Well now that the one hour Project Runway casting special is out of the way , its time to get down to brass tacks. Time for the show to start in earnest. Time for the backbiting and 1 AM sewing crunches. Time for the model fittings and for Tim’s takes. Time for Michael Kors being bitchy and rolling his eyes and Heidi to look radiant as she Auf Wiedershein’s a whole new season full of contestants. It’s time for even more product placement than before (Now added to the TRESemmé hair salon and the L’Oreal makeup room, is the Macy’s accessory wall. It’s only a matter of time before Tim starts walking around with a GoldenPalace.com hat on. And goddamit if he wouldn’t make it work). It’s time dear reader for Project Runway 3.
Now that we’ve all seen the casting special we have gotten somewhat familiar with our contestants, so the first few minutes of the show, where each one is introduced, is a bit rushed which is good. We want to get right to the action.
The first contestant to enter the loft is Malan. Which is Mandarin for “arrogant oily prick”. He was born in Taiwan you see. “Tie-waannn” as he puts it. He talks out of the corner of his mouth and has an evil laugh. Expect him to be around for a while before getting the boot. After we hear him complain about how fake flowers creates bad feng shui, he is met at the loft by Michael Knight, the hip hop designer. And boy is that an awkward introduction. Soon Robert and hippie Bradley join the party.
Next up is Laura Bennett, flat chested architect extraordinaire (I’m sorry, but the woman wears clothes that goes out of its way to accentuate the fact that she has the chest of a young Macaulay Culkin). In her small talk we here her saying that she never dresses down. “With 5 kids it’s a slippery slope to sweatpants and a minivan, so I just don’t go there”. Cut to Laura with her five ids stuffed in the back seat of a Miata screaming for their lives. But hey, she looks fab!
Then its time for Angela from Ohio. Or as she tells us “Quote unquote nowhere”. Wait, I thought when you did the “quote unquote” thing, what follows has to be an ironic statement? . Like “Barry Bonds hits home runs because he rubs himself down with quote unquote flax seed oil”. I mean, when I meet people I don’t say “Quote, unquote ‘Hello’ “. Although maybe I should start.
Laura is fascinated by the fact that Angela is from Ohio. “What do people do in Ohio. I’ve often wondered about it” she asks her as if Ohio is some alien world where people live underground and eat dirt. Although she probably wouldn’t like it at all. I hear parents actually put their kids in minivans and don’t leave them for months at a time to appear on reality shows. Can you believe that?
Net up its Stacy Estrella, the 40 year old with the 20 year olds hair. Then it’s the pageant guy Kayne from Oklahoma. And really, where else would you open a pageant dress shop that good old Oklahoma? Here we get yet another glimpse of his bio video where he makes his Mommie Dearest “No more wire hangers” joke. About as funny as someone doing an Austin Powers impression. God I, quote unquote, hate those people.
The next person to come to the apartments is giraffe necked “rock and roller” Jeffrey. And he instantly proves his rock and roll bona fides by jumping up and down on the bed. He’s a total hardcore shredder! Jeffrey tells us that he has a clothing store called “Cosa Nostra”. The Italian mafia must be thrilled about this. He is also planning on opening a shoe store called “Hamas” once the funding comes through. Jeffrey has designed for many famous rock stars so it’s somewhat of a mystery as to why he is on the show. At least it was until I remembered Chloe with giant flat screens showing PR reruns in her store all day smiling about how now she can “charge more”. Jeffrey however is more than just a designer. He’s also something of a comedy stylist. A talent he shows us when he goes to shake hands with Vincent but, Uh Oh! He was wearing a wacky hand buzzer! The joke was so lame even BRAVO made fun of him by putting a “wacky hand buzzer” freeze frame graphic onscreen. When the network that brought you Celebrity Poker Showdown thinks you’re lame, it’s time to just go away quietly. But he won’t. Instead he hands Vincent some binoculars with shoe polish in the eyepeice and tells him to check out the view. He can barely contain his snickering at the impending hilarity.

