Can’t get enough of American Idol? Well then, you’re in luck Gasmi, because we’re now moving into hour 5,476 of auditions. Okay, okay, I may be exaggerating just a leetle but you get the picture. Tonight’s audition extravaganza is all about the Beatles. At first I’m super excited because I love the Beatles, but then I remember what show I’m watching envision what I’m likely to get tonight.
Let’s get to it, okay?
There can only be one Ra American Idol!
The auditioners travel to Vegas by bus where they will perform Beatles’ hits in duos and trios. Sixty-one people crammed on a bus? Blech.
What’s that smell?
Uh, that would be cheese and shattered dreams.
Which is exactly why you won’t see HIS ass on that bus. The bus delivers our young hopefuls to Vegas where they’ll now have twenty four hours to learn a Beatles song. That shouldn’t be too bad though because they’re also getting vocal coaches to help them work.
Clips of singing, vocal coaching, and tears. Some girl Lauren tells us she just can’t go home! I bet she’s he only one that feels that way. As the day wears on everyone gets more and more emotional, including the vocal coaches.
You’re going down. Down, down, down.
She tells her singers that they are going to die on that stage, and I wonder if she’s going to be sitting in the audience with a rifle because she is one insanely crazy BIATCH. I mean, I understand that she’s probably frustrated after hours and hours of working with these kids, but shit, that’s her fucking job, right? If she can’t handle it maybe she should be doing something else with her life.
You talking to me?
Uh, nope, no ma’am. Carry on.
Tink tells us crazy vocal coaches aren’t the only thing stressing out the auditioners. Some of them don’t know much about the Beatles at all, and one kids tells us she’s never even heard a Beatles song. WHAT?!?!?!?!?
CUT!!
Seriously, cut their asses immediately! I don’t understand how you want to be a singer and you don’t know the Beatles. Isn’t that like someone wanting to be a designer and saying they’ve never seen an outfit by Armani or Versace?
No worries, Tink has brought in Jimmy Iovine to help. After all, he did work with John Lennon.
Who?
I give up. The kids have to now perform their songs in front of Jimmy and his team of extremely bored looking music producers. This goes just as you would imagine it does. By the time Jimmy and his band of not so merry men get through with them, many of the kids have been reduced to blubbering messes.
Mission accomplished!
That’s all well and good, but now they need a pick me up. Well, we’ve got just the thing for them; Cirque de Soleil’s Beatles show! Ooooooo, ahhhhhhhh. I guess it’s a good thing they just happened to be in Vegas for this, huh?
After a quick break, it’s time to get to the singing.
Or wailing as the case may be.
Steven Tyler loves this, being a hell of a wailer himself. He is also a thief.
That’s totally my grandma’s blouse he’s wearing.
Randy and J-Lo also liked this song, but I’m not even listening to them at this point since I am a little distracted by their outfit choices today.
I need a c-oo-l. r-i-der!
Sister J-Lo, oh the time has come…..
Okay, now that I’ve gotten that out of my system, we can get back to the singing.
Pia Toscano and Karen Rodriguez actually know each other from high school. They were inseparable, singing together, performing together, fucking each other’s boyfriends…..They’re singing “Can’t Buy Me Love” while Steven howls over at the judges’ table. Of course everyone just loved it. J-Lo feels like they just get it, and Steven got a hard on so it’s all good for him.
It’s the next group’s turn and we flashback to them working with Jimmy Iovine who cautions Jacob Lusk not to oversing (translation: caterwaul) through the whole freaking song. Thank you, Jimmy. Jacob and his group have decided to keep it simple, and they succeed. It is simply awful.
Jennifer loved it; she thinks it was really great and they really made it their own. She tells them if you’re a singer you can sing anything. How would she know?
God you’re a singer, a singer sings stuff.
Stephen starts out by saying that was stup…. And just when I think he’s on the same page as I am…..he finishes. Pendous. Ugh. Stupid is the word we’re searching for here, Steven. Randy wants Jacob to put the pedal to the metal every single time. Jacob clues them in on the advice he got from Jimmy, but Randy poo poos that; bring it always! I’m sure Jacob will be thanking Randy two years from now when he has no fucking voice.
We follow this with three kids singing “Eleanor Rigby” surrounded by umbrellas. Um……okay. Next we have some old looking chick and her partner singing “Let it Be” with a gospel sort of feel to it. I’ve seen Across the Universe, and
This
Vs.
