American Idol: When In Doubt, Sing Veeeery Slooooowly

American Idol

By Flipit | | 2:10 am | 20 Comments

Tonight on American Idol, Skara says things that I knida agree with two times, most of the girls blow chunks, and OrganiJoplin lives!!

201003040147

It’s nights like this you wonder how this girl didn’t get on the show.

Tink must be in the doghouse for something cuz they open him up in minority lighting.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.12.53 Pm

Now you know how black people feel.

There was a time when girls couldn’t show their ankles. Then knees were exposed and it was a huge deal. Then shit went crazy and people started showing their shoulders! How we’re all not walking around in underwear by now is completely beyond me. Point is, as a parent, where do you draw the line? Cleavage, apparently.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.16.11 Pm

Just because “blower” is in my job title doesn’t make me your whore, America!! I will only wear sexy dresses with t-shirts underneath!

I don’t know what she’s playing at with that outfit, but we should all just be thankful she’s not wearing jorts. After introducing the contestants, Tink pulls Bowersox/OrganiJoplin aside to welcome her back from the hospital. She says she’s a fighter, but doesn’t say what she’s fighting against. I love a medical mystery!! She could have licked a penny as a kid and is now just suffering from the copper poisoning! Or maybe a paint chip fell into her mouth while she was sleeping and she got lead poisoning! Or maybe she was pregnant and didn’t even know it and now there’s a mystery baby at the Free Clinic wondering when she’s gonna come pick his ass up. Who knows? She’s a hundred times more interesting now, though.

Let’s say hey to the judges!! Happy valentines! I know you’re on a diet so instead of edible chocolates I got you a big black man in a Mr. Rogers sweater! You’re welcome.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.20.58 Pm

Here’s to a sex free Valentines day! Down with chlamydia!



Ellen has gotten rid of her Boy Scouts uniform in favor of this captain’s uniform from Boat Trip. I hope she comes up with a new costume to showcase her lesbianism every episode, cuz it’s getting fun.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.22.20 Pm

For results she’s gonna show up as a softball umpire.

Skara doesn’t have any gayness to showcase, so instead she shows off her receding hairline. Premature female baldness isn’t going to come in fashion, Skar. Stop trying.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.24.04 Pm

You want to steal Simon’s shots? Two can play at that game!!

Could Skara get any further away from Ellen? It’s rude. Simon is a super cheapo t-shirt tonight, but at least he’s showing off his burnt chicken skinned moobs. Is it wrong that this shot makes me hungry?

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.25.57 Pm

If it wasn’t for that desperate growth on your arm I’d get a side of ranch dressing and lube you up real good.

Randy, rate the guys! Hot! Fire in their eyes! In it to win it! What dat be! Ellen, how important is song choice on the big seas? She tells a story about singing “Who Let the Dogs Out” at her Nana’s funeral. Ouch. That one tanked hard. Really, Ellen? I know you have a lot of jokes to come up with in one day with two jobs and all, but wow. Now Tink does an impression of when he first met Teri Hatcher at a karaoke party at Marc Cherry’s house.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.31.52 Pm

You’re so pretty! What? I can’t hear you! Bend down! You look like a really pretty rubber skeleton! Let’s make out when we’re drunk! What? Oh! I’m singing “I Honestly Love You!” How bout you! Yes! I’d love a cosmo it’s my fave drink! Put it in a sippy cup though!



Tink asks Skara why she’s so far up Simon’s ass this year. She tries to change the subject by saying that he’s rolling his eyes less. “You want me, don’t you?” Simon drawls. “There’s a lot of competition this year from all the boys.” First off, ew. Second, if Skara’s husband hasn’t divorced her by the end of the season he’s one giant pussy. Tink ignores her idiocy and moves on to Simon since he knows Skar will be in the shot anyway. Simon says the girls shouldn’t forget the words. Then he punches out and goes to a check cashing place to see how much they charge to cash a thirty million dollar check.

OrganiJoplin is up first. She shows off a baby picture, and she has a twin!! She’s also had giant bags under her eyes since she was tiny. Drug addiction starts young, people. Watch your kids!

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.39.24 Pm

Benicio del Joplin

She’s very different from her brother. He’s a square, which is a nice way of saying he didn’t get pregnant as a teenager, he washes his hair, and he has a job. She tells us about little trinkets she’s collected over the years from people who didn’t have change on them while she panhandled. Bottle caps, gum wrappers, little notes that say “get a job you lazy bitch.” Hey! I think that one was from me! I won’t give you change, but advice is freeeeeee!!!