Then the “Cute girl” Alison shows up. And then Uli, who is from Germany. She is like the St. Pauli Girl when you’re sober. I would give her 5 dollars just to hear her say strudel. Next up it’s Bonnie, who designed for Serena Willliam’s ass. Then we get our hip young certified ski instructor. Katherine. Shes a light sleeper so as long as you don’t snore. Obviously she never heard a German snore.
Back in the guys room Robert sees a note pinned to the note board. He opens it and starts to read it. “Designers… You have all been voted off.”. Goddamit. Here I was all ready for another season of Project Runway that leads up to Fashion Week, and then we find out it’s actually a five minute long season. A giant practical joke, if you will. I mean all that anticipation and its over. What were they thinking? Oh wait. What was that? Let me rewind my TiVo I think I missed what he said after that. OHMIGOD! He said he was just kidding! It didn’t really say that! Holy shit Robert! DON”T DO THAT! God I totally thought you were serious. Boy is my face red. I tell ya we gotta be on our toes this season. It’s a bunch of tricksters. If Robert gives me a big can of nuts to open I am not falling for it. I will not get giant snakes all over me dammit! Between Roberts practical joke and Jeffrey’s hand buzzer its gonna be a comedy showdown. Seltzer bottles and banana peels at noon.

Punk’d!
No, what the note really says is to have all the designers join Tim and Heidi on the roof for a celebratory toast. Once all the designers get there they see a decidedly non pregnant Heidi (these must have been her rest months between children) and Tim Gunn. Tim tells everyone that he is just thrilled to be working with them. I am thrilled to here Tim tell people he’s thrilled. Now its time for champagne and some time to get to know everyone a little better. But Tim starts it off with a toast to season three. Then he gets all quiet, takes a sip and says “this ones for me” and then pours the rest out and says “and this ones for my homies”. Word.
as they all sip and mingle Vincent the crazy guy tells everyone about how he was “near death” the last time he was in fashion, and that he’s getting back into it. He even cashed out his 401k. He couldn’t handle the pressure you see. So he figured the best way to ease back into the fashion world was go on the serene, stress free environment of a competitive reality show.
We also get to hear Robert Best bitching about the time he worked with Isaac Mizrahi. “At times I wanted to drive a steak through his heart!” he squeals. Well in Isaac’s defense, the people at Target demand nothing less than perfection in their name brand fashion. You think they would let Isaac design some half assed gaucho with their label on it? Not for $6.99 they won’t. This isn’t some shitty Jaclyn Smith collection people. This is Target.
Next we see Stacey tell everyone her life history. And she of course follows the cardinal rule for all people who went to Harvard: Tell everyone you meet you went to Harvard. She even got to start her own dot com. www.chickengeorgerocks.com. Then she went into fashion and then finally reality television.
Well now that the small talk is over and everyone has had a chance to eat cheese and champagne on the Atlas apartment’s cramped roof. Oh excuse me, I mean penthouse. Heidi brings them all together. “Does everyone like your apartment?” She asks with a glint in her eye. Uh oh. Get ready for a shocker! Yep, its time for the first twist! They will have to create a piece using only the materials found… in their apartments! Tim then holds up the Project Runway Snakebite Kit which has been refurbished for this challenge to hold a pair of scissors, some pliers and a laundry bag. They have 15 minutes starting… now!
Now its time for our first mad rush of the season. Everyone races downstairs. Malan, from Taiwan, is just beside himself. “I was irritated that the materials would be bed sheets and interior fabrics. I myself prefer better quality fabrics.” he bitches. You know what I find irritating? His pronunciation of the word irritating.
As everyone frantically rips apart their apartments, we see Angela ripping apart some brown leather with some nice top stitching. Laura tells us that as long as she ahs fur, she can make “fabulousness”. Stacey meanwhile has been watching too many bad reality shows and decides to use a strategy of taking things she won’t use just to keep other people from getting them.
When Bradley, the resident hippie sees a big pillow he grabs it and rips apart the pillowcase exclaiming “aww sweet”. The white boring pillowcase is “sweet”. I don’t have high hopes for Bradley. This sets of Robert because that was his pillowcase that he brought here special. He even named it “Bubby”.
