Survivor: No One Cares, Russell

Survivor

By Schoonie | | 8:15 pm | 24 Comments
S19E14025.jpg

Seriously, can you stop talking about how you got robbed? I just want you and your tiny, tiny shirt to go away. It’s the morning of Day 37, and Russell is up early while the rest of the castaways sleep. Of course, this means that Russell has to complain and bitch about being awake while everyone else is sleeping, because what’s the point of being up early if you can’t use it to feel superior to others?

“I’m FOCUSED, I’m better than them,” he says, despite the fact that Jaison and Mick have won immunities while Russell…has not. “I should be here with superstars,” he says. Stupid foreshadowing, making me watch him again next season.

Russell talks to Natalie, telling her that she should really try her best, because if Brett wins, he won’t be able to save her, since they’ll need the three guys to stay and try to beat him. “My goal was to be the underdog and slide through, and it’s worked,” she says, worrying that she can’t beat Brett. Take a page out of the Book of Tonya Harding, people. It’s not that hard.

S19E14012.jpg

From the right side of the screen, with a tire iron. That’s all it takes.

Russell is doing his “preparation” for the immunity challenge by smack talking Brett. “I can OUTDO HIM when it comes to pain,” he says. This is what he had to get up early for? This guy is so lame.

Immunity Challenge. There’s a simple obstacle course with some puzzle pieces at the end, and the contestants will retrieve them and then assemble the puzzle to win immunity. Jaison takes a mean spill right at the beginning and finishes the course last, but the whole thing is all about the puzzle anyway. It has the Survivor Logo on it, so it’s definitely not as hard as the puzzles we’ve seen in the past. Russ and Mick come close, but Brett finishes first, meaning that a Foa Foa is finally going to be sent home.

The Foa Foas look dejected as they return to camp. Natalie knows that she’s in trouble, asking Russell what the plan is. He promises her that he’s going to try and keep her. “I want her around because I can beat her! She’s been riding my coattails this whole time,” he says assuredly. Hey, how did that work out? I forgot.

S19E14013.jpg

“Hahaha…second place is mine!”

Russell walks up to a Jaison lounging in the shelter some more, declaring to use that he’s pretty much checked out of the game. “Natalie is definitely stronger than he is,” Russell says. It’s really taken this long to figure that out? I love how having a penis automatically makes you awesome on Survivor. I’ve never understood that. He also thinks Mick is a good option, since he thinks Mick will beat him in front of a jury. I must say, after knowing how this ends, Russell’s predictions in this sequence are beyond hilarious. It’s like opposite day up in this bitch.

So Russell gets Mick and Jaison to agree to vote for each other, putting the decision in the hands of Brett and Natalie. While I do think Russell completely shat the bed strategically once he got to the finals, he’s does a pretty good job here at manipulating the other people. He’s essentially made promises to all these people to go to the finals together, which they have all believed. Of course, he seems to think that this guarantees him the win, when in fact Natalie, Mick and Jaison are the smart ones for knowing to go to the finale with a pompous ass clown. But whatever, he’s the GREATEST STRATEGIST EVER! Let’s throw him a thirteen episode party!

Tribal Council. The Foa Foa jury is clearly ecstatic to see Brett with the immunity necklace. Probst asks Brett if he was “sandbagging it”, waiting until the right time to strike. Yes, Probst, it was Brett’s plan to completely blow it strategically, allow all his friends to be voted out, and then dominate the endgame via the expedient solving of puzzles. He’s a genius!

S19E14014.jpg

Next up: solving a Rubik’s Cube in 30 seconds.

Brett correctly answers no to this question, telling Probst that it’s about frame of mind; he just wants it more than the Foa Foas do, because he knows he’s going home if he loses. Probst talks briefly with the Foa Foas, but they basically tell him what we already know: that the vote is basically a matter of Who Can Beat Brett versus Who Is Good To Take To The End. A Tribal Council full of insights, people.

Time to vote. Mick regretfully votes for Jaison, telling us that he’s checked out. We also see Jaison apologetically vote for Mick. We don’t see the others. When Probst reads the votes, there’s one for Mick and the rest are for Jaison and he’s done. His final words are quite pissy: “I am very upset at Russell, he broke his word to me. I’m rooting for Brett, because he is who we were, and underdog that really wants to win.” Hmm. The writing seems to be on the wall for Russell, no? How were we all surprised?

Back at camp the next morning, Russell gets Brett alone, asking Brett if he thinks he can beat him in the top three. Brett thinks that it’d be close, and Russell plays the “I want to beat the best” card, because apparently Brett is one of the best despite the fact that I had no idea who he was until about two weeks ago. He offers a top three deal to Brett and they shake on it, and even Brett isn’t fully buying it. Russell, of course, is super proud of himself, all “Never hurts to have insurance, right?” and cackling. I really think that neither person in that deal has any intention of keeping it, so I’m not sure what the point of that was. Whatever, I guess he’s the genius.

S19E14015.jpg

“This says ‘No one is buying it.’”

Turns out there’s new treemail, and guess what? They’re going on a walk during which they will remember the previous players! Shocked, I know. I mean, we’ve seen this 19 times now. It is not interesting and no one cares. I mean, do we really need to remember Ben and Yasmin?

