The Top 24

53 Comments

1. 1
   Keyser Soze
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 7:28 am

   My pick is Taylor Hicks to win. Even if he doesn’t win, he got enough exposure to get picked up by somebody. I would buy anything he records. I heart Taylor.
   I wonder who VoteForTheWorst.com will pick this year to get behind?

2. 2
   Sher
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 7:30 am

   Right on, Dan – Taylor is so weird, and I love him for it. If he doesn’t make the Top 12, I’m going to protest.

   I’m also loving Chris, Mandisa, Katharine, and Kellie, and Sweet William is my hometown boy so I have to root for him too.

   I have no idea who a quarter of those people are.

3. 3
   USNRNPage
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 8:22 am

   I am hoping this will be the guys year! I love Ace, Chris and Taylor. Other than Kelli, I am not that impressed with most of the girls. Although I do admire Mandisa’s courage and integrity.

   I was yelling at the television the entire time the Brittenums were getting all of the air time on Tues. Thank god we don’t have to listen to their idiotic rantings any longer. Shame on AI for not editing them out earlier. ( But then, that would have left about a 12 minute episode.)

   Thanks for the breakdown of the final 24 Dan.

4. 4
   BigMax
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 8:44 am

   Taylor also plays a great harmonica. That was pretty cool. Lots of really talented people — no obvious Constatines or Fedorovs this year.

5. 5
   Krizzatch
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 9:47 am

   OK, I’m obviously in the minority here, but I think Taylor looks like a spastic Tim Pawlenty with bad hair. It’s called Grecian Formula. Look into it.

   He’s got soul, but he’s no Idol…

6. 6
   Ash
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 9:56 am

   This is totally random, but after watching this and seeing Taylor play his harmonica, I was walking to class the next morning, and some dude was strolling down the sidewalk rocking out on his harmonica! It was so funny!

7. 7
   Redhead
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:02 am

   I’m just hoping for another Melinda Lira breakdown on the first elimination night.

8. 8
   littledarling
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:04 am

   I love spastic Taylor Hicks!
   I’m so glad those obnoxious twins are gone. They were just too much to stomach.
   So excited to hear the guys this year!

9. 9
   holyterror
   Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:21 am

   I’m cheering for Mandisa and think she’ll win, for her balls alone, but also for a great voice. Plus, I think she’s genuinely beautiful. Plus, Simon’s dissing her makes people want her to win. Plus, all that Jesus shit plays well in the Red States, even if it makes my eyes glaze over.

   Taylor had me until he brought in that fucking harmonica. I can’t stand anyone who needs props, much less the dumbest instrument ever invented.

10. 10
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:28 am

    I’m GLAD that AI kept the Brittenum’s in. They gave me a great opportunity to teach my children lessons about pride and arrogance. And then when “Broken-Spirit” had to go back in and apologize, I was able to throw in a BONUS lesson on HUMILITY! You have to watch these reality shows and try to extract some useful morsel of wisdom from them to pass on to your children, otherwise, you’ve wasted an hour and an opportunity. Like with “The Real World”, I just tell my kids “You see those people? Whatever they do, you do the opposite”.

    Thank you, Brittenums, for providing a public service. Good luck in the hoosegow. Don’t forget to hook up with the Nation of Islam. Oh, and here’s your prison dictionary http://dictionary.prisonwall.org/ don’t thank me … I just hopes that ya don’t get “checked”.

11. 11
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:39 am

    Holyterror:

    That “Jesus s–t”, as you so eloquently put it, plays well anywhere. It’s the AUDIENCE that’s unworthy of the message. The Man’s life was a living example of what we need to do to get to the next level, documented and handed down to us. Yet humanity is too arrogant and foolish to pay attention. Some people want to believe that this is all there is, but deep inside, they know that they’re squandering this incarnation. So they lash out, when in truth, they’re disappointed in themselves on a level too deep to be consciously felt. But hey, everybody’s gotta move at their own pace.