Last week, Simon told her he could hear her performance outside any subway station in the country. Well what a coincidence! She used to perform on the subways all the time. I’ll pause while you guys get over your shock. You done? I hope every week Simon gives criticism that relates to homelessness so we get more backstory. “That song sounded like you pulled it out of the dumpster.” “Coinky! I used to make five course meals out of shit from the dumpster!”

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.46.22 Pm

I lost my first tooth from biting into half a Snickers Bar that froze in the winter trash.

Tonight, she’s singing CCR’s “See the Light” and she’s doing it gospel style. She’s out to prove that she can make Simon stop and listen on the subway. Not that he takes the subway. We get a shot of his trailer. Idol Gives Back my cornhole. That thing costs more than all the kids in Haiti and Chile combined.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.48.28 Pm

Don’t worry kids. Dora the Explorer mosquito nets are on their way.

Tink makes fun of Simon’s giant trailer, but the site of it has given Skara a labia boner.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.50.04 Pm

Labboner



OrganiJoplin starts by wailing to an organ and sounds great. She can sing the blues, which is no shocker. It’s kind of the same performance as last week with a much better song. She doesn’t make one mistake in this song and kicks its ass. I didn’t feel anything, but that’s my fault cuz I refuse therapy. She’s gonna need to innovate if she wants America to keep her though. Like the shamwow guy. Randy loved it, Ellen is glad she’s not dead, Skara says it was a complete recovery from last week. And…yesterday? I don’t even think Skara knows that she’s being witty. Simon drinks some Captain Morgan’s from his coke cup and says that she was legitimately ill and chose to sing well instead of using the sympathy card. He underestimated her and even says she’s like Kelly Clarkson. Shot of her family. Aw, uniform crinkly eyes!!

Organi tells Tink she didn’t think she’d be alive this week. Simon’s complimented her so she’s totes safe to play the sympathy card now. At least she didn’t bring up singing in church. God deserves a break.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 8.56.06 Pm

This family knows how to wear stripes. Take note, Randy. They’re really five hundred pounds.

Haley Vaughn is next. She’s nervous, but not so nervous that she can’t smile big. It took a lot of guts to steal that poinsettia out of the lobby and tape it to her head, so let’s give her some credit.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 9.00.39 Pm

She sang Beatles last weak and this week she’s youthing it up with Miley Cyrus. aslpdigw[aorighasl[gbnagago[gwoi “Ith tho excthiting to have funth!” Ugh. Take out your mouth guard. Your teeth won’t all smoosh together if you break the rules for three seconds. Poor girl probably wonders why no one invites her to lunch. It’s cuz they don’t want little bits of your salad all over their faces. She admits to Tink that in real life she’s thuper inthecure. Aw. I hope no one sends her a link to this blog. It’s all for fun, little one! No, don’t answer I don’t have enough paper towels to converse with you right now. Shhh. Let’s just hug.

In her video package she tells us that her hobby is making her own headbands. Ya don’t say! There she sits all cutely with her Elmer’s glue. Have you guys been to Etsy.com? Don’t waste your time. Go to Regretsy.com instead. It’s hilarious, and I have a feeling we might see our girl there in no time. She let Green Mile try on one of her headbands, and it makes him look like Macy Gray in Idlewild.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 9.06.50 Pm

I don’t remember this, but Haeleyeleyeth says that all of the judges were nice to her last week except Simon, who called her a wind up doll. She’s totes happy and bubbly all the time you guys. This is her trying to make a mean face.

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 11.42.16 Pm

You’re still and yet there is spit all over my screen.



She just CAN’T. NOT. SMILE. People who smile that much are usually super evil serial killers. She’s singing “The Climb”, and when she starts I’m so happy I’m not actually watching Miley Cyrus that I’m cheering. She stays on key, even through her first belt section. By the time the chorus comes, though, she’s all smiles and lisps and I long for Miles. If you make me wish I was listening to Miley instead of you….well, it should be punishable by death. On this show, there’s always the issue of people who can really sing and can’t choose the right songs, and then there are the people who can’t sing but they can really perform. This girl? Can’t do either. That was one hundred percent pain. WHY IS SHE HERE?

It didn’t work for Randy, and he even uses the word excruciating. The biggest shocker is that he knows that word. Ellen says Haeleyee has a great smile, which is equal to Paula’s “pretty dress.” Hey you guys, Haeleyeyeee does know how to not smile!!

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 11.47.12 Pm

Glad you learned something from your time here.