Anyway, let’s see what generic pleasantries everyone will be spouting this time: Marisa existed and was apparently a strong lady. Russell seems to think that if he hadn’t gotten rid of her, he’d be gone. He’s said this more than once, and frankly, I don’t buy it. If that’s his best strategic argument, he can cram it. Also, her voice is almost unbearable. Mike almost had a heart attack, and was also slightly racist. Betsy says…stuff. Ben was lots racist. Yasmin was loud. Ashley I had completely forgotten about. Other Russell thinks he would have won, and he says some stuff about his family that doesn’t make a whole lot of sense and is oddly morbid. Liz was sort of cool, and she would have gotten a lot farther if she had just gotten one Tribal Council farther. I feel like we would have been rooting for her right now. Russell thanks Galu for voting out Erik and making a move for Foa Foa. “Voting him out was your downfall,” he says. That’s not even close to true: when you’re up eight to four, losing one person is not your downfall.

Kelly says…stuff. Laura talks for a long time about being an “awesome grandma” that makes no sense at all. Everything these people say fall into one of two categories: stuff that’s generic and stuff that makes no sense whatsoever. Does anyone know where the bathroom is? I have some magazines to catch up on during this segment.

John and hauls a rope in a Speedo, or possibly very scary underwear which I do not remember. He still believes that breaking the tie was a good move, despite the fact that he was immediately voted out afterwards. How does anyone think that’s a good move when they’re almost immediately punished for it? Would that not persuade you that it had perhaps been a mistake?

Dave was apparently hilarious and misunderstood, bringing the total number of things he has in common with Pauly Shore to “one”. Monica was “the fakest person here” according to Russell, which tells you just how badly she got to him during that brief period when she decided to strategize. When it’s Shambo turn, Foa Foa thanks her for switching. “My whole life, I’ve been uplifter of the underdog,” she says, which tells you exactly why she ended up switching, which is very interesting sociologically. If Galu had been the team down four to eight, do you think she would have stayed loyal? Jaison gets remembered too, but even the Final Four are all “Wasn’t he just here yesterday? Why are we doing this?”

Having reached the end of their producer mandated spirit walk, the Final Four symbolically burn the masks of their former competitors. They all stand there with their hands on their hips and look pensive as helicopters capture aerial shots, meant to portray just how majestic and important this all really is. It ends up falling somewhere between “Completely Cheesy” and “Swiped From An Episode Of Captain Planet”. I realize that no one has ever used the adjective “majestic” to describe Russell before, but that’s apparently what they’re going for here. He’s like a tiny penguin king!

S19E14016.jpg

They spent a long time arguing over who got to be ‘Heart’.

Final Immunity Challenge. The contestants will place a small wooden statue on the end of a pole and balance it using both their hands. Every two minutes, they’ll add another foot long section of pole, making the statue harder to balance, and then keep their hands on the lowest section. The last person with a statue wins immunity. I must say, I would be terrible at this. Once there are about five sections, Mick’s statue drops and he’s the first one out. Natalie’s statue drops right after, so it’s down to Russell and Brett. Somewhere off camera, the producers are so happy that they poop themselves.

It begins to get windy and the poles start swaying, which can’t help. The time comes to add another section of pole, bringing to total to seven feet. Brett adds to his pole immediately while Russell takes the strategy of waiting him out. Unfortunately, this also means that Russell has to hustle to add his section of pole, getting it on just before the allotted time runs out. The remainder of the challenge is actually pretty exciting: Brett’s pole wobbles and bends, and then Russell’s pole wobbles and bends, and it’s very tense and Natalie almost passes out.

S19E14017.jpg

“Oh maaaaaa worrrrrrrd.”

Eventually, Brett’s pole wobbles enough that the statue falls, and what do you know? Russell is actually able to back up his shit talking for once, so he wins immunity. Of course, he can’t help overstepping his bounds some more. “This challenge just won me the million dollars! I am a millionaire,” he says cockily in confessional. While that is supposedly true, I don’t think it’s going to be in the way he’s hoping. I love how he can even turn things that you would normally give him props for into hilarious failures. I should have watched the finale first, and then watched the entire season. That would have made things much more tasty. The recaps would be mad late, though.

Speaking of which, I would love a retrospective YouTube montage of what are now giant Russell FAILS, if someone could hook me up with that. Just a parade of shit-talking that never, ever comes to fruition. Hooray for other people’s pain! That’s what Christmas is really about.

Back at camp, everyone high fives Russell for winning. Brett is already talking about how much fun he had playing the game while sad memorial music plays in the background, in case you’re wondering whether the producers are going to make this suspenseful.

Brett’s all “All I have to fall back on is Russell’s promise,” and you can tell that even he doesn’t really believe it. Russell starts talking to Natalie and Mick about how awesome it’s going to be when he wins, and they look sort of sick. You can tell that they’re really tired of hearing him yap. Can you imagine having no one to talk to but Russell for thirty-nine days? Ponder that shit.

S19E14018.jpg

“Yeah, that million dollars is MINE. NO WAY anything can go wrong at this point. Dumb ass girl.”

