The girls split up and find the others (Paige, Toby and Caleb) to warn them that A is on the train and that Aria is missing. Hanna grabs “Caleb” and tells him that Garrett is on the train and they have a situation but “he” is too interested in fondling her. Hanna looks up and realizes that Caleb is actually standing across the room so she turns around and pulls off his mask only to reveal a second one that looks very similar to her face. Ashley runs into the creepy girl who is now hiding out in Hanna’s room when she reveals that her mom got mad at her and that her sister probably told her lies about her. She mentions they fight over everything including dolls when Ashley tries to comfort her and realizes that she is ice cold. She goes to get Ted but when they walk upstairs she is missing and the blanket she put around her is now neatly folded on the bed. *spoiler* Pretty sure they will be adding Courtney into the mix very soon since she gets mentioned every Halloween. Google it.
Spencer is still looking for Aria when she gets attacked by the same person that drugged Aria. You know..I know Emily is supposed to be the athletic one but I thought Spencer played some kind of sport yet she couldn’t take her assailant? Paige ends up saving her by tackling the masked man/woman who ends up running away but leaving behind a red fake fingernail. Is it wrong that I kind of wished it was Toby in the mask? We know he visits Mona in the looney bin but so did Caleb and Lucas and god knows who else. Aria is still in the box but she’s apparently not alone as a dead Garrett had been stuffed in the box with her. So here is the problem, how is he already stiff and dead when he JUST talked with Spencer a few moments prior to Aria’s disappearance? There is no way that he would have stiffened and turned blue that quickly. Aria uses a nail that she almost face planted on to get out of her duct tape while the others are still searching for her. The girls send Paige to meet with Toby and Caleb by herself since she can obviously handle her own but not before Spencer thanks Paige for saving her.
Paige runs into Jenna who tells her that Aria has a thing for authority figures so she should look where the engineer is. Jenna then notices that Lucas’ camera has been left unattended and smiles to herself since she likely knows what he is up to since she’s on the A Team as well. Aria finally gets the tape off as the masked man and someone else arrive and start trying to push her box off the train. It seems as though this is a girl and a guy team pushing the box from the sound of their voices. However, Aria is wailing too much to really hear what they are saying but it was along the lines of being made to do something they didn’t want to do. The box gets caught on the flooring which leaves Aria time to grab a nearby screw driver and puncture one of the people pushing it. This makes them run off as the girls find and save Aria from going over the train. The girls turn to look into the box and realize that Aria wasn’t alone and that Garrett is now dead…and officially too. Not like Ian dead where they never saw his body after the fact. Ashley and Ted discuss the little girl who Ashley believes is a ghost. Ted is asked if he believes in ghost and being a pastor he says he isn’t supposed to. They drink wine and that’s the end of the discussion.