This?
No fucking contest.
No word from the judges on this one; instead we go right into some red fog and a duo sitting at facing pianos performing “Something in the Way She Moves.”

Nice. This was the first number that I actually really like so far.
Time for another break. Coming up…..
Did Randy’s egg sandwich start to kick in or is J-Lo having a breakdown?
We’ll have to wait to get that answer. Right now there’s more singing to suffer through. Next up, Divo and the Divas.

They have good voices, but I like my Beatles pure, so I’m not a fan of what they do here. Randy’s not loving it either, he thinks they can all sing but he wasn’t feeling it here. J-Lo agrees, but Steven thought they nailed it. Or maybe he wants to nail them. That’s probably it.
OH MY LORD NO. The next song up is “Blackbird”, and those of you that know me have heard me proclaim my love for this song time and time again. I consistently hate almost every “creative” version of this song, so as soon as I hear the opening chords I can feel myself go to a bad place.

But as crazy as it may sound, I actually LIKE this one. I can already tell that the guy’s voice is going to annoy the everloving shit out of me, but honestly? It works with this song. I’m in shock, I truly am. The judges all love it as well which makes me go back and listen again because obviously I must be wrong in liking it. But even after another viewing I continue to like it. I must be drunker than I thought.
After a singing montage of judges likes, we cut over to a gift shop where CrazyPants Ashley is shopping for a wedding outfit.
Unfortunately, they’re all out of formal straightjackets.
Yes, she has decided to get married while in Vegas. Not only that, they’re going to get married in the same chapel that Brittney Spears got married. Yes, that worked out so well for her, didn’t it? In the limo, CrazyPants Ashley tells her fiancé she doesn’t care if he gets cold feet; he’s going through with this no matter what. Or she’ll kill him in his sleep. And then she adds a “my precious” into the mix and I am suddenly very afraid for David.

As riveting as it is to watch the wedding of Gollum, we have things to do and dreams to crush so let’s get back to the singing, mmmkay?
Next up are Melinda Ademi and Thia Megia; two of the teeny boppers, but now more notable as the duo that vocal coach Peggi Blu lost her shit on.
I hope someone searched her for guns before letting her in.
She remains unimpressed by their rendition of “Here Comes the Sun”, and the judges seem to agree with Randy calling it interesting and Steven saying it was just alright for him.
It’s all that mean ladies fault! Wah!
Backstage, Tink is talking to CrazyPants Ashley about her wedding the night before.
Preeeecioussssssss
Um…….I think I want my mommy.
She tells Tink she hasn’t been distracted at all by her wedding; she is super ready to perform. Boy do they suck.
Steven hates it so much he gives them the finger
Preeeecioussssssss?
I think that’s gonna be a c-ya for CPA! Buh bye.
The next trio up had a hard time when Jimmy Iovine critiqued them. Basically he told them to go away and pick another song. Yikes. So they did just that, dumping “If I Fell” and switching over to “Hello Goodbye” instead. Ugh, I hate this performance.
Including the Benny Hill tribute.
The judges are not fond of it, saying that the song was just not right for them. I think they probably would have liked their original song better.
Up next are funky cold Medina and Little Dirty Bear singing “Hard Day’s Night” while jumping on a bed. Steven Tyler calls them freaks, and let’s be honest here; he would know. And then, it’s time for the last performance of this round.
What’s the deal with the giant cross?
These guys are singing “Got to Get You Into My Life” in a style that is way too boy bandy for my taste. Eh. Oh, and they also sing their own echo at the end of the song which always sounds AWESOME. Well, awesome if you cut out the esome part and add ful to it instead.
So the performances are over and I have to say I am really disappointed. Not so much in the singing itself – I knew I wasn’t going to be a fan of much of them – but I was really really hoping someone would sing “Come Together” because you just know Steven would have totally sang along with that one.
Okay, really weird confession sidebar here: I used to love watching the Sgt. Pepper movie when I was younger. You know the one with the Bee Gees and Peter Frampton? Now, now, don’t judge! Anyway, for those of you that haven’t seen it, Aerosmith performed “Come Together” in the movie and it was strangely dirty and sexy all at the same time.

I think that was the first and only time I ever thought Steven Tyler was sexy. See the power of the Beatles? Excuse me while I go take a shower.
