Umnata, I can't decide if you're brave or dumb (no offense intended). I mean, to still be watching this travesty is amazing. I have trouble just watching the clips on The Soup!
I think it would be better for Brandy to replace Paula rather than Randy- as long as they can get Randy to stop calling everyone dog. Paula needs a long rest in rehap before she goes in front of the camera again.
How the hell does "The Hoff" have the nerve to critizie anyone?!? We've seen the music videos, sir. Germany has very poor taste in entertainment.

Doh! Naturally that's supposed to be a long rest rehaB.

I only watch this show because my boyfriend worked at the casting in NYC so it was fun during the early rounds to see the people that he saw in person. Now I watch for the Hoff! But seriously... My boyfriend is really smart and had this idea: They say they don't want it to be another American Idol, so next season (shudder) they should divide people into categories - singing, dancing, throwing around 65 pound women, being Russian and dressing in drag, etc. Then they can have the best singer, the best dancer, the best lady-thrower, and the best Russian in drag all compete against each other.

PS thank you Umnata -- I thought Sugar and Spice were terrible too. Good for Brandy for not being sucked in. And N'Versity (What does that mean anyway? Apparently they got their name by praying. Hmm.) were nowhere near as good as All That and I'm sick of Piers and the Hoff drooling over any female in a sexy-ish outfit, especially if they are 16 years old!

Well if the little girls are considered "cute" not talent.... then I do not get why the judges let the "rappin granny" in... she's cute not talented.... bionca is talent. jojo

Please keep the recaps of this show coming. Do listen to the negative feedback from People. This show is great!, yes it has done before, even in highschools (variety shows or talent shows) but it is a breeze of fresh air. This show gives you variety, singers, dancers, musicians, jugglers, etc. The judges make you laugh, the contestants make you laugh, and like I said before it gives you variety. I do think that other shows such as So you think you can dance, Project runaway, real world are #$@@ because who are the regular Joes of the word to endure 1-2 hours of dancing, cat walkiing or fighting, obnocious people arguing, etc. But America's got talent just give us the act and makes us laugh!