    It’s like a pig in sty. The pig lives in filth, sleeps in filth, eats in filth. He says to all who will listen, “Man, this filth is GREAT! I just LOVE living in swill! Look at this mud! This is quality mud, dude!”. Meanwhile, the poor pig doesn’t know that there’s a whole other way to live, a far better way than the way he’s living now.

    We can’t play in the mud forever, dude.

12. 12
    wniffene
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:40 am

    I was so upset that they spent all that time “revealing” what happened to the Jailbird twins, as if everyone in America didn’t already know, so annoying. And is it just me or in the picture at the top of the recap does Kevin Corvais look like the one that’s not like the others, you know the one that does not belong. He’s the only one in a white shirt, maybe it’s a sign or something.

13. 13
    Lizardqueen
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 10:54 am

    I was so sure Mandisa was about to say “Simon, you hurt me. And I cried. But I forgive you. And I started working out and eating right.” That’s what should’ve happened. What good is acceptance of one’s own obesity? Of course dying of heart disease and diabetes at 47 years old means that much quicker to heaven. Mandisa is gorgeous and a great singer, but why all the fat?

14. 14
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 11:11 am

    Good point, Lizardqueen. No one should accept being severely obese. It’s not about appearances, it’s a health issue. But the food industry in this country knows that obese Americans are their best customer, so they try to placate them with “low-this”, lite-that” when in realiy the only things that have ever and will ever reverse obesity are: 1. SELF-CONTROL, 2. VEGETARIANISM 3. EXERCISE.

    People must master item 1 before item 2 and 3 can be effective. And I’m not just baggin’ on overweight people. That goes for all of us and our habits (and we know what they are) including me! The lesson to be taken up in the over-coming of our bad habits is s-e-l-f c-o-n-t-r-o-l.

    That being said, Mandisa is an extremely likeable person. She also has her head on straight. She showed that she actually THINKS before she acts. (Gee, another free Life lesson! Thanks, AI) That’s how you tackle an acidic, curt, rude, snarky Britisher named Cowell. Kill ‘em with kindness. I’m telling you, it knocks ‘em off balance every time.

15. 15
    happy_gal
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 11:23 am

    #13 and #14 . . . spoken like two people who have never had to struggle with their weight, or people who have lost a lot and now look down their noses at the rest of the “fat, lazy slobs” of the world. If only Mandisa had your willpower and attitude, then she too could be perfect. Poor Mandisa. Poor us.

    Anyway, Taylor is my number one pick by far. His voice is divine, and his harmonica playing showed that he is multi-talented and quirky. He is not your typical “idol,” which makes him the best choice!

16. 16
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:06 pm

    Happy_gal:

    Your first reaction is to be insulted. Your second is to deride and lash out. I defy you to tell me where in the passage the phrase “look down their noses” would apply. I stated facts. Facts that you obviously don’t want to accept. And because you have an already low opinion of yourself, you flip it around to portray me as lording it over “fat, lazy, slobs”. Those were your words, not mine. Look, I just pointed the way. If you want to continue to walk down that blind alley, be my guest. The cure for obesity is simple. Don’t eat so much. Don’t eat when you’re happy, or sad, or lonely, or bored. You don’t have to put fork to mouth. Or bottle to mouth, or powder to nose, or money on the roulette wheel, for that matter. The template applies to ALL habits.

    “Perfect”? That’s ridiculous. No one said anything about “perfection”. Unless that’s the way you spell “health”. Because that’s where I was coming from. Hey, it’s your life. You choose your own exit from the world stage. If you want to leave with a drumstick in one hand and a Diet Coke in the other, go right ahead.

    Your response hints at a bitterness and self-loathing that would evoke pity from me…if I weren’t above “looking down my nose” at my fellow man. Good luck to you.

17. 17
    TexasK
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:13 pm

    Taylor — he respects Ray Charles and has a very Joe Cocker vibe about him when he performs (what others here have referred to as his lovably “spastic” tendencies) Those two things alone will make me root for him. And then there’s the gray hair and the harmonica. What’s not to love with this guy?

