"You can't kill the Boogie Man." A little girl who saw her parents get murdered said that line on Heroes the other night and I raised my fist in solidarity when she did. You can't kill the boogie, man. But the boogie can kill you (sorry it got your folks). There are only four Idols left and no one's safe. Pull out your crucifixes and body glitter, because this is Boogie Night. And this. Is American Idol!
Boogie is a nice word for disco, two syllables no one will utter aloud for fear of getting a chair thrown at their head by any nearby rocker. Disco killed rock, and then rock killed disco, then disco killed rock again, and now they both kind of suck. But are either officially dead? Too deep for disco? Speaking of unofficially dead, the first shot of the night is a closeup of Nancy Reagan! Aw! Nancy, where you been?
Tink introduces a video montage of Barry Gibb, tonight's Guest Mentor. No matter your age, you've turned down the volume on at least one of his songs at some point in your life. He wasn't only the leader of the Bee Gees, he has written and produced songs for some of the biggest names in the business. Barbra, Miss Ross, Celine...wait, I'm sensing a trend here. Nah! Barry's butch as the Brawny man.
During the get to know me montage, Tink never says the word disco once, even though he shows this album cover. I smell a conspiracy against that word.
Stop running, Barry. It's called Disco.
Barry looks much different now, and without the huge hair and mom jeans I can't stop staring at his waddle. It looks like a turkey's neck before it's made into giblets.
Barry says that since he is used to working with the ladies, he is glad to have the three divas and a possible bottom to mentor, and he jumps right in. Doolittle is up first with "Lovin' You Inside and Out". Barry's skeptical and surprised at first, but after hearing her he says the song sounds great sung by a lady. Always has, Gibblet. Always has.
She takes the stage wearing tight jeans and a fierce attitude and knocks it out of the park. She makes it her own and looks better than she has yet. Every week her extensions get longer and longer, and she gets younger and younger. Weezy Jefferson travels back in time a decade with each episode.
Simon's pouting by the time she's done, which can't be good. Randy gives her credit for great vocals, but wasn't wowed. Paula has difficulty criticizing Melinda because the vocals are so spot on, but she wasn't wowed either. She doesn't know if it was in the song choice, or the performance, or the styling, but they're looking for "woah woah woah". Simon rolls his eyes and says what Paula was trying to say was is that she was unimpressed. LOL. He tosses the ultimate diss, saying it sounded like a back up singer track. Ouch. He's ruder than he's ever been to Melinda, and she goes from "Gee wiz, me?" to "Whatchoo talkin' bout, Willis?" in an instant.
Tink asks Paula if that is in fact what she was trying to say and she replies "I keep it short and succinct." Oy.
Blake's up next with "You Should Be Dancing" and Barry loves the beat boxing. Here we go. He starts off in the wrong key and is using heavy echo, which doubles the pain. He does his slow mo MJ moves and sings "you should be dancing, y-y-y-y-y-y--yeah!" Y-y-yy-y--you shouldn't be. There's a section towards the end where he can break it down, which means he pulls out the ole bag of record scratching and wiggy wiggy. He sounds like my little niece did when she was struggling to pop out her first word.
Randy thinks sometimes the beat boxing works, but tonight it didn't. He said it was like being in a weird foreign disco tech. Paula says that he was off the melody but still showed why he's unique. Simon gives him unique but thinks the performance was absolutely horrible. Cowell's miffed when the music cuts him off, but Tink promises him a chance to call Blake a poser later.
LaKisha's singing "Stayin' Alive", and again Barry doesn't know how an actual girl will pull off his song. He wants her to take it up into her head voice and I hope she takes his advice. We've never heard her head voice.
« Betty Gets All Middle Ages | | Look Ma! No Morals! »












Comments (15)
Hey Flipit, I agree Lakisha is probably done. If it were based on last night alone Blake should be gone, but I think his fan base is a lot deeper than Kiki's.
Great recap!
-JR
1 of 15 | Posted by JasonR
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 9:18 AM
Love you, love you, love you, Flipit. Reading your recaps makes temping a heluva lot more fun.
Unlike you, I am a Blake fan. However, You Should Be Dancing is NOT a good choice at this point in the the competition (though I did like This is Where I Come In). I think Night Fever or How Deep Is Your Love (which he did in the group round in Hollywood) would have been a better choice for his first song.
Like you, I have a feeling LaKisha's out. Blake has enough of a fan base (yes, including me) to keep him on for at least another week, though he's going to REALLY have to bring it next week to make it to the finals. However, I can see LaKisha and Melinda starting to cancel each other out, if that makes any sense.
Jordin is good with the right song, I'll admit. Her first song was really good. Her sugariness irritates me, though (I had some similar issues with Carrie Underwood at times, though she definitely deserved to win). And I am getting SO SICK of the "she's only 17!" garbage. Every season, there's at least one really young finalist (though, granted, they usually don't get as far as Jordin has). Also, wasn't Diana DeGarmo 16? Did they keep saying that? (I didn't watch that season.)
I still maintain that Jordin is heavily favored by the producers to win, and that's totally not her fault, but it still rubs me the wrong way.
2 of 15 | Posted by maybeimamazed02
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 9:20 AM
Blake's performance last week won me over, but I groaned when he beatboxed again this week. Yes, its neat that he can do it, but AI is a singing competition and beatboxing should be an infrequent occurance. I think tonights results will be relatively predictable, with Kiki going home and Blake in the bottom two.