So now it’s time to cut the herd down again. They call people up in groups and weed them out and to be frank it’s not very easy to follow because people that it looks like they’re cutting are shown later jumping up and down all happy like. Thankfully CrazyPants Ashley gets cut along with twenty other people.
But the cuts aren’t over yet. The forty remaining kids will now travel back to Hollywood, perform a solo we won’t be shown, and then told whether or not they’ve made it through to the top twenty-four. We’re going to spend the next fucking HOUR of this episode hearing the judges break the news to less than a quarter of those people. Fuuuuuuuck.
We get the opening credits again which means originally this portion was supposed to be an entirely separate episode. Lucky for me that I get to add it to the Beatles desecration I’m already recapping.
I hope they’ve done some reinforcement work on that chair.
Either that or they’re continuing their streak of cruelty and hoping that someone will break that chair and fall on their ass. Alright, I’ll admit I might give a little chuckle if that happened but I certainly won’t be hoping it happens or anything. What? Why are you all looking at me like that?
Tink tells us about the long walk to the chair that each contestant will have to take in order to hear whether they’ve made the cut to the top twenty four.
Shit, I’m getting winded just looking at that distance.
What is that, like a fucking mile or something? And now I’m imagining that walk back when you’re the one who hasn’t made the cut. Shit, I hope someone just sits their ass on the floor and refuses to do it. Make some PA in a golf cart drive over and pick you up!
The judges settle in and we’re ready for the first person of the day, Naima Adedapo. She shows up wearing a combo pageant/prom/bridesmaid dress.

You can tell that J-Lo hasn’t completely lost touch with the chola in her because she loves the outfit. We get the standard flashback sequence about her journey as well as a glimpse of her solo performance (singing “Put Your Records On”). They blather at her for a minute or two and she’s crying, but then the tears turn to happy ones because she’s going through to top twenty-four.
Naima takes a minute to cry into her lap before hugging all the judges; she adds a little extra umph for J-Lo telling her she’s loved her since those Fly Girl days.
Is it too late to cut her ass?
The judges are happy about their decision and share a little fist bump moment. I guess to celebrate how awesome they are or something.
It’s Holly Cavanagh’s turn, remember her? Sure you do, she’s the one that cried and cried and cried and J-Lo gave her a chance to sing another song if she could pull it together and it was all so suspenseful about whether or not she would stop crying and be able to sing. J-Lo reminds her that she wouldn’t even be there if she hadn’t given her another chance that day. Yes, we get it J-Lo, you’re SO WONDERFUL.
So Holly is not going through because J-Lo got outvoted by the guys. But they tell her very emphatically that they want her to come back in a couple of years. PROMISE US!! And then Holly cries.
They really need a box of tissues next to that chair.
A couple more people get the axe, and of course Cuntface Gamboa manages to make they’re getting cut all about himself.
Waaaaaahhhhhh, they’re cut and I’m still here…..it’s sooooo haaaaaard….
Ugh. I don’t think I could possibly hate this guy anymore. Oh wait, I can. He sings “Hello” for his final song and NO DOUCHENOZZLE it is not you I’m looking for! Pleasepleasepleaseplease let this guy get his ass kicked to the curb.
Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
My hatred for him is further cemented when he drops down to his knees and then sits criss cross applesauce on the ground before giving the judges all hugs. And then he drops to his knees again after going down the steps to head back to the holding area. And then a fist pump to the sky. HATE. HIM.
Here comes Hayley Reinhart.
Who hoped that flashing the judges her vag would win her at least two votes to move on.
They talk a little about how she auditioned last season and did she learn anything during her time away. She tells them she learned a lot, even though it’s only been a year. Things like showing off her vag, which worked because she’s going through as well.
Time for one of the teeny boppers, Deandre Brackensick. Oh, I like this kid; I think he’s my favorite out of the teeny bopper set. Randy tells him he should be proud that he made it to the top forty, and then talks about consistency and that they didn’t he had enough. So he’s getting cut.
SRSLY? You put in Cuntface but not me?
I feel the same way Deandre. J-Lo tries to make him feel better, saying that out of all the people they have to cut today she feels like he has a great, great chance of being a recording artist right now. She hopes that this rejection will do for him what it did for her in her day; make her work harder to prove them wrong and push harder. I am so annoyed.