    And something tells me Patrick Hall is going to be good for a laugh. Ace: I have a feeling he’ll be eye-fucking the camera Constantine-style by the time the Top 12 are chosen (Note to Ace if you visit TVGasm: Do NOT EF the camera. You’re cute as hell, but EFing is creepy no matter how hot you are.)

18. 18
    RealityTV4Me
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:17 pm

    “Bucky Covington: Great looking” Are you kidding me? You must have like Constablublub-puke, too.

    William looks like Peter Brady.

    #15 – THANK YOU!!!

19. 19
    Ellen
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:37 pm

    William is by far my favorite. I find him so god damn adorable in that I-just-want-to-hug-him way. When they didn’t show him until the very end, I thought for sure they had already dismissed him and hadn’t even shown it, so when he popped up in the last two minutes and got a “yes,” I was a happy girl.

    I like Paris a lot too, but I assumed she’d be in the top ten ever since I saw her at the first round of auditions, so I have to root for William more than her since he’s more of an underdog. I, too, hope she doesn’t continue to make the mistake of over-singing. I noticed within the past few episodes that her voice was kind of missing the haunting quality it had when I first heard her sing, and I couldn’t put my finger on why until you pointed that out.

    I see Ace as the Constantine of this round, and I predict that Paula will cry when he gets voted out of the top twelve. Thank God he’s at least better looking AND better sounding than Constantine was.

20. 20
    Mark
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:46 pm

    Don’t hate on Mandisa. It’s very hard to lose weight, even if you try hard.

    I don’t know if I will vote for Paris. I mean, I love her voice, and I wish she would win, but I’d rather not see her talent be ruined because of AI making her do a pop album.

21. 21
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:46 pm

    Somebody please tell Randy that “Good lookin’ out” is something we USED to say about TEN YEARS ago as a way of thanking someone for a favor (aka “a solid”, another worn-out term). It was not intended to be used as a substitute for “good-bye” or “nice job” or whatever he wants to use it for. If you can’t use slang properly, then dude, just be your normal self.

    Will someone PLEASE get this man a copy of the “Handbook of Black American Slang”? PLEASE???

22. 22
    Bauer's Sweetheart
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:46 pm

    Mama Weaver, is that you? You can’t fool us by calling yourself G-Money!

23. 23
    georgiababe
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 12:57 pm

    #16 – G-Money..it’s not easy to just stop eating or smoking pot or whatever. I know that it sounds so stupid, to eat when you’re sad, but you obviously have no idea how complex that issue can become. It’s not simply a matter of wanting some ice cream, it’s a form of therapy. Time goes by so fast, and before you know it, you down a whole carton. Yes, it is the obese/overweight person’s fault for getting themselves that way, but it’s not as easy as you think to let go of something that has been your comfort for so long. Believe me, I know.

    On a different note, Taylor reminds me of Ray Charles. When he broke into his spastic, improvised song at the end, my boyfriend remarked that he acted like Ray Charles did. I love him, but holy cow I hope they DYE HIS HAIR!!! I also love little Kevin. When I first saw him I thought, oh this poor boy is going to be humiliated but he (thankfully) proved me wrong. I also love Patrick Hall and Elliott. And William. I also love Chris. Ace kind of bothers me. I’m really not sure why. As for the girls, I love Katharine, Mandisa and Kellie. I also love Ayla, Stephanie, Lisa and of course, Paris, but I don’t know how well Stephanie and Paris will fare in the pop world. Their talents seem to be better used elsewhere. This is the most talented top 24 I think we’ve ever seen (I still don’t understand how Mikayla got in, and Kimberly Caldwell) and I think that it will be the toughest so far. We’ll just have to wait and see.

24. 24
    G-Money
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 1:14 pm

    Georgiababe and happy_gal:

    Alright. I’ve done some ruminating over this and I can see how my words can be mis-interpreted as displaying a lack of sensitivity. You’re both right, it’s not as easy as snapping your fingers. I stand accused. The charge? Insensitivity. I plead “no contest” and throw myself upon the mercy of the court.

    Forgiven?

