American Idol: Donna Summer Wins

Hey! T.Vo and Flipit here with a live blog of the finale! HOLLAAAAA!!! And now! For the last time this season! THIS! Is American Idol!

Picture 16-7
Spoiler alert! Donna Summer wins!

T. VO: Hooray!

FLIPIT: HOLLER!!!!! I can't believe it. It's our first live blog together.

T.VO: At least we've met in real life, so this isn't like, "To Catch a Predator."

FLIPIT: Thank you for saying that, in case there are any FBI agents spying on this chat. You look ten years old.

T.VO: "You want a martini, little girl? Get into my creepy white van."

FLIPIT: Instead of diddling you I forced you to write recaps.

T.VO: And here we are.

FLIPIT: Sweetest friend biography ever. So who do you think is gonna win?

T.VO: Sadly, Fetus. But that doesn't make for good TV unless his dad goes bizzonkers.

FLIPIT: You think Cooke deserves it? Meh.

T.VO: Cook has more staying power as a musician/artist, but I don't think he can overcome the Mormon/tweenybopper voting bloc who call in at least four times each.

FLIPIT: Well, Cook does have georgiababe.

T.VO: True.

FLIPIT: Fetus will move in on Josh Groban's crowd. We may not ever hear of him, but he's a huge success. At least my great aunt Gloria says so.

T.VO: Aunt Gloria would gush over Fetus and then never buy any of his new-fangled CD's or figure out what an MP3 is.

FLIPIT: She flew here to see him in concert! And I'm sure she would have bought a record if they'd been selling one!

T.VO: Cook should win.

FLIPIT: There are enough off key faux rock singers already. I see those tools and their ironic tees sitting around in Starbucks all day long staring at a wall and introverting. Get a job!

T.VO: But aren't there enough precocious poptartlets in HWood as well?

FLIPIT: We take talented robotic little pretty babies and put them in cages here. They are what keeps the money flowing through town. We cherish them. You can never have enough precocious pop tartlets!

T.VO: You're scaring me.

FLIPIT: Sorry. He's at least kinda humble and honest, ya know?

T.VO: His dad just makes it unappetizing. There's an entire reality show dedicated to stage parents, right? If Fetus had been a girl, he could've ended up like JonBenét .

FLIPIT: The kid's boring as church, but he seems kinda real.

T.VO: There's only so many times you can look like a baby deer tranquilized by an elephant dart run over by a Zamboni. And Cook's real. He cried too. Like Hillary.

FLIPIT: And look how well it worked out for her.

Obama.Champion

T.VO: Fetus is a well-polished, rehearsed little man bot.

FLIPIT: A bot that can make old people cry!

T.VO: Remember the Santa Monica Farmer's Market Massacre, where the old man "accidentally" ran over all those people?

FLIPIT: That was so not an accident. That was angry old man syndrome. I'm so getting that. I don't believe for one second he thought he was stepping on the brakes as he ran over thirty something people. He'd just had ENOUGH.

T.VO: I just got a bike today, and if I were to be hit by someone while riding the sidewalk, it would be an old person in a Caddy and they'd be blasting Fetus's song. They'd get distracted an run up the curb thinking it was a parking spot. Or the ice cream truck,in a twist of irony.

FLIPIT: LOLolollll congrats on the bike.

T.VO: Or Charlotte Church, before she got knocked up.

FLIPIT: Or Josh Groban! OK it's about to start. Are you ready for the last two hours of American Idol in 2008?

T.VO: Wait, this is 2 hours? I could've gotten 8 cavities filled during this time.

FLIPIT: Don't worry, it will probably sound like you are doing just that.

The show opens with the Davids staring each other down.

Picture 12-18

You're hot. No, You are!

T.VO: It looks like they should make out. MAKE OUT!!! MAKE OUT!!!

FLIPIT: You blinked first, Cook! Fetus wins! They're both in white. It's like the final Cylons are meeting for the first time.

T.VO: But first, they have to get communion and go into the confessional. Then play altar boys.

FLIPIT: Or change a bedpan. The costumer saw Amanda in her work uniform and was like I smell a finale theme!

T.VO: Wow, Tink is taller than someone. Yay for him.

T.VO: Is that...Holly Robinson Peet in the crowd?!

American Idol: Donna Summer Wins Sections:  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7  |  8  |  9  |  10  |  11 

« Step It Up and Dance: Fruta Picante! | Main | Keeping Up the Kardashians: Bruce's Pants Get Tight »

Comments (23)

Gildedlulz:

THANK FUCKING GOD.