He has a great attitude, saying he just wasn’t ready this year, but next year he is going to bring it.
After a quick break it’s Paul McDonald’s turn in the chair. He’s one of the “Blackbird” singing duo I enjoyed, but I don’t know that I really want to listen to his particular voice over and over and over again.
Though seeing Flipit tear apart his wardrobe choices will be LOADS of fun.
Not only did he choose to wear that hideous suit for his final solo, he also sang an original song. I honestly don’t know what to make of the song because I was entirely distracted by bouncing roses. The judges sit with him a spell, just chatting and he’s sitting there doing the whole “active listening” thing and smiling and nodding and I start to wonder if he’s really a dickwad wrapped in a charming suit.
Is that a bit of smarmy I spy?
I dunno, Gasmi, is it just me? Maybe I’ve grown too cynical and I’m starting to see things that aren’t really there. I hope I’m wrong and he’s just a nice charming guy, but I’m getting a teensy squicky right now.
Anyway, he’s made it through because the judges think he’s special and unique and they want to celebrate that. Tink plays it cool backstage and just gives him a short sharp bro-shake, but you know he’s secretly squealing on the inside.
Who me?
Ashthon Jones takes her turn in the chair and tells the judges she’s been missing them. They’ve been missing her too, and J-Lo says she’s been one of their most consistent contestant. So it really should come as no surprise to hear that she’s through to the top twenty four.
Well, no surprise to us at least.
When she goes back to where her family is waiting, she totally fakes them out before telling them she’s made it through. Bwahahahaha! That’s something my family would do. I love it.
Remember Chris Medina? You know him; Steven molested his wheelchair bound girlfriend back on audition day. Yeah, I’d say it’s a done deal that this guy makes it through, right? I mean, we all know how much Idol loves a good sob story. Oh, and he sings “Fix You” for his final solo which is so fucking pandering and puke inducing. Yep, he’s the next Gokey.
As he sits down with the judges he talks about what a great time he’s had and how his fiancé now thinks the best time of her life is when Steven kissed her on her cheek, she got to shake J-Lo’s hand, and meet Randy Jackson. Ew. Suck up! I hate this kind of crap so much because while I think it’s great that he’s chosen to stay by her side after this tragedy, any of that greatness is completely NEGATED by his obvious use of it to gain sympathy and support.
Shit, I’m surprised he didn’t wheel her ass up on stage and sing that fucking song to her when he did that last solo.
J-Lo tells him that it has been a blessing to meet him, but they are not putting him through to the next round. Wait, what? They’re not putting him through? Bwahahahahahahahaha!!! I fucking love it! Hee! Suck on that sob story boy!
Damn, I thought for sure she was going roll me right in there.
He gives them all hugs and as he leaves J-Lo starts crying about how hard that cut was and how she wanted to tell him in the right way and she doesn’t think she did it right. Randy and Steven tell her what and awesome job she is doing, but you just know she’s seeing that poor girl in a wheelchair and feeling bad about the whole thing.

She still doesn’t feel like she told him in the right way. Oh no, they tell her, she really was great and compassionate and please don’t cry, we’re no good at all when someone cries.
Wait, I don’t want my mascara to run!
J-Lo doesn’t wanna do this anymore. Oh, suck it up Buttercup. Someone show her her pay stub; I bet she’ll find the strength to carry on. Well, we’ll have to wait til tomorrow to find out if the smell of money can dry those tears because that’s it for tonight Gasmi.
What did you think? Did you enjoy the Beatles massacre? Have you heard of the Beatles? What about the results so far? Are you as annoyed as I am that Deandre got cut while Cuntface made it through? What about Medina’s cut? Were you as surprised as I am that they passed up a huge sob story?
Check back soon for DearCrabby’s recap covering the rest of the top twenty four reveal! Until then….
SWAK, PottyMouth
If you like it, spread it!:
20 Comments
That’s okay, PM. I saw the movie and Aerosmith’s “Come Together” is the only Beatle cover I’ve heard that I actually like better than the original. Primarily BECAUSE Aerosmith is just such a band of freaks that they’re innate filthiness just brought a whole new, sexy level to that song.
Which leads me to the anemic “Got To Get You Into My Life.” Which was covered by Earth, Wind & Fire in the movie. Changing it to R&B can be successful, but not by three dinks auditioning for AI.