At this point on DAY THIRTY-EIGHT, Russell figures out that he may have pissed off a bunch of people and that this might not be as easy as he thinks, so he goes to Brett and tells him that he’s a great guy, but that he doesn’t want to force a tie to keep him in the game. Mick, meanwhile, is super paranoid, telling Natalie that he suspects that something is up. “Oh ma god, you are so paranoid,” she tells him. He’s freaking out here mostly because he’s slowly realizing that he’s probably screwed either way, whether he goes home or not. That can’t be pleasant to deal with.

Tribal Council. Probst’s love for Russell is in full effect here. Mick and Natalie get yes or no questions, like “Was sending Brett home a done deal once he lost?”, and Russell gets questions like “Is it hard to send someone awesome like Brett home when you are equally awesome and want to go to the end with other awesome people?” It’s sort of gross. “Is there part of you that can appreciate the competitor in Brett?” he says to Russell only. Probst doesn’t ask Natalie or Mick whether they want to go to the end with the best, because the insinuation is that they are inferior. Probst crosses new lines of inappropriate favoritism every season.

S19E14019.jpg

“Russell, would you say that you are the best person ever to play this game, and also way better than these other people, and also willing to come over to my house and eat a dinner that I prepare for you while wearing little clothing, and then maybe we can spoon afterwards?”

Time to vote. We see Mick and Natalie vote Brett. Of course, when the votes are read Mick gets one and the rest go to Brett, so he’s done. Brett’s final words are as generic as he is. I mean, he literally says nothing. He seems nice enough, but whatever, peace out.

It’s the morning of Day 39, and the typical feast is waiting for the Final Three when they wake up. Russell is all “I brought two people with me,” he says, which is patently ridiculous since he couldn’t have gotten there without him and Natalie has made several moves throughout the game. Russell begins playing an unnecessary mind game here, telling them that he brought them the whole way and asking Natalie what she’s planning on saying to the jury. Natalie gets all defensive while Russell continues, telling them both that he’s letting the whole jury know that Natalie and Mick have been in the backseat this whole time. “He needs to be reminded that he couldn’t have made it without us,” Mick says indignantly. “We’re all sitting in the same place.”

“Don’t make me make you look STUPID,” he says to them, spitting out this last word. He lies in the hammock, listing which five people are going to vote for him. “And then, I am another millionaire,” he says nonchalantly. He’s just kind of being a dick here. He clearly hasn’t thought that this might actually fire them up and make them want to beat him more instead of beating them down.

S19E14020.jpg

“Man, I have TOTALLY got this wrapped up.”

Mick, Natalie and Russell light the camp on fire, denying millions of kids with pediatric diseases lots of auction dollars. “If these people won over me, that would be a shame,” Russell says. “I’ve played better than anybody in history.” I’ve said it once, and I’ll say it again: not even CLOSE to true.

Final Tribal Council! The jury enters, complete now that Brett’s been added. Probst makes the interesting point that for the first time in history, everyone in the finals has voted for every single person on the jury, meaning that they should theoretically be on an even playing field. Time for opening statements: Mick’s is actually pretty terrible. He tells the jury that he made it a point not to promise them too much or treat them terribly. His insinuation is that he’s not an asshole like Russell, but he doesn’t actually say that and he probably should have.

Natalie tells them that everyone told her that she couldn’t do it before she left, says that people told her she couldn’t do it, that she went outside her comfort zone and has been humbling, and then she says “thank you” to the jury, which is always, always a terrible move. If you lost a game, and someone told you “Thank you for losing!” wouldn’t you be pissed off at them?

And now: Russell. He says that came to play hard and to win the game (apparently everyone else came to lose) and then made huge strategic moves. He started in his own tribe by getting rid of Marisa and Betsy, and then he went to Galu and got rid of Kelly and then went to John to get him to switch and get rid of Laura.
Let’s go backwards: the John thing, he had very little to do with. That was mostly Shambo, whose resolve forced a tie that John was unwilling to commit to. It was mostly circumstance and had little to nothing to do with Russell. Getting rid of Kelly was the result of an idol, and while he found it, that’s not really strategy, save for the part where the Foa Foas as a group convinced the tribe he didn’t have it. And as for getting rid of Marisa and Betsy, I’m sure we are all wowed and surprised when a middle aged woman and cute girl get voted off early. That certainly never happens! Also, his point is that Marisa and Betsy “suspected him”, like he’s kept it a huge secret that he’s been sneaky. The truth is, everyone knew Russell was sneaky, some people just chose to take advantage of it by going to the end with him.

My point is, he hasn’t really done that much.

“If either Mick or Natalie has outwitted or outplayed me, than give them the money, but I doesn’t think they have,” he says. There’s certainly an argument to be made for Natalie, I’d say. I’m also not going to argue that Russell doesn’t deserve to win, because he does. I just also think that Natalie deserved to win.