That's all I need to say.

gildedlulz:

Oh, and Amanda's amazing performances last night made me love her even more. She so obviously hated being there; I about died laughing.

I really loved how she was dressed in a pleather vest and pants while the rest of the contestants were wearing tuxes and dresses during one of the last group performances.

LOL, Amanda!
You're my Idol.

JustJesse:

Awesome recap guys! I had a lot of fun reading it. Just a few things though. You said something about David Hernandez teaching Archuleta about something out on tour, but only the top 10 will be there, and finishing 12th, Hernandez won't be one of them. The top 12 gets to come back for the finale, but only the top 10 go on tour. And when you were talking about Carrie Underwood's songs, "Jesus and Gravity" isn't one she sings. Dolly Parton sang that when she was on the show, so maybe that's where you got confused. Other than that though, nice work! Glad to see Cook win!

T.Vo:

Heh. JustJesse -- I was making fun of Carrie Underwood since she looked like she'd borrowed Dolly's clothes, so naturally, I pretended she was going to sing "Jesus and Gravity" too.

renoblondee:

Hey guys, you made me laugh so hard during this season, but not feeling it w/ the finale so much. I think you all felt like I did LAST season. It sucked. I didn't give a flying fig WHO won. But THIS season I fell in love w/ Cookie like so many others. He. Is. The. Man.
Don't understand the hateraide. Also, maybe you all are just too young, but Bryan Adams and ZZ Top and George Michael fucking ROCKED the house God Damnit. Anywho, love ya anyway, and I'll always be back. Cheers.

JustJesse:

Whoops, my bad. :-/

georgiababe:

BREAKING NEWS: Carrie Underwood's Pants Stolen from Dressing Room, She Still Performs

LMAO Thanks for the shoutout! Glad to know that my CookLove (patent pending) is so infamous lol. And, for the LAST TIME, I will annoy all of here on here again by professing my love.

I still don't really know why you have such a problem with him, but meh. He WON (part in partial to me) and he already has a number one hit in the Philippines. I thought the Mike Myers thing was hilarious actually, especially when he implied that Fetus hasn't gone through puberty yet lmao. As well as Myers trying to shave Cook - frankly, I was rather surprised (and slightly disappointed) that you didn't comment on that.

Whatever. I think the Cookie scruff is HOT. Although I'm sure I've made that clear by now lol. I had a mini-viewing party with some other Cookie fans and you have NO idea how excited we all got when the Guitar Hero commercial on. We sent him a meat basket, actually. I'm not even joking. Shameless sexual innuendo. But I mean, have you see the size of his boots....? Lol

Anyway, the right David won, hands down. Archuleta is destined for Disney and HSM forever. I was SO happy for him - whether you like him or not, he's struggled really hard to get where he is and he deserves it.

Pretty great recap - although I was rather disappointed that you didn't comment on Cook's adorkable little dance during "Sharp Dressed Man". But probably everybody but me thought it was lame.

Anyway, I will stop my Cook Love, once and for all and say thanks for a great reason. Even though I didn't really like the way you portrayed Cook. But, like I said in another post, at the end of the day TVgasm is all in good fun. Plus, Cook won. So I'm cool.

And shout out to renoblondee - clearly, you have good taste.

georgiababe:

Okay, I lied, I'm not quite done.

There is a GH commercial on the Tube that is twice as long as the one they aired. Both Archie and Cookie have one, but obviously Archie's is like child pornography. But in Cook's you see BRIEFS. I almost died.

JustJesse:

georgiababe-

Archie's is like child pornography? Don't you think that's a bit much? I mean hell, you see more of Cook then you do of him. We all know you prefered David C so I think the Archuleta bashing can stop.

georgiababe:

Archuleta bashing? DUDE. It was a JOKE.

Don't get your shortchuletas in a knot.

BRaps:

I’m so sad for Fetus! My heart broke for him when he lost. I thought he was a shoo-in all season long, and when it came down to him and Cook I thought he would prevail similar to sugary teenybopper Jordin over wiggy-wiggy Blake. But judging by the record number of votes cast, I definitely underestimated Cook’s fanbase. I mean, Fetus must have received like 43 million votes, which probably would have been enough to win most seasons. But Cook crushed that amount by a healthy margin.