They cut the goldilocks guy because with him there, there’d be no competition: he’d win hands down, just on looks alone. And it wouldn’t matter at all what anyone else did. Millions upon millions of young and not so young teenyboppers would be wetting their panties in order to vote for him.
I like it that they kept the Karoake Douchebag. Hope he’s a VFTW pick.
Oh yeah, and I really like J-lo. In fact, I kind of like Tyler too. And Randy’s not annoying at all anymore. It’s a great thing that Simon left, isn’t it? Not only that, now that Simon’s gone, they seem to have made a truly sincere effort to find people who can sing. I mena, I realize it’s American Idol and all, but some of these people really truly can sing.
I know, after initially trying to be the “Simon” either Randy realized or the producers told him that they don’t really want a Simon anymore. I like pissing on people’s delusional dreams as much as the next person, but I’d rather be the cynical one, not the show.
I always think there are two types that get put through, though. The possibles and the cannon fodders. They don’t want 24 people with genuine shots at winning (looks or talent) so they pick people like the karaoke dude to get canned in the semis so he can’t come back next year, either. Goldilocks is only 16 and if he was inconsistent, they’d want him around next year when he’s gotten more used to singing in his big boy voice, and maybe looks less like a girl. That only works on RuPaul’s Drag Race. Put him through now, and he could go early.
As for Paul McDonald…I say, if you’re going to wear a Gram Parsons suit, you have to sing a Gram Parsons song, dammit. Otherwise you look foolish. But I’m going with a 75/25 split on nice guy to smarm. He does sing like Kenny Loggins and has the beard to boot so he’s not smarm free, but he seemed nice enough.
I’m sure JLo was legitimately upset cause of the kid’s sob story, but I still the crying made it look like it was all about her. Then, Seacrest actually voices over that we’ll have to see if she has the STRENGTH to make it through?? Seriously?! She has a contract. I’m sure she’ll be able to continue in order not to get sued. But I do have to admit I like her more than ever. This was a great plan for her to come across as not-a-total-bitch, while still being diva-ish.
I like Lauren and the guy with the weird little voice. That rendition of Blackbird was one of the best I’ve ever heard. I’m not totally shocked that the 15 year olds don’t know who the Beatles are. They were born in 1995 for pete’s sake. And it’s not like they’re that popular in ethnic households (this is a generalization, so please don’t rain the wrath of the internet troll upon me). So a young black person could conceivably not have ever heard a Beatles song. Or just not have known that’s who was singing that jingle on their tv.
I never agree with the judges on reality shows. I think they passed on some good people and let in some goofy ones. Grandma glasses? No. Churchy wailing Black Guy? No. But hopefully they’ll be gone pretty soon. I do think they did have a shit ton of talent this season. All I listen to is the singing anyway. I FF through all of that stupid backstory crap. Do. Not. Care. Thank you, TiVo!!
My favorite is Scotty. Love him. Like, waiting-for-him-to-turn-18 love him! (Apparently JLo does too!!) I might actually vote for the first time ever just to keep him on.
Have these kids not watched every past season and seen Beatles week? How could they not be prepared? You’d think every contestant would have Beatles, Michael Jackson, Neil Sedaka, and Barry Manilow songs in their back pockets.
I am really enjoying this season. There is much more focus on the good singers and decent human beings. I always hated the crazy divas, queens and self-important jackasses that got so much air time in the past seasons. I am surprisingly impressed with the judges and how they are making this all about the singers, not themselves. I really think the producers made too much of J-Lo’s “breakdown.” I mean, who wasn’t crying after that elimination? Well, probably not many Gasmii, I guess! And thank God we don’t have to suffer Simon’s and Tink’s playful bickering anymore!!!
Oh yeah, and I’m pissed that 2 of my favs, John Wayne and Caleb, were cut. Booooo!
Great recap, PM!
Boo!! Why in hell did they let all the male eye-candy go? Last year I had Timmy Urban and Alex Lambert (for awhile, anyway) to have jailbait fantasies over. I was looking forward to viewing Golden Boy Deandre and his long, lovely blond curls; Colton Dixon, another Bible boy to deprogram; Marion Morrison Schwartz, the croonin’ cowboy; Caleb Hawley (I think that’s his name) and his dark curls; and maniacal-looking imp, Carson Higgins. Crap! Now all that’s left is bores or oddballs. How could they pass through talentless meany, A-hole Jordan Dorsey?