Time for questions! Jaison is first. You can kind of tell that he’s bitter just by how he looks. “I want you to give the jury info about who you really are,” he says. “If you don’t, I will.” Natalie tells the jury that she’s in pharmaceutical sales and gave up her job to come to the show. Russell tells them that he’s a businessman, and that this is the first business he’s had that’s been successful. Mick says that he just finished medical school and is 320 thousand dollars in debt, so he could really use the money. Jaison announces to the jury that while says that none of them have lied, Natalie makes a lot of money, Russell is wealthiest guy in game, and Mick’s got a well paid fellowship at one of best hospitals in America. Essentially, Jaison is trying to keep anyone from voting based on need.

Next up: Shambo, who really should be wearing a bra.

S19E14021.jpg

Man, she looks fancy.

She begins by apologizes to America for dismantling Galu. “I’m really beginning to question that call,” she says indignantly. Prepare for her to say a lot of things indignantly, by the way. “Mick: you have got to be kidding me,” she begins. Kidding about what, who knows. Prepare for her to make a lot of statements without backing them up, too. “Would you agree that your overall gameplay could be called….feckless?” she says. He tells her that he doesn’t know what the word “feckless” means, and she’s all “I’m done with you,” because he has ruined her fun. This is all an opportunity for Shambo to look superior, as you will discover. She’s essentially Lisi, asking how many zeroes are in a million dollars.

“Natalie, I’m thinking of a word, and it starts with a C. Can you finish it?” Wow. That is both inappropriate and incredibly hypocritical, since Natalie wasn’t the one treating others like shit throughout the game and throwing tantrums. “I’m going to let you finish it Shambo,” Natalie says, embarrassed for Shambo, as we all should be.

“COATTAIL!” Shambo yells. “How do you think America will see your gameplay?” Natalie’s answer is that she thinks people will see her as the girl who “showed up in a sundress and gold wedges”, someone who should have been voted out first but “had enough intuition to notice that aggressive girls got voted out”. All pretty valid, nothing too out of line, right?

Shambo goes “Wow, that is major BS, I’m just cracking up on the inside right now.” Over what? It will forever remain a mystery. Do not expect Shambo to explain herself, or to apply logic to her pronouncements! Just who do you think you are?

“Neither of you are getting my vote,” she says as if Mick or Natalie ever expected to get it. “Thanks for playing!” she says like it’s already done and Russell has won. How did that turn out for them, again? I forgot. This is all so, so tasty to rewatch.

Brett. “Mick, if we were going on a bro date together, what would we do?” Mick is like “WTF?” and Brett has to explain what a ‘bro date’ is. Mick’s like, “I would wake you up with a little sweet nothing, a little tickle on the nose,” he says, taking the question a little too seriously. He gets all generic about it, telling him they’d go eat and talk about sports and girls. Turns out he was asking to see how much Mick had invested in Brett as a human being. Looks like Mick knows Brett just as well as the audience does. ZING!

S19E14022.jpg

“Question one: What is my name?”

Kelly. She tells Natalie that when she was in the game, she had to rely on herself (which I don’t remember seeing a lot of), and that she was hoping to see the same thing from Natalie but ended up extremely disappointed. “Well, I may be not as good at physical challenges, but I got better throughout the game,” Natalie says. I’m confused, because from where I was standing Natalie did a pretty damn good job at challenges.

Kelly makes a bitchface and moves on to Russell, asking him if the way he acts during the game is the way he acts in real life. When he says no, she wants three words to replace the “outwit, outplay, outlast” motto he’s been espousing. “It might be hard to believe, but: honor integrity and loyalty,” he says. This question is very unfair to Russell, because people shouldn’t be judged for who they are during the game, because it’s, you know, a GAME and all. Of course, it’s been revealed since the finale that Russell is a giant asshole outside the game as well, but that’s no matter.

Monica, who looks HOT. She says that while she’s seen Russell’s “key moves”, she hasn’t seen a lot of passion from Natalie and Monica, and wants to see some fight. She asks Mick why he deserves the money over the other two, and he plays the whole “I’m a nice guy” card, talking about how Russell’s ego is out of hand and that his behavior does not merit a million dollars. Russell interrupts here to say that Mick “did the same thing”. “He didn’t mind that I was being a snake when he was giving me high-fives about it,” Russell says. While that may be a good comeback in this instance, doesn’t that contradict Russell’s main argument that he did everything, since it means Mick was an active participant? I feel like Russell really, really botched this last part here. If he’s going to take the route where he appeals to the jury’s game playing side, he may have wanted to actually make some solid, logical argument for himself, which I’m not seeing at ALL.

Dave. He just wants to know what they each think their chances are at winning. Mick says 25%, Natalie says 30%, and Russell says that he came in larger, but that right now he’s at about 55%. Enlightening. Next!

Laura. “Russell, what did you learn about me that enabled you to beat me?” I’m not sure why she’s asking this, because the answer is obviously “Shambo hates you because she’s a twelve year old with a mullet” He strokes her ego and tells her that she was “the biggest threat in Galu” and “Controlled a lot”. At this, she looks like she was about to cry, and that’s when you can tell that she really, really wanted this.