Skara rubs up on Simon a lot and says that Vowel has a lot of people rooting for her even though she can’t sing. Simon doesn’t want to make it even more painful, so he just calls it a mess. Then he does make it more painful and says “there’s an irony about you singing a song about climbing when you fell off.” LOL. Tink says “what good did that do?” Tink has spent too much time in the toaster today and he’s very grouchy. I wonder when it’s gonna be popular for people to just be pasty again. Probably when I start tanning. Bastards.

Who beat Girl Gayken upside the head?!?!

Screen Shot 2010-03-03 At 11.55.20 Pm

If this hair doesn’t distract you from my shitty vocals, nothing will.

Tink asks Gayken how the schedule shift worked out and she says it was good for her cuz she had more time to plan on how horribly she was gonna mangle tonight’s song. In her video, she says that she likes to refurbish antiques. Way to drum up the interest, there, kid. Her mom told her she was here to be a star so she’s gonna do it!! She blames her hideous performance last week on nerves and says this week she’s gonna do a song that Skara recommended so the judges can’t bitch. Oh, they still will. They don’t remember what they said two seconds ago.

The thing about this girl is that it sounds like she can probably sing really well but can’t quite get it together on stage. Does that make sense? She seems a lot more confident today, if the hair is any indication. She’s a half note flat through the whole song, and all I wanna do right now is burn antiques. Randy’s like uh…no. He blames Skara for the song. LOL. He says she brought nothing new to it. Ellen thought it was “adorable.” That’s what she said to Tim Urban about a million times last week, so in other words “wow you’re cute in pictures.” Skara compliments her own song choice for showing off her tone, but says she needs to push harder. Simon looks off into the distance like he’s watching a giant clock. He says it was marginally better but compared to OrganiJoplin she’s an asshole and should be turned into sausage. Gayken doesn’t get it, and she never will.

Katie’s next! Her friends in high school think she’s awesome cuz she’s on American Idol!! She’ll be trying to act more youthful this week, too! What we don’t know about her is that she can ask for a kiss in six languages. Damn, ho! I didn’t see the slut factor happening. She’s lucky her grandmother won’t remember she said that in the morning. Before she performs she jumps up and down and calls herself awesome like that girl from the first audition. LOL. But does your stomach hit your chin when you do it ? NO. FAIL. She’s singing that “Put Your Records On” song, which has tortured me in Starbucks ever since it came out. Katie is so dorky and awkward that I am always surprised when she opens her mouth cuz she can actually sing. She has a deep, country-ish voice, and it’s lovely. Unfortunately, she’s as exciting as an eye boogar forming in the corner of your eye.

Screen Shot 2010-03-04 At 12.15.48 Am

Do you feel it forming?

She’s goodish through the whole song and her last note is high and lovely, but still I pause the tv just to throw spit wads at the target on her forehead.

Screen Shot 2010-03-04 At 12.17.42 Am

Randy thinks that the bright moments were her high notes but she was mostly boring. Ellen thinks she’s still too old and needs to get younger. She doesn’t want to hear dentist office music. The crowd boos Ellen and Katie says “it’s ok guys”. Thanks for your permission, foreign people maker outer. Skara says a lot but I can’t listen cuz she sounds like a toilet flushing. Simon? Bored. Katie tells Tink that to be younger she’s gonna research and look up stuff. LOL. How To Be Younger: Retin A, Fish Oil Pills, New Face, New Boobs, Lots of Masturbation. Tink asks her if she likes Justin Beiber. LOLOLLL. Tink needs to get some. From someone not old enough to grow hair around their wiener, from the sound of it.

Screen Shot 2010-03-04 At 12.22.45 Am

You had your turn, Joplin!

DoDo is next. She keeps wiping her nose like a coke head, but insists that she’s just nervous cuz she’s nervous. OK then. You should have an autobiography. She was the mascot in high school. What kind of high school has the Blair Witch as their mascot?

201003040029

This is sick.



Pre performances, she prays and meows as a vocal warmup before pooping on gravel in the greenroom. She looked up the word “indulgent” after Simon called her that last week to “look into the context”. Wow. She read the definition and still doesn’t get it. I look forward to giving her money for my slurpee at the Hollywood 7-11. What a twit. She’s gonna do “Lean on Me.” Darn. My guess was wrong. I thought she was gonna do a song from an iPhone commercial. You know the one that sounds like a five year old singing? I guess that’s all of them.

Anyway, she’s really changing the song up. The people in charge of stage lighting are doing their best to point out how vomitous her outfit is tonight, and for that I love them.