The chicks I really don’t care about at all. They’re all dull and sound the same. So many of the contestants really effed up but still made it to the next round. The judges are always so vehement about not messing up the words, yet some of the worst offenders got through. I think a lot of them got the pass for kissing Jennifer’s comely ass. I am thankful that we’re FINALLY done with 50-year-old drug addict Ashley. The producers were probably very disappointed that she didn’t try to kill herself or hold the judges hostage when she was given the boot. I guess her sham of a wedding tamed her down. Her poor, poor husband. Maybe she threatened to kill herself or him if he didn’t go through with it.
Kudos to the judges, though, for letting MexiGokey II go. J-Lo needn’t have cried so hard. He was on Jay Leno last night, singing his new self-scribed sob ditty. So somebody took pity on him and he now has a record deal. If he’s lucky and it sells, he can go on tour while somebody else takes care of his fiancee.
I suppose I was fortunate that our local LA Fox channel conked out for about 30 minutes. I didn’t get to hear most of the Beatle tunes mangled. The black kids may have a bit of an excuse for never hearing the Beatles, but the white ones do not. My nephews and niece, who were born in the mid to late 90s, have loved the Beatles since they were small children. I have no idea if they’re familiar with Aretha Franklin or Smokey Robinson, but I agree that if you’re going to be a singer, you should study up on those who have gone before you. That said, I’d be willing to guess that Scotty Baby LockThemDoors does know who Johnny Cash is. If he doesn’t, he should.
I agree with you on pretty much everything, Pottymouth (well, the parts that I can remember…a lot of those people were pretty darn forgetable). Fortunately I’m not a huge Beatle’s fan (I know it’s blasphemy, but…) or I would have been even more annoyed by the mostly horrible renditions of the Beatles songs. I was so annoyed that they let Fake Glasses Guy through, but I had a feeling they didn’t want to pass up on the drama/controversy his overly inflated ego would bring. It’s certainly not because of his talent. The guy has a passable voice but he always looks and sounds like he’s passing a kidney stone when he sings. I think he graduated from the Jessica Simpson School of Vocal Styling. I was shocked they didn’t put Medina and his sob story through. I didn’t hate him (although it annoyed me that he really seemed to exploit his girlfriend’s condition) but I don’t think he was that talented. Ashley’s cut was another pleasant surprise.
Right now my favourite is Naima. Ashton might be good but there was something about her reaction taht was insincere to me. She had to know that she had as good a chance as any and better than most of making it through. And how the hell do you grow up anywhere in the English speaking world and never have heard a Beatle’s song? Sheesh!
I like Steven & J-Lo as judges. They are much better than Ellen & Kara (who I detested). I’m thinking Cuntface will be the VFTW pick so that’s where my votes will go. I like Scotty’s deep voice. It will be interesting to hear him sing other genres. I think the reason they cut MexiGokey-Medina is because his “fiance’s” mother wasn’t having anymore of parading her daughter around in a wheel chair for AI. She blogged that she didn’t know her daughter was going to be on tv during the auditions. When the girl realized she’d been on tv she slapped herself repeatedly out of anger. Medina’s whole devotion is questionable anyway because he was supposed to marry her exactly 2 years after proposing and that was 4 years ago. He sounded like shit on Leno.
Another thing, I also like the guy who looks like a Black Casper the Friendly Ghost. His voice sounds just like the singer in Antony and the Johnsons. If he can rein in the diva, he’ll be fun to watch.
Much better than the headband-wearing squinty screamer guy. Although he seems to be the only rock(ish) singer this season.
Oh yeah, and the deep-voiced kid? Right now he’s a one-trick pony. There’s no way he should be sticking around. He’s another one they should have thrown back in the pond and come back to a couple years later. His Beatles singing was simply terrible.
Gilty Plezzur…Chris Medina’s new single was written for him by Rodney Jerkins. (Just clarifying that it wasn’t “selfpenned.”)
I would like to know why there was “only room for one country guy,” as Ryan said on the voiceover. Country music fans are legion, and country music does plenty of cross-over (as evidenced by Carrie Underwood, a former contestant, and Shania Twain, a former mentor,) so it would seem country should get a better representation than only 1/24 of the contestants. Although I’m not a huge country fan, I would prefer that over the endless overblown runs that too many of the contestants inflict on us. Boooooo that they cut John Wayne.