S19E14023.jpg

John. “Mick, give me the hard sell. Blow my mind right now,” he says. Mick’s response is lame: “In terms of character, you won’t find a better person. With Russell, the ends don’t justify means, and that’s who you’re giving money to if you vote for him.” He also calls himself a “stand up dude” repeatedly. I am not a fan of anyone calling themselves “good people”. That is a pronouncement for someone else to make. Mick’s argument is also a pretty weak, if you ask me. Mick really blew it here, too. You can kind of tell that Natalie won by default, since she was the only one making any sort of logical argument, albeit a tenuous one.

And now, Erik, who’s had the most time to think about what to say here, which means: pretentious speech. He tells the three of them that he doesn’t need to hear anything from them. He tells Mick he was a terrible leader who did nothing with the position that he was awarded. He tells Russell very emphatically that they have “absolutely nothing” in common, and at this point he begins to cry. “This is the first time anyone has gotten to the right place by behaving the wrong way,” he says, going for incredulous but landing somewhere between over-rehearsed and unintentionally hilarious.

“Natalie: people will say that you don’t deserve to win, but why is it less admirable to stand in the back than Russell, who gets a free pass for doing what he did?” He turns to the jury and announces that “perception doesn’t meet reality” which literally means nothing at all in this instance, and he’s basically just trying to sound smart by saying things he’s heard in movies and on TV at this point.

S19E14024.jpg

“I’M OUT OF ORDER? YOU’RE OUT OF ORDER!!!”

“In a reality filled with arrogance (shot of Russell) and “delusional entitlement”(shot of Mick), maybe and the person who is the least deserving is actually the most deserving.” My favorite part of Erik’s whole speech is when he points at Mick and says “delusional entitlement” at the end of making a twenty minute speech about how terrible it is to have morals and end up on the jury as a result. Classic.

Commercials. I love the Radio Shack spot featuring Biz Markie. “Oh, SNAP? Guess what I saw?”

Back from the break, it’s time to vote for the winner. There will be no closing statements (at least not that we get to see). We watch Erik votes for “Ratalie”, which he means nicely, if you can believe it. Sham votes for “Russel”, which makes me think of Russet Potatoes. Who doesn’t know how to spell Russell, seriously? Those are all the votes we get to see. At this point, I was pretty positive Russell was going to win. In fact, my notes say “7-2 Russell”, because I figured Natalie would get Brett and Erik’s votes.

Probst walks away with the votes, and we’re in Hollywood for the final. Natalie, Russ and Mick all look much better. Some people said Natalie was wearing too much makeup, and maybe I’ve spent too much time in the South, but I thought she looked pretty good. Russell’s shirt, however, is about eight sizes too small.

S19E14025.jpg

Probst talks forever and ever about how great this season has been (seriously, worst season ever) before getting to the voting. Erik’s vote for Natalie is first, then Shambo’s for Russell (lots of cheering for Russ, BTW), then another apiece for Natalie and Russell, and then the rest are for Natalie and she wins, unbelievably.

So…that’s it, you guys! An unremarkable end to an unremarkable season. I’ll see everyone on February 11th.

About

Like most people in America, Schoonie watches entirely too much reality television.  Unlike most people, Schoonie gets to share his opinions with the world, which is pretty rad.  Currently living in Chicago, Schoonie's been with Tvgasm since 2006.  He spends his free time writing Survivor fan fiction (Letters to Penthouse, all featuring Rupert!) , playing with his cover band, and playing with his other cover band. Also, this one time, Lisi fell.

24 Comments

  1. 1
    zerocool
    Posted December 23, 2009 at 8:50 pm

    Schoonie, I know we disagree about how much fun it was to watch this season. Russell & Shambo made it interesting when it probably wouldn’t have been otherwise. But I want to say thanks for your fantastic recaps. They have to be a lot of work.

    I’ll just say this, when watching Erik, I thought who knew he was a feminist at heart? I thought it was a pretty good speech. I hate it when the jurors ask stupid questions that are about themselves (such as Laura’s question). But considering Galu was incredibly dumb, their questions were bound to be dumb too.

  2. 2
    itchy
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 12:50 am

    At least it’s been a fine season for recaps, so thanks for that, Schoonie.

    By the time Erik’s speech came around, it was clear the choice was between Mick and Nat –since very few of the jury seemed to care to hear what Russell had to say, didn’t even bother to question him.

    Brett did a fine job of exposing Mick’s own lack of a social game. And Erik provided the nail in the coffin with what I thought was a very important idea.

    Also, yes, it’s easy to forget that Natalie was instrumental in winning a number of challenges, and was central to most of the blindsides.

    So for me, a satisfying ending to a really frustrating season. I just hated the fact that they focused the whole season around a single character and just ignored the real gameplay — and I especially hate that the whole season turned out to be one giant season-long red herring.

    What a bunch of bullshit. It’s like reading a great novel only to find out that it was ‘all a dream.’

    I almost would have prefered Russell to win, in that sense, since they made such a fuss about him.

    So fuck you, producers, fuck you editors, and fuck you Jeff Probst for continuing to insist that Russell is some kind of great strategist when it’s clear that he’s just a nasty ol’ penguin (tee-hee! thanks for that one Schoonie).

