was Michael Alig who killed Angel Menedez and chopped him up, not James St James.
James St James wrote the book telling the story of Michael Alig, and that book was called called 'Disco Bloodbath. Later the the book was turned into the movie 'Party Monster'.
Posted by: herenandnow | October 3, 2005 10:39 AM(#35 of 40)
I'm telling you, once they get the bible-thumping beauty queen off the show, this cycle is going to out-do any of Janice's inane, silicone expressions.
Hey chronic, thanks for calling out Kim's Wesleyan trip. My sister was exactly the same and after a few years in blue pants from the Naval outlet stores?
She's a corporate 'ho/, home-owner lesbian who gets waxed more than I do.
I got electolysis but whatevski.
You know I'm sayin'.
Posted by: Sarah | October 4, 2005 5:18 PM(#36 of 40)
Well, if it does turn out that Coryn is transgendered wouldn't it be lovely if there can be some kind of evolution in popular discourse that would state that "Coryn is transgendered" hypothetically instead of "she's a man." If she is transgendered she's certainly not a man or was she once a man. Transgendered people are born into the wrong bodies. It's a medical condition which should be refered to properly and respectfully of the people who have this condition.
Posted by: laverne | October 4, 2005 6:53 PM(#37 of 40)
I love Bre and Nik. Lisa, I hope she don't become a bitch. Cassandra is o.k. I don't think that Jayla,& Kyle will win. They don't stick out. I absolutely do not want Kim to win.
Posted by: Rrobert | October 5, 2005 4:42 PM(#38 of 40)
Why do Tyra let us know who's being eliminated at the beginning of the episode by talking about what they've done in a previous episode?
Please
Let Me Know.
Posted by: Rrobert | October 5, 2005 6:30 PM(#39 of 40)
lisa... blech... that nose - horrific! Aside from that, my only comment is that Kim reminds me SO much of a guy that I dated in highschool.
Posted by: alison | October 6, 2005 4:37 PM(#40 of 40)