Skitched-20100304-003317

Take a hint, lady.

She hits more notes than she did last week, but she misses a lot too. This week she adds some belt action into it and it’s a huge improvement. Singing so loudly, it’s harder for her to imitate some drunk singer on the top of the Indie charts, and it works. She sounds mostly good!! But damn when she’s off she’s really off. I know a lot of you don’t like that I compare her to CawCaw from last year, but to me they’re the same beings. Dumb pretty girls with talent but not enough brains to figure out how to use it. Another boring ass performance. Randy hated the song choice cuz it was too soulful. Ellen loves her voice but wasn’t into the song choice. Skara says flat out “it wasn’t good.” She keeps talking, and seriously she needs to stop talking. Simon congratulates DoDo for continuing the cat theme through the song. BWHAHAHA. She had an opportunity to sing and wasted it on a lame song. She cries. Tink tells her to turn it into lemonade, and she doesn’t even have the strength to ask who gave the lemon AIDS in the first place.

Michelle is next. Tink asks her how confusing the judges are, and she answers that the judges are super important. Kiss ass!! She’s gonna take a risk today by singing “Arms Wide Open” by Creed. In her video, she tells us that she’s a kids choir director at church. She says kids are so raw and real that she wants to be like that. She prays and meditates before shows so she can plan out exactly what she wants to happen on the stage. So another piece of evidence that prayer doesn’t work. I still have faith dammit!! I get that she’s trying to be positive and stuff, but all I can see is a girl who’s hiked up her skirt to pee in an alley.

201003040043

That’s illegal, you know.

The song is an interesting choice, and she has a nice voice. Not really buying it, but she hasn’t bored me into a near coma so I predict that she will win the night, cuz that’s saying a lot for this crew. She falls a bit in the belt section. And when I say a bit I mean on her face. She looks like she’s singing well, but the girl doesn’t have a lot of power. If you can’t belt? DON’T. The first half was pretty, the second half blew. Randy likes her skirt, but she did nothing with the song. Ellen thinks that she did do a lot with the song and gives her credit for almost being good. Skara says it was her favorite performance of Michelle’s cuz it was at least believable and she has a good attitude. Huh? They’ve all had a good attitude. How was that any better than anyone else tonight? She couldn’t sing half of it! Simon agrees with Skara and admits to giving contradictory advice and says that she got a solid b. Then he asks Vera Wang if she liked it!! HOLLER! VERA!! Wait. Why are they showing Lisa Bonet from ten years ago? I don’t get it.

201003040049

Simon points out that Randy is in a shitty mood, but Randy says he likes the Wang dress and Michelle should stay. Unless she plans on not wearing skirts that looks like they’re being pulled off of her. Then she can leave. Lilly is next, and she tells us that the coaches have been teaching her how to have charisma, which means staring into the camera a lot.

Screen Shot 2010-03-04 At 12.52.05 AmPhyllis

I see your future, and it involves lots of dick jokes.

In her video, Lilly tells us about all the instruments she plays. She can even fart with her arm pits! She also uses throat spray. I’m really glad this show is two hours. She’s singing “A Change is Gonna Come” and she’s gonna do it with a twelve string guitar. She’s another one who sounds like she’s imitating Yael Naim to me, but people seem to be into that sort of thing this year. Her look is unique, and it’s cool that she can play instruments, but her voice sounds like millions of other imitations. When she belts she goes way off and squeezes it out of her nose and throat so hard I can’t believe snot didn’t pop out. By the end, she’s shaky and in a completely different key than the song. Simon watched these rehearsals and still said the girls are better than the boys? Sorry, but no. And hey! VERA WANG IS WHITE!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? How has an Asian person not sued her yet? This is like when that dude lied about being an addict in a book and had to go on TV to say sorry to book club readers.

201003040059

You owe Oprah an apology, lady.



Randy says this season has the most unique contestants ever. That’s like calling one gallon of milk whiter than another. Randy loved it and calls it his fave of the night. Ellen says Lilly has “it”. Chicken pox? ADD? WHAT? Skara loved it too and says Lilly had a “moment”. Seriously you guys? What’d I miss? Simon says that she’s relevant. He needs to stop using that word. It just doesn’t sound right on a show about manufacturing crappy pop stars on purpose. He wasn’t crazy about it and says she oversang it a bit. He finishes by saying OrganiJoplin was better. Slam. Well, I’m confused. Stiffler’s Mom is next, and she’s like an updated Long John’s Silver employee tonight.

