We've got 3 girls and 3 guys left and I really don't see the girls making it... they will be picked off one at a time. They need to pick their songs very caefully because the guys can survive a bad song choice and these girls can't.

I couldn't agree with you more, and that was proven with the Mariah night. None of the girls did well on Tues. I think the final two will be between David Archuleta, and David Cook.

I *hope* Syesha is next. Pipes or not, her tude pisses me off. No one wants to root for someone who thinks their doody doesn't smell.

Honestly? I really don't like any of these clowns. I don't get the Cook phenomenon, either. Archuleta is just ehhh. Castro is a one-note to me. Brooke needs to sing to children. She could be the female Raffi. Carly was the one I had hopes for -- but she's sinking fast.

I do like David Cook and I think you have to enjoy the type of music he sings to understand how well he can turn a song like he did MC's. He is more creative than the others, you must realize that????

And you asked for my thoughts..
My thought is they should have sent Brooke home too... she hasn't got the ability to handle what would come with winning AI... and isn't she, like, 40 or something?

Brooke sucked, Carly sucked...all the girls sucked on MC night. I wasn't a fan of David Cook until a couple weeks ago, and he's the one for me. Archuleta has pipes like I've never seen, but he doesn't have the star power that David Cook has in my opinion.

Also, I know it's a reality show, but I read that Carly and Mariah already knew each other from Carly's previous album that tanked and they pretended to meet for the first time. Either way, I'm over Carly.

Do you think I'm ill for already anticipating next week's show...and can't wait. It's getting unhealthy.