I think Ryan’s intro was likely written and recorded after the cuts so at that time they knew only one country singer got through. Plus, the show really is more about finding a pop star. Carrie was a special case but even her country songs are more country pop. I can see why they wouldn’t cast more than one traditional country singer.
Scotty is straight up Randy Travis with no subtlety since he only knows one song. He makes the big first impression and sailed in on that, but since we didn’t see most of John Wayne’s performances, maybe he really was more inconsistent. Or maybe they thought he couldn’t be marketed like “the kid with the deep voice” could.
But I’m hoping crazy Casey Abrams was able to perform because I think he and Julie Zorrilla are my favorites. Naima was good, too, but I like the kids who can actually play instruments as well as sing.
Good Lord, somebody else wrote that thing for MexiGokey II? Oh, Jennifer, such wasted tears. He’s already getting better promotion than any of the truly talented ones. I waded through the video of the song, which is mediocre at best, and cringed. I really feel for his fiancee. She was so pretty and it is a tragedy, but Jeezuss, what an exploitive piece of pap. I couldn’t do that to a loved one. I’d try to find some more dignified way to help them out.
The “Black Casper the Friendly Ghost?” I believe the correct term we are using these days is Affable African American Apparition.
I have to admit my Beatles ignorance here. I can’t help it..I was raised in an ethnic household! Wah! Before this show, the only title I could name AND recognize on the radio was Yellow Submarine. Now, I know the “All We Need Is Love”, which I’ve heard a billion times and just never cared to ask who sung it. Of course, watching the idol hopefuls sing them will not help my case. When I do come across the actual Beatles version, I’ll most likely not recognize it. However, the song Blackbirds (first time i’ve ever heard it was by the AI duo) and it sounded great. I really like the guys voice. I’m partial to that style as my fav vocalist/leads (Florence Welch, The Cranberries, Evanescence, Alanis) all have that quirky yodel-y style..well not so much Evanescence but damn, girl has some pipes!
I’m sure I’ve been exposed to Beatles originals via yogurt commercials and the like but haven’t made the connection. However, when my guy was visiting me from Scotland, I took him to the Dakota to see where John Lennon lived and died and then onto to Strawberry Fields, to see Yoko’s tribute. So..I guess I know my history a bit better than my music.
So far, I like Naima..she has a great voice and I love her neo-soul style. I dressed similarly for years and it’s so flattering for many body types, adds a regality, and in a sea of mini skirts and hair extensions, it’s great to stand out for just being yourself.
Hmmm – I suspect CrazyPants Ashley is the same person as that “Leave Brittney Alone!!” person on YouTube? I have never seen them both in the same place … have you? I really will miss her Crazyness : (
I cut the Cripple Wife Guy some slack, because his hospital/therapy bills must be astronomical, and if exploiting her tragedy will result in being able to give her superior care and treatment, then I’m all for it.
This is the huge difference between him and Gokey — his gal’s still alive and needs help right now.
That said, I think the least Idol and its uber-wealthy stars could do, after exploiting her story for their own profit, is to chip and help out. Idol generates MILLIONS and MILLIONS of dollars. Surely they could do more than just exploit this girl.
I found it interesting they cut him. Granted, he looks like a schlub, but his voice is on par with most of the guys they kept. But this season at least they seem to be going out of their way to eliminate all the sob stories. Unless you count Squinty the King of Pirates.
Also, this show and the one that followed it would have been a lot more interesting if it hadn’t become clear early on that pretty much the only people they featured chatting with the judges were the ones that got in.
itchy…I couldn’t agree with you more on the Idol pitching in to help.
Also…Squinty the King of Pirates is the best nickname for Autistic Tourette’s Boy that I’ve heard so far. Could someone please explain his tail?
So has anyone said already that Cuntface Gamboa looks allot like Alvin from Alvin and the chipmunks, when he’s wearing his glasses? I totally see Alvin in him!! Especially that picture of him with his hands in the Air!! I would love it if they gave him the Oh Eh Ooh Ah Ah song!! ROTFL!
The “Black Casper the Friendly Ghost?” I believe the correct term we are using these days is Affable African American Apparition.
OMFG sarcasatire thanks for the laugh!