Meanwhile, Malan is still in the same state he was before. “It was sort of irritating to see how inappropriate people act” he smarms. Wow, second “irritating” from him in 2 minutes. That is so exasperating. Irksome even.
After their fifteen minutes are up its time to head over to the workrooms where all the contestants get down to work. Not long after that they are visited by Tim Gunn. He gathers all the people around and tells them that they have until 1 AM tonight to work, that they have each been assigned a model and their measurements are on their tables. Also whoever wins the challenge has immunity for the next challenge. And then Tim tells them to, as always, MIW.
Soon everyone is busy working. There are feathers flying around form the down comforters which prompts a round of bad feather jokes. Where’s the wacky buzzer when you need it? Keith tells us that he has never made a dress before, but it’s OK because he thinks he has the best taste of anyone there. That’s called runway smackdown.

Over on the other side of the workroom Stacey is having trouble with the sewing machine. It seems that her not having sewn in over ten years has had an adverse affect on her effectiveness on the show Project Runway, a competitive reality show that involves sewing together numerous pieces of women’s wear in a short period of time. Who knew?

At 11 PM Tim stops off, before his ritzy night on the town no doubt, and does his first walkabout of the season. When he looks at Vincent’s he tells him that his pockets are too cartoony. It’s the kind of outfit better suited for Darkwing Duck then a runway model. But Vincent digs it. He thinks it’s a crazy look and he loves it. And then he shows Tim his basket. Tim tells him that he doesn’t think the basket alone works. Then Vincent grabs some chains and ooohs like he just invented the bikini, or even, dare I say, the pubikini.
Over at Jeffrey, the man with the giraffe neck, Tim tells him that he thinks his big mess of a jacket is competing with his big mess of a dress. When Tim comes by Stacey’s workstation he just gives her that quiet pained look we’ve come to know so well. Even Stacey realizes that its not a “good Tim Look”. She is behind because she has abandoned the sewing machine and started to hand sew her piece.

Tim comes by Keith’s station where he is working with a big blue bedsheet . Tim tells him that he thinks the judges may point out that since the bedsheet is so close to real fabric, he really isn’t challenging himself. One of his diary interviews talk about how he doesn’t respect some of the designer judges styles. Our first schtick alert of the season. Because of Course the Fashion Director at Elle Magazine and A world renowned designer are just winging it. Listen, Michael Kors may not now the best way to apply a spray on tan, but he does know fashion.
Jeffrey says that when he looked around the room he thought everyone’s pieces was a blur of “remedial intermediate bullshit.” Hmm. Remedial I get, but intermediate? God that is so quote unquote irritating! When everyone gets back to the apartment they find out that…the place is still a mess. Harsh. BRAVO makes everyone practically sleep on the floor.
The Next morning we see them at 4 hours before the runway show. Jeffrey is looking forward to his model and the runway show because he looks at those aspects as “the cherry on the cake”. Man, what kind of remedial intermediate metaphor was that? Keith added a placement and ringlets at Tim’s instruction, but when he slept on it all he wanted to do was get rid of it. When will they learn? Never cross Tim.
Michael Knight is using coffee filters to create his dress. I like the look he’s getting from it and really like the innovation, but he’s been a blip the whole episode. Austin Scarlett covers his model with corn husks and is heralded as the next great thing, but MK gets nothing. Kayne comes by to compliment him by saying that “when you think of coffee and you think gross, but you look at this and think beautiful.”
A few minutes later Tim shows up. Since it’s the first runway he is going to give them the rundown. They have 3 hours left. Then its time for the L’Oreal makeup room, the TRESemmé hair salon, the Macys accessory wall and then if they get tired they can try one of Wendy’s new dollar menu items like the delicious chili and wash it down with a nice cool Pepsi.
Then, the models descend. Uli’s model looks at her dress and says in amazement “oh my god I would wear that!” Bonnie’s model has a boob problem. They keep falling out of her dress, so she decides to use lots of double sided tape to keep her fastened. Stacey’s dress is too sheer and she says she cant send iot down the runway as it would be “too provocative”, meaning we would get stray cooter shots. So she creates a last minute “coquettish” underwear on her extremely flat stomached model. She even sharpies in some hem lines.