    As for the All-star season, I initially had the thought that Russell would have some kind of unfair advantage going in there as the only person no one knew. But maybe that backfires on him? Because it seems to me, the first person to eliminate is the unknown quantity. Regardless, his character is so loathsome, I can’t imagine any of them keeping him around for very long.

    He only stayed on this season because he had no real competition in the villain category — Ben was just a loser, not a villain. Otherwise he had the field to himself. But on a tribe filled with ‘villains’…well, no way he’d survive the feeding frenzy.

  3. 3
    Tadow
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 4:28 am

    Thanks for the recap, I was SO happy that Russell lost, cause that’s what it’s really about. Nothing against Nat, I think she deserved it out of that group.

    Kinda liked Eric’s speech, though it was super rehearsed. Now, maybe it’s because I just spent a semester in grad school having theory poured into my head, but I can see how Eric’s point that the juror’s perception is not reality.

    And I REALLY thought Mick said he’d wake Brett with a “pickle on the nose.”

  4. 4
    tadow
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 4:30 am

    Grrr, I should really proofread. delete: “how”

  5. 5
    philo
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 5:57 am

    Shambo tried too hard to pull off a Susan Hawk-like speech. Hope this is the last I ever see of her.

    Russell’s arrogance ahead of the final tribal council while the three were at camp was unbelievable. Sitting back in the hammock telling Mick and Natalie his final speech. Russell’s face at the final when the votes were read was priceless, though I think Russell started to feel his victory slipping away at the final tribal.

    Glad Survivor Nat won and not Big Brother Nat this year.

  6. 6
    soapboxx
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 7:33 am

    I think Russell got so much screen time by default. Brett’s personality did not make for good camera time. Whenever he had a cameo his remarks were dull and like watching paint dry. Same to Mick. It’s possible most of Galu was the same way. If they just get on camera to wax poetic and philosophical about their tribe mates and “surviving”, it’s no wonder they got no screen time. I’m very glad Russell lost although I do think someone needs to grab a defibrillator and rush over to Mr. D’s house. I haven’t seen him in the comments since Russell’s loss and he might well be splayed out in front of his TV clutching his chest crying “no no no!”.

    As for Allstars I will be pissed if they let Johnny Fairplay back in because he practically walked off the last Allstars, begging to be voted out. I really don’t like it when a contestant takes a spot away from someone else that would have loved to be there. Also what was up with CBS going to extreme lengths to hold a spot for Natalie? Probst says she missed 3 casting calls or something? How does that make all the applicants who stood in line for hours feel when they got their five minutes with a shitty PA then “Next!”?

    Thanks again Schoonie, you made this season bearable.

    P.S. Am I the only one who liked Coach from a pure entertainment level?

  7. 7
    itchy
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 7:44 am

    Oh, I wouldn’t worry about Mr. D. No doubt he’s camped outside of Russell’s house waiting to ‘console’ him.

    I liked Coach too, since it was always clear he couldn’t win, and he wasn’t a schmuck about it, just delusional.

  8. 8
    Damian
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 8:29 am

    First. Monica looked AMAZING on the jury and at the recap. Yum. I enjoy her skintilla.

    That aside – GREAT recaps Schoonie. Really made the season better. I still enjoyed watching it, but I echo itchy’s ‘Fuck You’ to the producers for such heavy-handed handling of the characters. Towards the end, I was getting pissed because people were not gunning for Russell when they had opportunities, particularly when Brett won immunity and the elf could no longer use the idol. It took until the reunion and tribal to realize that they were taking HIM to the final because he really was not a threat to win. We just never saw much of that. I’m sure there were a veritable fuckton of conversations around camp about how much of a nine faced douchecanoe Russ is and that everyone knew he promised everything to the entire universe.

    itchy/Schoonie – I ask you this – Would you have enjoyed the season if half-squat was edited to be the Jester of Survivor? Basically exploit the comic failings as much as you extolled them in these recaps and comments? Hmm.. That might be stupidly rhetorical. :)

  9. 9
    jennaboa
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 8:38 am

    Schoonie, I know the thought of Coach and Russell on screen together is probably giving you heart palpitations, but your recaps are beyond awesome, so please hang in for us, m’kay?

    “Russell’s shirt, however, is about eight sizes too small” Sort of like his wee heart. Russell’s like a shiny, fedora-wearing Grinch Who Stole The Season. And was he wearing the immunity idol under that shirt? Guh.

    This episode was a snooze fest filled with a lot of the same pompous jury questions, i.e, Laura, Kelly, et al, but your recap was spot on per usual Schoonie.

    Mick. Man, he must be a craptastic anesthesiologist. He can’t balance a weensy statue on a pole? Didn’t he have to gain a certain amount of surgery hours in med school, requiring him to use precision and skill to cut into humans? Doesn’t he have to measure out precise amounts of meds to make sure he doesn’t euthanize people? You’d think he’d have a deft hand and great balance given his job. Seriously, I do not want that man putting me under.

    Not mention his people skills suck. You can tell Brett was appalled when Mick tried to make a joke about his bro-date question. Joking about giving a proper-if-boring Christian boy a sweet kiss in the morning, after a presumed night of hot, sweaty sex, is not the way to win a million dollars, moron. Lame. Don’t joke, Mick. And don’t come near me with any needles, either. Ta.