    Bauer’s Sweetheart: Who, pray tell, is Mama Weaver?

25. 25
    georgiababe
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 1:16 pm

    forgiven. thanks for understanding where i’m coming from.

26. 26
    tvaholic
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 1:33 pm

    Wow, G-Unit, while I have to respect your Mr. Spock-like take on the logical, are you aware that the world is not black and white? Or do you just feel your opinions and beliefs to be fact and all shall bow down to you? I think it’s rather ironic that you don’t care for Simon because it sounds like the two of you are quite similar. BTW, I’ve lost 27 pounds with Weight Watchers and exercise, and I still EAT MEAT! Your idea that vegetarianism is crucial to health and weight loss makes me think you must be a card-carrying member of PETA, which if true, would make me dislike you even more.

    Sorry, had to get that out of my system. that being said, Paris will be a winner, no matter what. If the phone-happy teenagers who’ll surely vote for Ace every week get her booted, she’ll bounce back up & right into a lucrative deal where she won’t have to sing songs like “A Moment Like This.” I do like the guy with the hat who married an older woman with kids-I like his voice & his attitude, I can totally see him fronting a band. I’m so glad you pointed out the side-by-side comparison where Heather Cox inexplicably won. Ok, I can explain it, Simon always had hard-ons for pretty brunettes-remember the Vegas stripper from last year?

    Good lookin’ out.

27. 27
    tvaholic
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 1:34 pm

    Sorry G-unit, I must have been posting the same time as you. I love a guy who asks for mercy.

28. 28
    Ellen
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 1:58 pm

    Upon visiting VFTW.com, I just remembered who Ayla Brown is. She’s the one whose dad is a senator and whose segment in the first round of auditions consisted of that bit of information as well as a long list of everything else that makes her so wonderful and accomplished. She’s also the only one who I instantly and strongly disliked. I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with being accomplished, but shit, try a little modesty. I was able to recall all of this because VFTW referred to her as “Snob-Bot.” I’m glad I’m not the only one who got that vibe from her. Hopefully she’ll get canned.

29. 29
    Bauer's Sweetheart
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:28 pm

    Mama Weaver was the person we all loved to hate on the Amazing Race Family Edition – she and her three children did nothing but viciously trash talk the other families, and then claim the reason the other families disliked them was because they (the Weavers) were such good Christians. I think your comments were generally correct but they sure can come across harshly when they are just typed words and we can’t hear the good intentions behind them. I’m glad to see you’ve reconsidered and pledged to be more sensitive, and I am sure Jesus is proud of you.

30. 30
    Wade
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:29 pm

    The Alabama Idol dynasty continues. I interviewed Taylor Hicks today, so check it out.

31. 31
    juddfan
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:33 pm

    Well . . . some heated discussions in here. May I weigh in on it too, i have to say I love the big people among us, I find their plight to be like my struggles but visable to all, and therefore, a place where everyone can project their bad feeling about themselves. I have managed to conquer my external weight struggles, but I will always feel “chunky” inside. I feel a kindredness with big people and can see their obvious vulnerablitly and wouldn’t ever want to make matters worse for them. My sister is obese, and likely always will be, and I couldn’t love her any differently even if she was a twig, I don’t care how big she is. I of course realize being obese is not good for your health, and I see she is beginning to have struggles with blood sugars and her knees, but frankly, nothing any fun is good for you, is it!? I think we all must do something that’s not good for ourselves, coz frankly, this life can be a struggle . . .

    though, I do love that we have this outlet to be less PC than we might be in person, and I often cackle at the callous things we say, often the more biting the better, and I try to hone my bitter spews to be comic relief rather than cruel.

    Simon must have some issues, I guess, coz he can be needlessly cruel–you don’t have to tell a big person they are big . . . they (and I) remind ourselves every second of every minute of every day.

    I love that people are liking Taylor, and I like the grey hair, myself. He’s very different, and therefore refreshing! I really like bunches of these people and will be interested to see how they do.

    I have a feeling Paris, David and Taylor will all make it, w/ or w/out the show.