Vincent meanwhile continues his descent into mental illness. Everyone is ragging on his ridiculous straw box that he is using as a hat. Especially now that he added chains to it. Uli says she was going to say something but he seemed so proud of it she didn’t have the heart. And its true, Vincent loves his little hat. He even lined the inside with tinfoil so as to make sure the government can’t scan your thought patterns.
Tim rounds them up and says its time for our runway show. “In fashion one day you are in, and the next day you are out.” Heidi tells our gathered designers. “There are fifteen of you know, 3 of you will make it to Olympus fashion week and one of you will be the winner of Project Runway“. Then she tells her what the booty is. A Spread in Elle magazine, a mentorship with INC: International Concepts Design (no Banana Republic this year?), A year of representation from designers management agency, the 2006 Saturn Roadster, and 100 grand to start their own line of clothes. Now lets meet our judges. Top American designer Michael Kors. Nina Garcia, and our guest judge is designer Kate Spade. Oh snap I dated a girl who wore Kate Spade! This episode is really gonna hit home!
Laura’s fur lined piece looked great to her. She was so happy in fact that she sad her “entire body was smiling”. Some of those smiles were vertical. Bradley’s looks like his model is wearing a sleeping bag, which of course, she is . Bradley tells us that he’s never had a piece go down a runway and he almost cried. Keith’s bed sheet dress looked fine, and he dismissed everyone slses as looking too costumey. Well, they were using coffee filters and straw hats keith, its not something they can control. Angela is another designer happy with her outfit. She was as happy as a “five year old on Christmas eve”. So she was happy, but not really happy otherwise she would have said Christmas morning.

Anyone up for s’mores?
The first person who didn’t like his piece was Malan. But he’s Malan and he loves everything he does so he just said he was afraid that “the art elements might be misperceived”. When Bonnie saw her dress she said that all she was thinking was “Oh my god I hope her boobs don’t fall out”. Take out the word don’t from that sentence and it’s exactly what I said sitting on my living room couch. What are the odds?


Katherine’s piece was a bunch of aqua blue plastic bags and a comforter. Then Michael Knight’s gross but not gross coffee filter dress. Then it was time for Vincent. And honestly, his piece wa a freaking mess. The huge cartoony pockets, the giant box on the womans head with chains wrapped around it. Even Kors gave it a confused look.

And don’t forget Jeffrey and his fabulous shooting feather bomb
After the runway show they bring all the designers onto the runway. Heidi then calls on the names of Alison, Bradley, Angela, Kayne, Milan, bonnie, Catherine, Michael and Uli. They all have made it to the next round. Heidi then tells them the rules. “The six of you remaining have the highest and the lowest scores. One will be made the winner, and one of you , vill be out!”
First up is Laura. Kors thinks her garment is chic and beautiful. He loves it. Then its time for Vincent. Heidi immediately says “I would have done without the hat. I have to say”. Well yeah you kind of have to, the woman is wearing a birdfeeder attachment on her head.
“With the hat you’re wondering how many drinks she’s had.” Well, looking at my handy dandy drink/stupid accessories ratio calculator, the answer is seven daiquiris. And if my calculations are correct if you add in a shot of Jaeger to that she would be sticking tampons in her nose.
Vincent, who professed his undying love for the hat an hour ago, is now backpedaling in earnest. “To be honest with you I was in question with the hat.” Yeah right. Well, sometimes less is more ” Heidi says. Yeah, if by less you mean “no basket hat” I mean it’s not like you can “tone down” something like that. It s a basket. On her head. With chains wrapped around it.
On to Keith’s. He says he was thinking two things. Gone with the wind and the Carol Burnett show. That you can look totally hot like Vivian Leigh did (shares the same birthday as me FYI), but he didn’t want it to be like Carol Burnett, who “looked like she was wearing a curtain rod”. Well, after going in my wayback machine I found out that in that sketch she actually was wearing a curtain rod Keith. In fact the curtain rod was the central part of the joke. Nina loves the buttons on the back. So much so that when she says she thinks its “adorable” her eyes actually roll back into her head.