201003040105

She tells Tink that she’s not planning on being “super epic”. I can’t wait til she does decide to go super epic. Whip out some Dances With Wolves on our asses. We don’t know that she was studying to be a recording engineer and before she performs she likes to goof off cuz if you’re not ready you’re not ready. She came back as way less of a ho today to please Skara, She’s singing “The Scientist” by Coldplay and she’s gonna play the piano to boot! I think she’s got the strongest voice so far, even when she misses a couple notes. She seems a bit confused having to play and sing at the same time, cuz she’s going super slow. The song sounds like it’s trying to make it out of a pit of oatmeal. That said, her vocals are great and I love the faces she makes.

201003040110

She blows a little riff, but she’s making me feel it and I’m kinda in love with her right now. Maybe it’s cuz she was preceded by such snorers, or maybe it’s cuz she’s making sneeze face for me.

201003040112

Cover your mouth!



One thing she’s got over the rest is that the girl knows how to feel it. Randy liked it even though it was too slow and she missed some notes. Ellen liked the guitar. LOL. Ellen was so bored she almost fell asleep cuz it was so slow. She said if she was a babysitter the baby would be asleep. We have been waiting for Skara to turn into the new Paula, but the way Ellen’s going it might be her. She makes less sense every time she opens her mouth. Skara says “I kinda love you”. Wait. We agree! I have to go change all my opinions now. Skara says she’s all over the place but good at all the different styles she sings. Simon didn’t understand what Skara said and then says Stiffler’s Mom was good but she gets corny when she performs but it was a million times better than last week. I thought she was the best last week too so I’m out in the cold here. LOVE HER.

Paige is next and has cotton mouth cuz she’s a stoner. Wasn’t it just commercial break? She’s the type to have to pull over and pee right when you leave the truck stop. We will never drive to Disneyland together. She tells us in her video that she likes to color. Um…..I’m just gonna move on. I can see why she usually wears colored contacts, cuz without them she looks like Sheri Shephard.

201003040118

Elizabeth is right, y’all!



She got the most compliments last week, so she’s gonna sing Kelly Clarkson tonight. Snapple: Too Confident Too Quick Flavor. It’s so exciting that Simon starts pulling cheese out of his flip flopped toe.

201003040120

He’s so got a Scrabble game going on under there.

She sings the song to the same arrangement on the radio. She has a nice voice, but she’s no Kelly and proves it when she reaches for the high notes and cracks on all of them. The belt is better, but then she has more high notes. Ouch. Her vibrato’s so damn fast. She sounds like a baby who’s crying so hard it’s shaking and has throw up coming down her face. Skara wrote that song? Wow. That’s actually one I like. Ok this is the second time in one night I’ve like Skara. This needs to end. Randy didn’t think the song choice was good for her and then kinda makes fun of the song. LOL. Ellen loved it. Skara thinks she could have a hit with her great song, but the song was written about a terrible relationship and there were no smiles there so she shouldn’t be smiling so much. Then Paige smiles big. Simon thinks she chose the wrong song two weeks in a row and she’s getting lost in her choices. His advice is to nail it next time if she’s not booted and sent home with a coloring book that Skara wrote.

Siobhan is last, and very slowly says that her plan is to not think too hard. She tells us that she used to have a mohawk. She describes how she gave herself the cut, and she’s cute and funny. Then she does lip trills for warmups while pointing at her nose. This girl’s a kook. I love her super slow speech pattern. She’s like Rain Man played by Geena Davis. She’s singing Aretha’s “Think” tonight. That’s some balls. She does it like the original, which isn’t wise. She gets a little shrill at parts, but her voice really shines as she starts belting it out. Still, why are you singing this song, cracker? Aretha could eat you for breakfast, and she would if she could still fit out the door of the house to come out. The high yell at the end is hilarious, and she actually nails it!! Wow. I didn’t see that coming.

201003040131

You’re just a snack pack to Aretha girl. You better step off.

She was so good last week. She didn’t suck this week, but she definitely wasn’t as interesting. The audience goes crazy for her, and that’s the first time that’s happened since OrganiJoplin went. Randy gives her credit for kicking ass on an Aretha song. Ellen loved it too and compares her to a Snuggie. HAHAH. Weird but awesome. Skara thinks that she must hit high notes cuz she’s a glass blower. Sio says she learned to scream like that from Kelly Clarkson in the shower. Ellen looks jealous. Simon says that she’s a weirdo and parts of the song sucked but that note was incredible and he’s happy that she’s interesting. Simon wants to be ruder, but he can’t stop smiling.