32. 32
    wallstreetpanic
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:35 pm

    My favorite part of the Bible is where Jesus tells all the fat people that they suck and he hates them.

33. 33
    juddfan
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:39 pm

    oh, wallstreetpanic . . . such a perfect example!!!! Why couldn’t I have thought of that!!!!

34. 34
    Lizardqueen
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 2:57 pm

    Is this a bad time to point out that the men seem to have an inordinate number of orthodontia issues? Where are all the snaggletoothed ladies?
    For the record, I LOVE fat people. Love ‘em I tell ya. My dad weighs 350lbs. and he has a little machine he has to wear at night so his fat doesn’t choke him to death while he sleeps, or it reminds him to breath or some such sad thing. True story.

35. 35
    juddfan
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 3:12 pm

    indeed, LQ, I don’t think veneers are a part of the make overs yet, but I’m sure they’d be welcome, esp since teeth are so in your face while one sings . . .

    My sister’s hubby’s on one of those breathers too, but I thought it was for like sleep apnea or something.

    guess I don’t need to say you’re one of my faves! ; )

36. 36
    Bauer's Sweetheart
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 3:29 pm

    And I better say it before Elton John does, but what’s up with the racial representation here? One black guy in the top 12? That’s all they could find all over America? Nice to see an Asian and a Latino in there but seriously, only one black guy??

37. 37
    zoobabe
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 4:41 pm

    Wow! A lot of comments so far! I’m also a Taylor fan, and a Kevin fan, and William, Ace, Kelli, Katherine and Mandisa. I also dislike Brenna (can’t sing) and Ayla (can’t sing well enough) and wants to play basketball just as much as sing anyway. They definitely put some people in for the effect they will have on the whole group, but the public usually weeds them out early. I just hope that little Kevin doesn’t choke under the pressure!

    juddfan- are you sure you don’t want to change your name to taylorfan? He’s cute in an unconventional way, and he has SOUL!

    LQ- your comments (as usual) are hysterical!

38. 38
    juddfan
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 5:58 pm

    You know, zoobabe, I should consider that, but I have a feeling someone more worthy of that handle will come along! I do dig him though, and he’ll make the show much more watchable. I also think Chris, the bald rocker is hot (for a non-potbellied guy! LOl!!!)

39. 39
    jenny10girl
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 6:53 pm

    LQ and juddfan – it’s called a CPAP machine…it is for sleep apnea…which basically does help you breathe during the night. I work for an insurance company, that’s how I know…Anyways, my favs are the bald dude (Chris I think?) and the guy with the nice smile…Ace, right? The grey haired guy is good, but a bit weird for this competition…that’s my take at least…

40. 40
    zoobabe
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 7:16 pm

    yeah jenny- that’s Ace with the nice smile. He’s very easy on the eyes.

41. 41
    mere2142
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 7:59 pm

    I love Taylor and hope he goes far this year!

42. 42
    Keyser Soze
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 8:45 pm

    “For the record, I LOVE fat people. Love ‘em I tell ya.”
    Yeah, that sounds as genuine as the old “I love black people. I have several black friends.”

43. 43
    TWilliams
    Posted February 17, 2006 at 9:27 pm

    I guess I am the only person who likes Ayla Brown which means she won’t make it. I don’t get the vibe that others are getting off of her . . . her mother seemed to think her daughter was something special but I didn’t get that from the daughter herself. Is she supposed to be hated because she is pretty, can sing (just not as well as some of the others), is an athlete and comes from a very blue and liberal state? It sounds as if none on this site are too quick to judge. I think the only finalist that has shown any despicable traits at the moment is Brenna who immediately wanted to start making some money after being selected to the top 24. I have already had enough of her . . . she could care less if she is entertaining as long as she gets rich.

    I do like Taylor, he seems geniune. I didn’t see the harmonica as a prop he had to use — his entrance into that room wasn’t going to determine whether or not he made the finals.