FashionGasm!
Now it’s Stacey. They don’t like her models underwear is showing. And they all can see that her whole piece is unfinished. Kate spade thinks its messy and Kors says it doesn’t fit the woman correctly.
Robert. They love the back on Roberts’s piece. Kors says its very three dimensional. He thinks it’s charming.Jeffrey’s is a bit of a mess. Kors and Nina think the feather show on his runway model was distracting. The piece looks better without the jacket but the whole thing is confusing. Then Kors gives him the same warning about layers that they gave Santino last season. Don’t overdo it.
After the deliberations they bring out the contestants. They let Laura go and then announce the winner. It’s Keith. He won the challenge on his first dress. Kudos my friend. Then Heidi tells Robert that he is in and can leave the runway. And she then says the same thing for Vincent. Huh? Baskethead gets a pass? I smell reality show producers intervention. After all, we did find out that they do have a hand in the judging. I smell a rat.
It’s down to Jeffrey and Stacey. And the loser is…. Stacey. Where’s your Harvard degree now Stacey? Nothing can stop the power of the Auf! Backstage Stacey gets the gentle Tim Gunn “don’t let the door hit ya where the good lord slit ya” speech and she is gone.
So what did everyone else think? Good season so far? I like it, and think we have some real talents here. And of course there is the big “Controversy” that is shrouded in mystery that we have to look forward to. And of course, the model with the fractured eye socket. Should be a good season.
If you like it, spread it!:
39 Comments
Wow, first comment!! I’m almost glad I am such a loser that I am home on a Friday night. Or should I say quote unquote loser???
I am so happy to have Project Runway back, along with the great Tim Gunn and the great Ed Hill (and his always amusing battle with the punctuation and spelling).
Ed, you asked about Banana Republic being gone. They are out as a sponsor this year. Tim Gunn mentioned their dropping their sponsorship in the marathon interview he gave with the Chicago Tribune I linked to in the Road to Runway recap. It is well worth a read. They also made him return the clothes they gave him to wear on the show. They probably got tired of people blowing off their offer of ‘mentorship’.
As for this episode, we are off to a good start!! This is truly the best reality show ever.
seriously, what’s up with that neck? does it require medical treatment? everytime he comes on the screen it’s all i can stare at.
Great, great recap! You covered sooo many of the thoughts I had while watching. My favorite was your meanspirited way of poking fun of Stacey, the Harvard grad (hey, and you neglected to mention she got her undergrad at STANFORD…but she made a big point of it)!
I cheered in delight when she bragged of her degree (why is it relevant to Project Runway? then was the first to be booted!
I don’t know why Stanford/Harvard graduates think that they will succeed at whatever career they try, even if they clearly have no talent for it. She should go back to running http://www.chickengeorgerocks.com.
Thanks for the laughs!!! I truly enjoyed this recap so very much!
I’m actually kind of glad that Stacey is gone. By glad, I of course mean that I don’t care. She couldn’t use a sewing machine. That’s sort of necessary.
I do however think Vincent SHOULD have been gone first because nobody could be drunk enough to wear the dress he made.
What happened to that hyped up “Somebody will be leaving the show” thing?
So excited about this season…
First of all, Tim Gunn was on Best Week Ever tonight, and it was HYSTERICAL. He put his guns up (with sound effects!). You must see it.
Second, since Giraffe is such a ‘rock and roll’ kind of guy, is it possible that he stretched his neck out the way that people sometimes stretch out their earlobes?? Because really, there’s something totally unnatural about it.
Beth W.: My friend and I were talking about who would be getting the boot, and she thinks that it’s Keith, even though he won the first challenge. Because he said in his audition/tryout that he designed and made women’s clothes in collaboration with Todd Wyeth, but after he won the challenge he was bragging that it was the first dress he had ever made. So that’s my guess, too.
Oh, and Malan is GROSS.