201003040134

So, another full on lackluster night. I liked Sio and slow ass Stiffler’s Mom the best tonight. I could have done without the others. OrganiJop can sing, but I just can’t stand panhandlers. What do you think? See you this weekend for resluts!

My bets: Heaaeleeye, Girl Gayken, Jermaine and Long Duck John are out. They should rest easy though, cuz I am always wrong about this stuff.

Flipit
About

Currently, Flipit's writing Real Housewives of Beverly Hills recaps, which you can find here. You can also find him doing a gossip segment twice a week called BS of the Day and video recaps of Project Runway All Stars, as well as spoof ReDubs of the coming soon trailers at the end of RHOBH!

Ronnie Karam has been with TVgasm since 2006 , which has given him the opportunity to make fun of hundreds of TV's most loved and hated reality whores. His plan in life was to be Julia Roberts but that plan was stolen by, well, Julia Roberts. He'll get you one day, JULIA ROBERTS!! When not making himself giggle for the gasm, Ronnie performs improv and sketch comedy at IO West in Hollywood a couple of times weekly while using the lovely California days to audition for commercial roles such as "ADORABLE MEXICAN UNCLE". Seriously. He would like to thank Jesus, Buddha and Xenu for the blessings they've bestowed. The writers here are the best around, and he's honored to be associated with them. Find video archives at CankleTV.com, or follow on Twitter @flipit

20 Comments

  1. 1
    Krispydixie
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 2:49 am

    Thank you for getting me through the rest of my work day! Love your recaps! i stopped watching Idol like two seasons ago, but I love to read ur take on it :)

    the last screen shot of Tinks on the first page was EPIC!

    Please don’t ever leave us!

  2. 2
    TheMiki themiki
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 3:01 am

    Am I nuts, or does Lilly look an awful lot like Tina Youthers? And does the fact that I know what Tina Youthers looks like make me really really old?

    Wonderful recap. Way to distract me from writing my essay on women artists in the Renaissance. My teacher gets mad when I write papers like a snarky sarcastic asshole, so I have to take a snark break every few hundred words or I fall asleep. This was perfect.

  3. 3
    Cherie
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 5:03 am

    “Ugh. Take out your mouth guard. Your teeth won’t all smoosh together if you break the rules for three seconds. Poor girl probably wonders why no one invites her to lunch. It’s cuz they don’t want little bits of your salad all over their faces.”

    Ha! And I was worried about calling someone a cunt this week! LOL you crack me up Swami Flipit!

  4. 4
    abaumga2
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 5:44 am

    Bowersox has Diabetes, and that is what caused her medical crisis this week.

  5. 5
    cansnuts
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 6:39 am

    Great recap as always. Again I liked Didi and was wondering why they were so harsh on her. Loved Crystal and Katelynn Epperley tonight. Hope you are correct in your predictions for who goes (though for the guys I would like to swap out Fraudrick for John Park if possible, but I wouldn’t care if John was the one).

  6. 6
    Sher
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 7:14 am

    Great recap as always, Flipit. :)

    I liked Crystal and Sio The Weirdo and that was it. I am pissed off at Lilly and Katelyn for singing two of my favorite songs ever, because I think they both sucked. Hated Stiffler’s Mom’s version of “The Scientist”, hated Lilly trying to sing Sam Cooke. EW.

    @themiki: YES. Lilly totally looks like Tina Yothers! Ha! If noticing that makes you old, then I’m right there with you.

    Sometimes I wish they did this like “The Gong Show”, because I would have paid good money to see Lispy gonged. Or pulled off stage with a cane around her neck like “Showtime at the Apollo”. My GOD, she sucks. Bad. I still can’t figure out why she was given a spot when there were so many others who deserved it over her.

    I didn’t get the judges’ comments much – I disagreed with them almost all night. I didn’t think DoDo was that bad, but thought Michelle was fricking terrible. The chick with the weird eyes and bad weave didn’t do too badly with that Kelly Clarkson song, but Girl Gayken? UGH. I was with them on that one.

    My predictions for tonight: Paige and Michelle go home for the chicks, and Long Duck John and Jermaine (the black Pee Wee Herman) for the dudes.

  7. 7
    considerthis
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 7:52 am

    Tranny/vowels and Ronald McDonald 4 the girls and Onesie or Fraudrick or Ducker for the boyz.

  8. 8
    DonnaRonna
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 9:10 am

    DiDi – “Lean on Me” should not be sung as a perky summer camp song.