    I forgot how much Kelly annoyed me at jury. She wasn’t alone — Wasn’t she part of the Mean Girls Group who yoga-ed, sunbathed and isolated Shambo? Does that make her the girl from Mean Girls who had a ton of hair to hide her secrets or the one who could tell when rain was coming with her breasts?

    At any rate, Nat’s entire strategy was play sweet Southern lass to the chauv oinkers by being as passive as possible in their alliance (while not being so passive as to be seen as weak) to get them to carry her to the end. She showed up in a dress and golden wedges (love that she had to throw in the golden bit) and played her part well. It could have completely backfired if she hadn’t also managed to deflect criticism to the other people in her tribe when she was under scrutiny. She was good at that, too. Coattail riding works. So does being a God-awful fuckwit. She and Russell were a match made in a Reality show producer’s idea of Heaven.

    I found Erik’s speech hysterical. You’re right, Schoonie, he’s watched too many court room dramas. It was if he was in a Perry Mason episode and Russell was going to jump off his perch and cry “You’re so right! I did it all. I am the sneak, the snake, the sock burner! *sob*” And then Probst would have had him dragged off for Cruelty to Socks and Stupid Little Girls. I don’t know where the “delusional entitlement” slur came from for Mick “ because he’s a doctor? Because he has terrible beside manner on his bro-dates? Huh?

    I liked Coach for the same reason I liked Russell and Shambo: I could not believe the amount of bull hockey coming out of his mouth. You have to wonder if these people watch the show when it airs and wish they had kept their traps shut? No, probably not, giving the sheer amount of ego. The fact that there are people like this in America ¦ wow. Shamwow. I am pretty sure that when they came up with “Freedom of Speech” the Founding Fathers weren’t thinking of Dragon Slayers, Chicken Whisperers and Would-Be-Reality-TV-Napoleons. Aw, poor Russ, well, Nappy didn’t win at Waterloo either, so you and a French emperor have something in common besides receding hairlines and a penchant for big ¦ egos.

  10. 10
    Memememe
    Posted December 24, 2009 at 1:36 pm

    Here’s a switch. I went to youtube looking for foolish quotes from Russell, but in this one, he doesn’t seem like the complete total douche that he did during the broadcast finale:

    http: //www.youtube. com / watch?v=-VdoaMXw7oQ

    He said he likes Natalie the most of everyone on the cast and when asked who he would want to win (other than himself), he answered Brett.

    He said he wouldn’t change a thing if he could go back, though, which is odd… considering he didn’t win. :-D

    Then, hours later, he was acting like a jackass on the CBS morning show when Nat got her check. Oh, well.

  11. 11
    Memememe
    Posted December 25, 2009 at 9:52 am

    Interesting that only certain commenters are allowed to post. oh well.

  12. 12
    itchy
    Posted December 25, 2009 at 11:37 am

    Is that true? Never noticed. Guess we’re part of the chosen few then. ;-D

  13. 13
    Schoonie
    Posted December 25, 2009 at 1:05 pm

    No it’s not true. Anyone with an account can comment.

  14. 14
    flipit
    Posted December 25, 2009 at 1:17 pm

    mememe, i saw your comment and checked the spam folder. you were in there because you had a link in your comment. we don’t ban anyone here, except the stupid tallfinder aholes!! hahah.
    thanks for a great season, schoon!! i can’t wait til summer comes and we can be together again.

  15. 15
    soapboxx
    Posted December 26, 2009 at 5:26 am

    Ok I just figured out how to get rid of those stupid intellitext adds, you know the ones with the double underline that pop up while you are reading if your mouse accidently slides over them. It’s easy to get rid of. Here’s how if anyone wants to know.
    Step by step:
    1) Open the IE options.
    This can be done by using the Tools menu within IE and selecting “Internet Options”, by right-clicking on the IE icon on your desktop or Start menu and selecting “Internet Options”, or by launching “Internet Options” from inside the Windows Control Panel.
    2) From the IE Options window, select the Security tab
    3) From within the security tab, click on the “Restricted sites” icon and then click the [Sites] button right below it.
    4) A list box window will pop up. In the “Add this website to the zone:” filed type in *.intellitxt.com then click the [Add] button.

    For Kontera and InfoLinks ads. Just add kona.kontera.com and *.infolinks.com.

    I hope this was ok to post here. It’s just frustrating to be laughing at Schoonie or Flipit or bBitz awesome recap and be interrupted by those annoying adds. If it’s not ok to offer this please delete this post admin.

  16. 16
    jelly
    Posted December 27, 2009 at 10:56 am

    Thanks so much for your recaps! I’ve been reading them for the last several seasons and now I’m addicted!

    You’re so funny and I love reading your analysis of the players too. Can’t wait for next season!

  17. 17
    billybop428
    Posted December 27, 2009 at 1:53 pm

    I feel so tricked By CBS. They made Russell out as this amazing player, when really, it’s clear that Natalie, Mick, and Jaison knew he would never win at a final tribal council.