I really liked the coffee filter dress and was kind of bummed that he didn’t get much air time. Malan is extremely annoying and I can’t wait for him to go…!
I didn’t hear if they are keeping the same models in the first episode like they did last year. Did anyone else? If so, it was Kayne, the pageant designer’s model from episode one. Although, of course he could still go and someone could get his model like Zulema did when she swiped Nick’s model last year. So this doesn’t necessarily mean he makes it to the finals. I was just so thrilled the damn show was back on I even TIVOed the Road To The Runway!! LOL
Tim Gunn said Banana Republic even made him give back the socks they gave him to wear. Feeling a little petty BR? Perhaps they are planning to sell them on e-bay. I would totally bid on Tim Gunn’s socks, though.
Laura’s chest freaks me out as well. It looks like a ten year old’s back put on a grown women’s front. I get the distinct impression that her kids are not allowed to touch mommy. I don’t think the casting special ever showed her touching them, just gazing at them fondly from a distance. It’s easy to have 5 kids and dress well when you can pass them off to a nanny.
Malan cracks me up. It’s obvious he’s fucking crazy, but amusing nonetheless. And I do feel really sorry for Vincent, but you hit the nail on the head with the tinfoil to keep out the government signals comment. That’s exactly the type of person he reminds me of.
elljay8, that’s just what I was thinking about Jeffrey. Maybe he’s actually from tribal Africa? Although his neck tattoo does say Detroit… well, I guess we’ll never know.
Anyway, I like the season so far, although the only thing I really paid much attention to was the runway show. Long live the Gunn!
Does anyone else start to vomit whenever they see that dude’s neck?
I seriously have to turn away each time I see it.
1. That guy’s neck is pretty gross. Can anyone tell what the tatt says? All I could make up is “Detroit”. I have never seen a novel on someone’s adam apple before. Also, take off the freaking hood once in a while, dude!
2. I am SHOCKED the “401K’ guy got past the first round with that freaking outfit! everytime I saw the model, with her shades and that wicker flowerpot hat, I just burst out in laughter. I mean COME ON!!
3. Tim Gunn is back and better than ever!
4. Does anyone else get annoyed with Heidi’s greeting outbursts? “HELLLLO! Welcome to the Runway!”
I thought Robert’s dress (with the red bows) should have won this challenge. Given what he used, he made a very nice dress. Keith had a freaking sheet to work with. WOW, innovative. Anyways, this season is starting out great! I don’t like Laura but she made a great-looking outfit, and so did Michael Knight with the coffee filters.
About Jeffrey Seberia, DAMN! I honestly can’t remember much he said because everytime he came on the screen, I would stare at that neck. It doesn’t look right.
And, elljay8 (#5), I saw Tim Gunn on Best Week Ever too and he was so great. Loved the guns and when he joked about Suri Cruise. I missed him so much.
If you guys haven’t read the Chicago Tribune article, PLEASE READ IT! It is Tim Gunn at his best, for you all Tim Gunn lovers!!! It’s a really great interview. He really dishes! It’s fabulous.
Jeffrey’s neck freaks me out too… but I think he got the tattoo just for the show – he didn’t have it on his audition tape, did he? Malan is Terrible. Yay PR is back! so much to love, so much to hate.
Did some looking around and found this stuff about the tattoo guy.
His myspace (ick :-{)
http://www.myspace.com/bowieichiban
The tattoo says Harrison Detroit (his son’s name and his gf is originally from here) and then underneath in a different language it says the love of my life.
hb
My nomination for this year’s “Santino Rice Memorial So-Full-of-Himself-It-Hurts Award” goes to…
Jeffrey.
And Keith.
And Malan.
I rhink there’s a phenomenon with reality shows…The first season, the contestants are honest. The second, they’re agressive, seeking the prize and “playing the game.” By the third season, they’re only on the show as a vehicle for their own star-making. And we’ve got that in spades.
Great recap, EdHill. How could they NOT eliminate Vincent?!?! I thought Stacy’s outfit was much better as a whole look than Vincent’s. For once I agreed with the judges on the winner. Keith’s was the best though I liked Kayne’s and the coffee filter one as well.