    Katelynn – I agree with Simon that it was a bit cheesy. I think it’s because she’s trying to do that “connection with the audience” thing the judges natter on about. Since when does Chris Martin make cheesy eye contact? He closes his eyes and emotes. He connects with the song, not with somebody in the second row.

    Loved Sio’s big note. Love her in general, because she’s so odd.

    Is it just me or are there lots more off-key moments this year? It seems like early on Ellen said something about different acoustics or electronics or something making the off-key stuff more obvious or am I making that up? It just seems like either the singers are worse or the sound system is (maybe both?).

  9. 9
    jennaboa
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 9:52 am

    Great recap, Sher! I had to work late and missed most of the show (I feel asleep during “The Scientist,” which is funny because I would have done the same thing when I saw Coldplay live at Austin City Limits a few years back if it hadn’t been 108 in the shade and so crowded. Coldplay always has that effect on me.

    I saw Lilly and quite liked her, but then, I love Yael Naim. Good comparison. :)

    OK, I like Vera Wang’s dresses quite a bit, but that white dress that girl was wearing looks like a sheet posing as a heft bag. and that picture so isn’t Vera. Did they really say it was? Edjits. You can tell Idol doesn’t know fashion from squat.

    I did watch the end bit with the recaps and was v glad to have missed most of the show. Especially the red head chick singing that hideous “Kiss Me” song.

    Randy’s paying money for those Mr Roger’s sweaters — that bug-eyed heart is Commes des Garcons logo and synonymous for “You Can’t Afford to Buy Me, Bitches.” I don’t know what distresses me more: Randy feeling like he has to pay so much to dress like my grandfather or a major avant garde fashion house trying to sell haute couture Mr Rogers sweaters during a financial downturn. :)

    Why doesn’t Skara just sit on Simon’s lap and be done with it already? Ugh.

  10. 10
    carmelicious
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:09 am

    Wow – this recap made my day!

    These quotes were just too funny, I must repeat them:

    “If you make me wish I was listening to Miley instead of you….well, it should be punishable by death.”
    (I seriously had the exact same thought…what a travesty!)

    “You should have an autobiography.”
    (this will be my new comeback to anyone who tries to talk to me about, well about pretty much anything)

    HAHA!

    Oh – I couldn’t really enjoy that cover of Arms Wide Open, I just kept thinking of Scott Stapp and his greasy hair, and ew, ick..I can’t even continue…

  11. 11
    sayhuh
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:27 am

    Ha ha, another great recap! That Miley thing is priceless. My feelings exactly! Although seeing her hickster dad enraptured in the seats is always good for a laugh. I knew you were going to like what that lady did with the Creed song, if not the actual singing, because you like the Divas. For me, a Creed song is awful enough – giving it the Celine treatment? Oy vey. Sounding flat and unpleasant on that hellish version of a hellish song? Please just kill me now.

    Poor DoDo. I like her, and I haven’t seen a mean-girl-style pile-on like the judges did on her since I was in third grade and my unpopular friends and I got backup from one of our older sisters and got to go all mean on the braggy girl’s ass. Good times!

    The people who voted for Girl Gayken last week after the worst, most off-pitch performance in AI history should be forced to watch that and last night’s performance in a loop for eternity. I hope they got on the wagon long enough this week to not vote for her.

    Poor Paige. She obviously wants to sing fun songs and the judges are hating her for it. They want her firmly sconced in that LaKisha big black diva spot. “You’re black! You’re bigger than a size 2! You can belt! Why why why why are you not singing Patti LaBelle or Whitney Houston songs?????? I don’t understaaaaaand!” Obviously they can’t say that out loud, but you know they’re thinking it.

    I’m kinda loving Lilly, Siobhan (funny how the judges didn’t take her to task for NOT changing the song one little bit) and Stifler’s Mom, although every time I see what she has on I can’t help picturing Nina shaking her head in that disappointed way of her and whispering “I’m just not sure about the taste level…”

    I agree with your predictions of who should leave (which of course means that they won’t) but I have a fervent hope that Dark Helmet will go. Of course he won’t, because someone has to keep the memorial Ace/Constantin douchy pretty boy spot warm for a few weeks…

  12. 12
    here4beer
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:32 am

    “and she doesn’t even have the strength to ask who gave the lemon AIDS in the first place.”

    Flipit, never ever change, please.

  13. 13
    fire@will
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:32 am

    Another fine recap (great song choice but a little pitchy in places, dawg).