3 of 15 | Posted by abaumga2
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 9:23 AM
ROTFLMBBAO!!! *Dead*. One of the best recap. Great screen shots. And I think Kiki is gonna bite it tonight, even though I think it should be BeatBoxBoy.
4 of 15 | Posted by UptownGirl
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 10:34 AM
So long as Melinda doens't go tonight.. I really don'e care who does out of the remaining 3... Blake... meh... he's so played out and his beatboxing sucks.
Lakisha.. she can sing yes, but I never saw the appeal of her.
Jordin, she's great when she picks the right songs, but when it's the wrong song, BOY does she suck balls.
5 of 15 | Posted by Shollia
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 11:21 AM
OK, is it only me who thought Barry's grayer and rounder head holds what is probably the worst pair of slurr-inducing dentures since Geoge Washington carved himself a set? And is it only me who thinks Melinda, with her crazy hand shaking and staggered stage lurching, is gonna get bounced right after that walking set of boobs, aka Lakisha, is finally tossed out on her dead-eyed, personality-free butt? Just asking.
6 of 15 | Posted by BobbyP
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 11:29 AM
Holy shit, does Blake ever suck. He sucks harder than anything has ever sucked before. He can't sing, he beatboxes as well as your average 8th grader (if I ever see Paula or Randy in person, I will personally beat the snot out of each of them for calling his hackneyed shit "unique.") Plus, he's ugly. This person has got be related to Big Brother's Mike Booger in some way, right down to his wiggy wiggy white boy fucktardedness (it's a word).
I find him to be the perfect microcosm for this entire season. Marginally talented, thoroughly unattractive, and unduly adored. Thanks, AI. Fuckers.
7 of 15 | Posted by Die_MediaWhores
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 11:33 AM
I think that Blake is in trouble. As much as I like him (esp. his rendition of "Time of the Season") I agree with Paula (WTF?!), he should have sang "Jive Talkin'".
I'm disappointed in most of the song choices - it's not like they didn't have thousands of songs to choose from! One/any of the girls should have done "Emotion" and another "Guilty" and hell, even "Too Much Heavan". .....and no, I am NOT ashamed of my BeeGees knowledge. Thank god no one busted out "Islands in the Stream"!
PS. Barry is scary with grey hair!
8 of 15 | Posted by jennae
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 11:54 AM
It was so cool that they got Will Farrel to do his Sean Connery impression last nite. What?! That was Barry Gibb?
9 of 15 | Posted by cvreeken
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 12:11 PM
Ugh, I hate hate hate Blake. I thought this was a SINGING competition, not a piss me off competition. He can't sing. Does no one else realize this? HE CANNOT SING! I'd be less pissed if Sangina was still there instead of him, I'm super cereal, guys. Die_Mediawhores gets the award for truthiness of the year comment.
Flipit, one of your best recaps ever. I lol'ed at your "Thanks for drinking" screen cap.
Screw winning a trip to the Idol finale, I want to win a trip to watch the finale with Flipit!
10 of 15 | Posted by brendahamLincoln
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 12:35 PM
Thanks for pointing out KiKi's panty line -- we were shocked. I am a large woman, and believe me, if you wear a dress like that, you definitely freeball it. Without question. (Or thong it, but I just didn't want to send everyone racing to scrub their eyeballs at the thought...)
11 of 15 | Posted by killbondnow
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 2:41 PM
^^^amen. self love is important. so are pantie lines.
"Barry's grayer and rounder head holds what is probably the worst pair of slurr-inducing dentures since Geoge Washington carved himself a set? "
"This person has got be related to Big Brother's Mike Booger in some way, right down to his wiggy wiggy white boy fucktardedness (it's a word)."
"It was so cool that they got Will Farrel to do his Sean Connery impression last nite. "
george washington carving himself a pair is still killing me. thanks guys.
12 of 15 | Posted by Flipit
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 2:52 PM
Hey flipit, nyah nyah nyah nyah nyah nyah!! My boy is still in and you get to watch him again next week! The beatbox gods have smiled upon him this week...
13 of 15 | Posted by Pegster
|
Posted on May 9, 2007 9:48 PM
i'll get you my pretty
14 of 15 | Posted by Flipit
|
Posted on May 10, 2007 12:53 PM
great recap, as per usual. funny captions! even funnier comments (fucktardedness is my new fave)
First of all -- those songs completely SUCK UNWIPED ARSE. No wonder the judges weren't impressed. Shithouse material!
Barry Gibb is a crappy liar bc it's so clear he couldn't stand hearing anyone (female) trying to do his stuff. Plus he HATED the beatboxing! (as did I -- give it a rest, mate!)
Kiki was great, but woefully underappreciated. I don't understand why the judges (and voters) weren't wowed by her perfs week after week, tho she did get a little hoarse towards the end both times this week... And she really didn't bring it on those high notes, which was a shame. She rocked that Shirley Bassey/Bond track a few weeks ago, tho. I don't care what anyone says.
Blake will go next.
Jordin's got the prize, fer sure. As I commented elsewhere, once her voice matures and she gains the benefit of proper coaching, her voice will be truly stupendous!
but never as good as Kiki's...
15 of 15 | Posted by Donna Martin Graduates!
|
Posted on May 10, 2007 8:24 PM