Even though I am not a Cook fan, it would be nice to see him become a success so that the show gets some of its credibility back. And I would love to see Fetus break free from his nutjob father and go on to do great things. The poor thing always seemed so nervous and tense. Hopefully he can improve his stage presence and personality like Carrie Underwood has done since she was on the show. Pants or no pants, she looked and sounded awesome on the finale! Lastly, kudos to both the Davids for being gracious in victory/defeat, and to T.Vo and Flipit for a great season of recaps! xoxo

JustJesse:

Shortchuletas? Wow, how clever you are...

georgiababe:

Hey, don't blame me, the Archies made that little gem up.

fire@will:

I wish both them - and all of you - the best. I'd love to have either of thier voices, but I don't envy them the kind of lives they are liable to lead.

Thanks again for some of the best. recaps. ever.

juddfan:

somehow, I missed the risky business send-up-and thank the lord in heaven above . . . I don't really want to see either in skivvies!!!! ick . . . the screen grabs are bad enough . . .

So thanks guys oh so much for hanging in there despite the obvious burnout, that gets worse at the end of each of these, no?

How much do I HATE Jordin Sparks . . . just puke city!!! She was on the news after and they asked her to give advice to the winners (besides fake cry) she said, "Get ready to have no sleep, I haven't had 8 hours sleep in a year"

Bitter little biotch! She's frigin' 18, I so didn't get 8 hours then, and still don't in my soon to be 45 years!!!!

I knew from the Simon apology what was going to happen, and I figured the unhypnotised masses would rise and revolt and vote for the one who wasn't shoved down our throats and Randified--I'm not sure I can watch this show anymore, toxic vomit festers in my guts and threatens to spew every time that stuffed doll spits a cliche--can't he just step down, please . . . I don't know what brought on all the hate for me, but I'm glad Cook prevailed and since I don't listen to Disney channel, I'm unconcerned about Fetus' fate . . . I'm sure he'll find his niche, and Cook, well, I'm not likely to get that CD either, but I bet it'll do well!

Kisses Flip and T.vo!!!!

JasonR:

Great liveblog guys.

At this point I've posted so much about Idol I'm just out of things to say, except for one observation: Oh, Amanda, how can you be 22 years old and still seem like a 50 year-old drunk aunt, or better yet Sally O'Malley from SNL . . . "I'm FIFTY yeahs old, and I can KICK and KICK!"

Congrats to Cook.

itchy:

The recap was so much fun, I figured, what the hell, I'll have a look at the show itself...(which I haven't bothered to do otherwise)...

First, there was, what, 10 minutes of filler before the show actually started?

Second, georgiababe, I'm sorry, but...are you not seeing the same stupid hair? The lopsided head? The stupid pubic-hair beard? The fat butt? The girl hips?

Especially this episode...I'm trying to figure out who the hell he is trying to fool with the mess he made of his hair...

In fact, I get it now, he really DOES deserve to win this show.

The fetus? giggle giggle grin gosh....

georgiababe:

Hello again, itchy.

I like his hair and I like his beard. And I haven't noticed anything else - I am sorry. And I am willing to bet that most women ages 16+ are going to agree with me.

itchy:

Ah, georgia, apparently much of America (that is, the segment of the population that actually votes in this...er...contest) agree with you!

For better or worse...

Problem for Cook is, he's posing as a rocker. But no one seriously interested in rock will ever take him seriously. Ever.

So even if he succeeds in making a career at this (Vegas will love him, after all), it will never be the career he wanted. It'll be the opposite of that.

And he knows it. You could see it in his eyes.

yuds101:

I have to say i never laughed to hard to when they both went to visit the "Guru" OMG-the looks on both thier faces were priceless! David a. looked clueless... very dissapointed u guys didn't comment on the funniest part of the show...but great recaps thoughout-thanks!

Boris8:

Did anyone catch what George Michael said to Ryan Seacrest regarding his compound after he was done singing? It sounded like flirting!

juddfan:

OMG Flipit!!! I forgot to mention

"If she wants a choker she could use my palms"

That is soooo F in' funny!!!!!! LMAOAJORIBW (Laughing my ass off and jumping off the roof in bubble wrap)

HEART

carmelicious:

FLIPIT: It's like Heaven, only gayer and whiter.

- officially my favorite thing you ever said!

I just wanted to thank you both for enduring this ridiculously long episode for our reading pleasure - and for a seasons worth of awesome recaps!

Embarrassing admission #1: I actually stood up and cheered when Cook won - don't judge!

Embarrassing admission #2: I still think Hanna ManTana should've made the final 2 - again - DONT JUDGE!

Soooo glad this board is anonymous!

Post a comment

Post a comment

60