Ahh, the pretentions of pseudo designers mixed with the pretentions of reality show contestants: so special.
I checked out the Chicago Tribune article that Junkie posted and was disappointed to learn that schlocky product placement ads are supposed to be even more prevalent this season, than ever before. Ed, it wasn’t just any old champaign they were drinking on the roof, it was Moet and Chandon champaign! I read where Heidi (Mrs. integrity) had a hissy fit and refused to handle the bottle on camera, because she thought the maneuver was too obtrusive.
It looks like Vincent mixed too much of the champaign with his lithium tablets, because he must have been more hammered than Kate Spade’s toes when he designed that breadbasket hat. And way to commit dude, when Michael Kors was busting your balls about it! His dress was bad, but no worse than that bed sheet fed through a cube steak grinder that Jeffery the Giraffe (from Toys “R” Us) put together.
Is it just me, or does Malan look like a gay version of Benecio Del Toro?
Did anyone else notice that Malan does a great Austin Powers immitation…even down to the laugh? All he needs is the glasses, the teeth, and to quit using the hair oil.
I wish Michael’s coffee filter dress had been one of the top three instead of merely being one of the pack that got a pass through to the next challenge. Keith’s bed sheet dress was pretty and well made but wasn’t as innovative as Michael’s. I wouldn’t have picked Keith’s dress to win over Michael’s or Robert’s, but who knows, maybe it looked better up close and in person.
As for basket case Vincent’s pass from the judges, I definitely get a whiff of producer interference. Granted, Stacey’s dress was a bit of a mess, but it wasn’t nearly as bizarre as Vincent’s outfit, which looked like something someone will wear to TomKat’s Scientology wedding, whenever it takes place. And Jeffrey’s outfit looked like something I could find at the salvation army. Even he couldn’t defend it to Michael, Heidi, and Nina. But since Jeffrey and Vincent are lunatics (re: good tv) and Stacey was nice and boring, it was no question as to who would get auf’ed.
All in all, a very good episode. Can’t wait to see how the rest of the season shapes up.
Yay!!! I love this show.
Thank you for a very entertaining recap.
I was dying over the basket hat. I can’t believe he didn’t go home. What else I can’t believe…that giraff neck! Man you called it on that one!
I just want to see Malan torn to shreds at some point.
YAY!!!!!!!!!
60% Matthew Broderick + 30% Chris Kattan + 10% Al Gore = Malan (100% irritating)
I agree that Robert’s and Michael’s designs were way better (i.e. more original) than Keith’s.
I want to punch Laura in her painted-on frown. Her five children are probably the most spoiled little monsters ever and her coat looked like an overpriced Christmas ornament.
Michael’s coffee filter dress was adorable! Such a good idea. But I think Robert’s dress should have won. The only really innovative thing that the winning dress had was the red buttons on the back. Blah.
So, has Tim Gunn ever said why they won’t let him be a judge? I think he has more taste in his little finger than Nina Garcia has in a whole pile of Elle Magazines. (Elle has hideous fashion; E. Jean is the only good thing in it.)
Is that “ick” about him or his (allegedly!) MySpace account? I hate MySpace; over 99.998% of the pages there are illegible. Haven’t people heard about good web page design before? That said, I was shocked that the horrible dress that was made from the felt liner under the mattress box and the padding didn’t get the designer immediately “auf”d.
And yes, Vincent reminds me of Austin Powers.
I’m with you on the Nina Garcia thing, MrsPetersen (#23). She drives me nuts; she’s got stupid hair, horsey teeth, and an indecipherable accent…ew, I just realized that Malan is Bizzarro Nina Garcia! They better not touch, or the universe might implode or something.
The funniest part is that I totally photoshopped that picture of Jeffrey’s neck and stretched it out a good foot and no one noticed.
EdHill, I’m so glad you fessed up about the photoshop because I was sitting here thinking that I didn’t recall seeing the gigantic neck — just the gross tattoo.
Two comments: coffee filter dress was INNOVATIVE. Bed sheet dress: NOT.