    G-Money, I have read you for a while and have to applaud you. You are honest and intelligent; something posters usually do not like. I am also surprised to find out that you do not like Simon since you are both brutally honest individuals. I don’t get the person who said Simon must be insecure because he is so quick to criticize . . . uh, not necessarily. Some people are simple that — honest and won’t sugar-coat anything for you. We need more people like that around.

    Lastly, I don’t think G-Money ever said that losing weight was as “easy” as A-B-C but it can be done by anybody — just as smoking or drinking or gambling etc. My uncle decided not to smoke EVER again and did just that. He finished his last pack after smoking some 40 years and never asked for another one. I know someone who did the same with alcohol. It can be done but it isn’t as easy for everybody. Don’t harp on G for saying it can be done. I even know someone who lost 40 lbs. overnight because his leg was amputated. Losing weight can be a challenge; but it isn’t impossible.

44. 44
    Victoria
    Posted February 18, 2006 at 12:03 am

    OMG-wallstreetpanic#32-that was hysterical!

    I don’t think Taylor needs to dye his hair, but he could do with a new hairstyle. Don’t be surprised if “Ace” goes further than him, because he is so pretty-too pretty for me, but there’s a lid for every pot. What really bother me is that he calls himself “Ace.” That nickname is just plain obnoxious.

    The biggest problem with this show is that they spent so much time profiling those idiot twins, and now we have almost no idea of who the people in the top 24 are. I have never even seen some of those people before this episode in any context. That’s just sad. I can’t really pick a favorite until I actually get a chance to see some of these poeple sing.

45. 45
    zoobabe
    Posted February 18, 2006 at 5:09 am

    TWilliams- I gave a specific reason for not liking Ayla. She can’t sing as well as some of the others, and she wants to play basketball in college just as much as be in this contest. That’s why she shouldn’t advance. Any AI winner should be ready to devote their full attention to a singing career. If she’s torn about what she really wants, she doesn’t need to win this as much as those who have already made up their minds and are willing to work hard. The judges asked her about this in her initial audition, and she admitted that she was torn between the two.

46. 46
    Jesus_loves_you
    Posted February 18, 2006 at 8:15 am

    - This year Chris Daughtry(the bald one)is inheriting all my Bo Bice rocker love and text votes, no matter what he sings, and especially if he has an off week.

    - Kelly Pickler you’re cute, your story is heartwarming with your alcholic, convict dad, and dead mom or whatever the heck your horrible backstory is that the producers keep force feeding us. I don’t care, I refuse to love you, and you won last year Carrie!!! Sorry just projecting my hate, I’m allowed.

    -Crooners are cool but your god, Old Blue Eyes, is dead and has a park named after him in Hoboken. So no AI winning for you kids, and I’m disconnecting all phone service for the “depends” nation.

    - Yes there is only one African American guy that can sing in this country, along with only one Asian, Latino, and arrogant Indian-looking girl. Needle in a haystack kids and our ethnic quota has been met.

    -Ace I also project my Constantine loathing on you this year. Simply because you made my girlfriend squeal, “Oh my god he’s sooo hot!!!” And two because I’m just not as pretty as you either. Ass.

    -Katherine Mcphee my favorite female just because you actually look like this girl next door to us, but I’m sure she can’t sing as well as you.

    -Grey-haired dude, Taylor, cut out the Ray Charles it was a little creepy, and not that funny after two seconds. The second you dye that grey hair your are soo getting booted by the “keep it natural” crowd. I like you just because.

    All other forgettables, um, good luck in life and keep working on that album. Has anyone seen Mario Velasquez, Vasquez, Villanueva, Vargas, …yeah exactly. Shout-outs to Justin Guarini, Kimberly Caldwell, RJ, Carmen Rasmussin, Mikayla, Rueben Studdard. Corey Clark and William Hung thank you both for not resurfacing as of this second.

    -Brittenum Twins c’mon who were these Devo’s fooling…they enjoy dropping the soap in the shower. “My Spirit has been broken and so has my Butt-hymen.”