    A couple of these young kids should probably not have been put in the final 24. They have no chance, but will not be able to come back when (if) they are ready in a year or two. I feel they are being sacrificed for ratings.

    Subway and Glass Blower are my current favorites, with “my fugly Daddy left my hot mom” showing a lot of potential. Smiley young girl (despite her “vote for the worst” support) should go, but I don’t really care who goes with her.

    Thanks much!

  14. 14
    chemgal
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:34 am

    They should have paid Paula whatever she wanted! I too can’t stand pan handlers so it doesn’t matter how good Crystal is, I will hold on to my vote as tightly as I hold on to my change when I pass one of her brethren on the street. WTF happened this season, really, really these are the best you can find out of the thousands that tried out? Really beginning to think the waitress from the restaurant down the street got screwed over when she couldn’t get past the first screening process in Boston. Cause she hums better than these gals.

  15. 15
    cansnuts
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 10:39 am

    I think Casey fills that Ace / Constantine spot better than Tim. (though I don’t receall Ace being a douch… maybe I’m wrong). Anyways, Casey seems endeering in his videos last week and this week, but when they were critiqing him and Simon comment a/b the lack of “grit” in his voice and he was like “aww that hurt, no grit?” or whatever, I had to roll my eyes b/c it seemed like a total Contanine thing to say. I hope he doesn’t continue down that path b/c he did come off quite humble and sweet in his videos.

  16. 16
    Sher
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 11:22 am

    Oh NO. Vote For The Worst is backing Lispy?! Shit!

    Please, American Idol God, when you’re through listening to Jermaine, could you please make sure VFTW doesn’t have much impact and that the tweens are offended that Lispy seems to be going for Taylor Swift 2.0 and SEND HER ASS HOME?! Thanks everso.

  17. 17
    itchy
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 11:44 am

    Um. Mr. Flipit, sir? I, um, well, I…well, gee golly gosh…I, um…I kinda… think Lacey Brown’s got the only really interesting voice of the bunch. She’s a long way away from having real control of it, but there’s texture there that none of the other girls have. Maybe I’ve been living in France too long, but she was on-key.

    Now, if she’d change the stupid hair. And the name. Somehow the combination of Lacey and Brown makes me think of shit-stained underwear.

    As for the rest, there’s three or four other girls who are almost believable as performers, which is a hell of a lot more than last season. It’s really interesting how sucky the guys are in comparison.

  18. 18
    soapboxx
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 3:05 pm

    This show is a joke. I really miss Paula’s drug muddled, messed up comments. Kara DiGardio, or whatever her name is, makes me want to puke with her uncomfortable, hyped, heavy breathing come’ons to the young guys. The judges are all “dude you just tried to sound like the original and I didn’t see any of you in it, make it your own”, then in the next breath “dude you just messed up the melody by improvising and you should just leave a song like that alone” dude…you judges suck!
    BTW I’m a VFTWorster, and yes we are responsible for the Taylor Hicks win (although I’m really just an arm chair VFTWorster because I don’t actually vote).
    Our goal now is to make sure Lispy makes the top ten so she will be on tour.
    There are much better young singers than AI ever tries to give a chance. AI is notorious for planting singers on the show that they have had failed contracts and relationships with. Didi is one of them. I barely watch the show and only read these recaps because they are written by the GOD of all recappers Mr.Flipit.
    If Flipit had written the bible it would be an easier read, funny, and would probably make alot more sense. Love you Flip!

  19. 19
    JasonR
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 3:54 pm

    Weird night. The white girls were singing soul and the black girls were singing . . . Miley and Creed?

    My top three were Crystal, Siobahn, and Lily.

    Siobahn reminds me of Ally Sheedy in “The Breakfast Club” after Molly Ringwald gives her a makeover and she’s all adorable.

    I love that the best girls are all kind of misfits and not the usual R&B diva clones we have seen a hundred times.

    I’m sorry but I’m completely in love with Lacey. The hair is pretty wild, but damn those eyes and that silky Texas drawl of hers just kill me. I thought her performance was middle of the pack but I don’t care.

    I think Jermaine, Todrick, Haeley and Michele are out tonight, although Didi, Paige, and John Park are also in jeopardy.

    Flipit you get better every week, and I don’t know how you’re banging these recaps out so fast. Me hopes you’re not taking Meth or something.

  20. 20
    sayhuh
    Posted March 4, 2010 at 7:59 pm

    Hey Flipit, good batting average in your guesses, and a couple of the people here should be very happy indeed – everybody wins (I think)! :-)

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Human Verification: In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.