And I loves me some Tim Gunn, but when he said MIW for the first time, it seemed as though he was immitating himself. He knows it’s a catch-phrase now and it didn’t seem genuine.
And I never would had you not ‘feesed up to the deed.
Wow, EdHill, not only was this a ” ” fabulous recap, but some hot photoshopping too . . . I did think it looked incredibly long, (or longer) but that thought didn’t occur to me, and I do Photoshop all day–I must s*ck!
I don’t mind Laura’s flatness, though I might not emphasize it quite as much as that first dress–I’m looking forward to her designs–not for me, but should be interesting in a completed looking way . . . love the thoughts on her and kiddies though–talk about wire hanger potential!!!
Robert’s my favorite so far, and I liked coffee filter dress the best too. Still don’t know all the names, but I will.
Thanks also for the Tim Gunn interview post–excellent behind the scenes dish!!!! LOVED IT!!!
And HoneyBunny–Great researching!!! Don’t know if I’ll go there, but I think his designs may be interesting too . . .
Where’s LQ!? I miss you . . .
Less ragging on Laura, please…you know, it IS possible to look good and be a good mother too (my mom’s done it for 26 years, with three kids). And I don’t think she’s a single mom, meaning there’s another parent to hold down the fort while she’s gone.
Her coat was cute.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought Michael Knight (hip hop coffee filter guy) was underrated.
I’m not saying the winner’s wasn’t good, but if they were going on originality, it wasn’t the greatest. I mean, a bedsheet makes a dress. Obvious. Coffee filters make a cute little dress?
Cool!
For that reason (and the fact that he seems relatively normal and not an a-hole), I’m already rooting for Mr. Knight. I’m also wondering if all of Robert’s (the Mattel designer who made the white dress with red bows, I think that’s his name) clothes will look like Barbie outfits, and if he’ll get chastised for that. Tattoo Neck Boy’s getup was AWFUL, but of course they’re keeping him (and Malan) for ratings, hoping they’ll find another Santino (without the onion smell
I love Malan’s sleazy oiliness. He is Edmund Blackadder and Mike Meyer’s love child. All we need now is Hugh Laurie to guest judge with a “brooch of purest green” while popping Vicodin. God bless PR.
conrad5 (#18)
KungFoodie (#19)
You are both right. Malan also reminds me of Tim Curry, too. (Sorry, Tim.)
stacyrocks, I agree Robert’s dress. I would actually wear that dress – how cute were those red bows? As for Keith’s dress, I think I saw a similar one at Loehmann’s the other day. Bor-ing.
One thing that made me nervous was I didnt see much of Michael Knight on the previews for the season. Hopefully this doesnt mean he’ll be exiting early.
And maybe this is weird, but I think Keith is hot. Is he gay or just metro?
Hey there juddfan-sweetheart. I don’t have BRAVO at my new place in the sticks. I’m trying to decide whether I break down and pay more to upgrade or not. You know how I love to fight the power, so I may have to watch PR3 Mondays on NBC. Missed it tonight. Whoops! But of course I loved the recap (I love everything EdHill does and yes I knew about the photoshopping). I’m also partial to the coffe filter dress. The bidding on it is up to $105 last I checked.
Apparently Keith did the Fashion Unthinkable…he copied other designers’ work and passed it off as his own in the audition phase. Not only that, but he TRACED over existing shots of models on runways wearing the fashions to create his drawings!That’s why his stuff looks like people in action…becasue they were.
I’m guessing that he is the big controversy that was hinted at in all the promos as being a PR first.
Personally, I think Malan looks like the love child of Alan Cummings and Austin Powers… he made me throw up in my mouth a little bit.
Sorry to hear the powers are getting you down, LQ! I’m sure the Monday broadcast is a good alternative. How ’bout the BB7? I’ll be on there too, hope to keep in touch!
love, your crackwhore sister!
ps. Tivo-diva, I think you nailed the birth source!
NOODLE, Keith frequently visits the Paul Lynde Bitter Queen Memorial…. ok!
(any Frank DeCaro fans out there? LOL)