    And lastly I love all overweight people out there. I personally no how hard it is for you. I lost 46lbs by eating right (South Beach diet), exercise(Taebo), and having a brother who was a Marine, hurt his back, and now weighs in at 300+. He also suffers from hallucinations, constant fits of panick, and OCD due to his diabetes and he’s also been breathing/living on one of those sleep apnea machines for the last ten years. Good luck to you all and God bless.

47. 47
    BrugaCMH
    Posted February 18, 2006 at 8:24 am

    Hey #15…Trim Spa Baybee!

48. 48
    Den of Earth
    Posted February 18, 2006 at 9:37 am

    Love Taylor for his individuality, his personality, and the fact that I’ve very much enjoyed everything I’ve heard from him so far.

    William Makar – I like the powerful sound of his voice, and the tone. Plus, he seems like such a nice kid.

    To me, Kelli Pickler is genuinely sweet, and – though I am admittedly the world’s biggest sap – I’ve been emotionally moved by her tears twice. And I think she sounds fabulous.

    Katharine McPhee – I’ve always been a fool for a pretty face, and she’s a beauty. Seriously though, I like her singing and personality a lot, too.

    It’s not fair to Ace, but I can’t watch him without seeing Constantine molest my daughter via the camera last year. I don’t know if I’ll ever recover from being assaulted by his leers.

49. 49
    KateMcV
    Posted February 19, 2006 at 2:49 pm

    Not gonna lie, I have no idea if Ace can sing, but I will vote for him just to look at the pretty every week. And I may also vote for Patrick “not as pretty” Hall just for that comment.

    Girl-wise I love Lisa and as much as I didn’t want to like Kellie Pickler cause of them using her story to make us cry every week, she is talented.

50. 50
    ImHot
    Posted February 19, 2006 at 8:16 pm

    KateMcV, I agree. I’ll also vote for Ace each week for eye candy and then top it off with a vote for squirrel eyes to redeem my soul.

51. 51
    iluvkobebryant
    Posted February 19, 2006 at 9:40 pm

    I love Taylor almost as much as I love Kobe!! Ok not exactly in the way that I love love Kobe. But I do think he is an all-star just like him. Taylor, U my boy, Do your thang, and I’ll be doing the voting.

    Brenna is just as bad as these twins with ridiculous airtime going on no talent, no class people. She makes “Annoying as Hell TV”. Hopefully she don’t last until next week

52. 52
    G-Money
    Posted February 21, 2006 at 8:25 am

    TWilliams:

    Thank you for your post. It’s good to know that some people are astute enough to see a message for what it is and not color it with their own insecurities before trying to interpret it. Yes, I am a more-or-less straightforward person. This trait of mine has miffed more than a few people in my travels, friend and foe alike. And I hold no malice toward them. Heck, I myself have bristled at the objective observations of others in the past regarding my behavior. I didn’t like be called out any more that most of us do. So I am always aware that there are those who will take umbrage at what I may have to say. That doesn’t stop me from saying it, though. I will always try to come from a positive place when it comes to voicing an opinion, if I can.

    We do not always accept brutal honesty for what it is. An attempt by Life to light the way for us. Once we begin to recognize that the guy that cut you off on the freeway is not a #@%!* but rather an opportunity to practice forgiveness and self-control, then humanity,as a race will have it’s feet firmly on the path.

53. 53
    tvaholic
    Posted February 21, 2006 at 2:12 pm

    G-Money (sorry about the G-Unit)you are quite Zen-like, so I can’t be hating on you anymore.

    wallstreetpanic: hil-AR-ious!!

    As far as the whiteout on AI-I’m not sure why everyone is so surprised. The show is looking for a pop star, more Christina or Brittney in the sense they want someone who’s easily molded into commercial success. Fantasia broke that mold somewhat, but even Ruben had to sing some boring songs. Kelly realized the “Big Poppa”, Svengali-like hold AI wanted over her & got out while the gettin’ was good. I’m not saying AI only wants white winners, but I think they just want a cookie cutter pop star that fits into their idea of what mainstream America wants. Sad, but true. That’s the only explanation for Clay Aiken’s success. I’m not saying he doesn’t have talent, but who does he appeal to?