    Shame on you CBS thinking that your viewers are such idiots that we can’t just make decisions for ourselves over who is the best player, you have to ram Russell down our throats.

    To even get an inkling of the other players, I went to CBS.com and watched the interviews of Marisa, Betsey, Laura, Brett, Kelly- people we didn’t get to see that much. Brett’s pretty boring, but again, shame on CBS for picking random LA 20 somethings every season. Didn’t Fiji teach them ANYTHING?

    btw always found this funny- of the 16 Tocantins contestants, only 4 of them actually applied, rather than being recruited: Sandy, JT, Spencer, and Coach.

    and Sandy, Coach, and JT ended up being some of the most memorable players of the season.

    CBS = CLUELESS.

  18. 18
    msjacqmills
    Posted December 28, 2009 at 10:26 am

    SOAPBOXX – thank you sooooo much for instructions on getting rid of intellitext – I couldn’t stand that crap!

    And, Schoonie – thanks for a great season of recaps. Can’t wait for All Stars!

  19. 19
    juddfan
    Posted December 28, 2009 at 12:56 pm

    Hope y’all had great holidays!!! Not much to add, still wish one of them had masterminded russ’ ouster, even if they had kept sham to replace him in the top for a can’t win, but if the 3 foa’s besides Russ had gotten rid of him, it could have been anyone’s game–they would have loved the one who served him too.

    Really hope Judd makes it to final . . . c’mon producers, I’m named for him for chrissakes!

    Guess hatch wont be in next one, and after the sexual harrassment, I’d be surprised Hawk would be back, and as pointed out, Fairplay was beyond pussy when brought back, and Rob C was lame last all star–right!? Also wouldn’t want Ambah and Boston back . . . . but burnt hands, yes, and perhaps good russ from this season could be in the heros . . .

    Guess we’ll see . . .

    Thanks again, Schoon, sorry you were HATIN’ this season . . . . Happy New YEar!

  20. 20
    pappy44
    Posted December 28, 2009 at 1:28 pm

    I thought dog the bounty hunter was rediculous…man, he has really let himself go…those man boobs….wow…

    speaking of boobs, is there a man alive that could successfully titty f**k laura? Good lord, there is like 3 feet of separation channel between those things…and people are wondering if they are fake or not??? puh….lease…

    I thought eric was WAAAAAAAAAy over the top. My take on him looking back at the jury when he was talking about perception and reality was because they all thought he was after laura and kelly…that was the perception. If you watch any of the “ponderosa” vids (which are awesome btw), they argue about that almost the entire time. I think that is the number one reason nat should have won. She made the biggest move. She had the most to do with getting out Erick, and that started distrust throughout the galu tribe for the rest of the game. You could hear it (and see it) when each of them got to ponderosa. But the best thing was not ONCE did ANYONE lay that on Nat….they had no idea she had done that, even after the fact!
    She rode coatails…sure…but she also made moves when she had to (you can’t tell me that she didn’t have SOME control over those guys…I mean, have you SEEN how hot she is? Lonely guys will listen to whatever a hot woman tells them! LOL) and made the biggest move in the game at the merge.

    Game

    Set

    Match

    and russell sucks…

  21. 21
    pappy44
    Posted December 28, 2009 at 1:31 pm

    @ juddfann:

    “Guess hatch wont be in next one, and after the sexual harrassment, I’d be surprised Hawk would be back, and as pointed out, Fairplay was beyond pussy when brought back, and Rob C was lame last all star–right!? Also wouldn’t want Ambah and Boston back . . . . but burnt hands, yes, and perhaps good russ from this season could be in the heros”

    Hatch can’t be back…he was in jail when it was being filmed…in fact, he was the first to let it out of the bag what this season would be. He was asked, and he asked to be released early for this, but he was denied, so he sent out an email detailing the email cbs sent to him.
    All that I have read…I haven’t seen Susan’s name at all…the two rob’s, yes…amber no…the one that does bother me that i have heard is pavarti…while she is GREAT to look at, she has already won an allstar, and I would rather have danni….mmmmmmmmmmmm

  22. 22
    juddfan
    Posted December 30, 2009 at 11:19 am

    Hey Pappy–my thoughts were based on the footage they showed advertising the season–seems odd to me that they would show all those people and yet not have them on the show . . .

    Hatch is quite a dick, eh . . . . don’t they have some kind of confidentiality agreement in place . . . .sigh . . .

    I, like you, hope there’s not too many from other all-star–esp a winner . . .

    Happy New Year!

  23. 23
    pappy44
    Posted January 4, 2010 at 9:59 am

    I do believe they have that agreement, but I don’t think hatch would have to abide by that, since he didn’t actually make the show…not sure on that though…

    I took the monatge (sp?) in the beginning as just a highlight of the moments of seasons past to set up the show, but you could be right…personally, i don’t want to see susan on that show, and I don’t want to see richard cause he has already been on an all star….

  24. 24
    Mr Dangerous
    Posted January 11, 2010 at 12:55 pm

    Hey Peeps!

    I’ve been on vacation and just got back to read all this.

    It sounds like everyone is still the same. I can’t wait for ALL-STARS. Go RUSSELL!

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Human Verification: In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.