Let's move on to a more adorable plotline. What's more adorable than a bloated river corpse, you ask? Why, it's Coach Taylor playing with his newborn daughter! He and Tami fawn and coo all over the place, while Julie just looks generally unhappy in the kitchen. Coach looks Thoughtful again. I don't want to eat a hat, Coach! You better get your ass back to Dillon!

"Landry killed a guy? What are these writers THINKING?"
A little while later, at Dillon Panthers Stadium, Coach leads a ceremony in which the team receives their 2006 Championship Rings (Panthers win state!). And of course, it's lovely. Each team member gets their ring from a variety of people, which seems to include a lot of random coaches. Tim gets his from brother Billy, and Matt gets his from - hey! It's the Official Dillon Panthers Decrepit Old Coot from last season! Welcome back, old timer!

"Have they cured leprosy yet, m'boy? Can't seem to find my ear."
And Jason gets his ring on a necklace chain, which for some reason marks the return of the lump to my throat that I had gotten so used to last year. The psyched look on his face almost makes up for his total lack of a plotline. He's probably thinking about this exact time last year, when the entire episode was all about him, lying there on the ground, unable to move. Ah, happier days.

"I'm still relevant!"
Seconds later, Coach is back up in the air on a plane back to TMU. That man can plane and deplane faster than anyone I've ever seen. He gazes down upon the stadium, and looks - you guessed it - Thoughtful. I rest my case.

"Man, that ground-to-airplane slingshot we installed just paid for itself!"
Okay. So here's what I think. Not a solid season premiere. I hate hate hate the Landry-Tyra plotline. I read somewhere over the summer that murder was going to possibly pop up and I prayed that it wasn't true. But dang it all, it is. And I just think the writers are better than that, there's no need to resort to a shocking, out-of-character ratings ploy. That's not why we watch and love this show. Stick to what you're good at - tearing my soul apart with good old-fashioned guilt, misery, and paralysis.
I hope that in the coming weeks they tone down Julie's increasingly irritating teenageriness. It's getting a little out of hand. Same goes for Tim's douchiness. That was a little unnecessary. I think it goes without saying that I would like to see more of Jason (naked), and yes, Smash as well. I would like to see his character developed a little more so that he's not all steroids and racism and cockiness. What's INSIDE the Smash?
Then again, I suppose beggars can't be choosers. The entire gang could run away and join the circus, and I'd still be happy just because they got a second season. I'm beyond thrilled to see this show still on television, and I'd be lying if I said I was not waiting all damn summer for this. So here's hoping for an awesome season.
What did y'all think? (See what I did there? Y'all! Texas forever!)
« Beauty and the Geek: I'm With Stupid | Main | Desperate Housewives: Turn that Frown Upside Down »


Comments (14)
I haven't read the recap yet, BUT I wanted to posst how excited I am! I got hooked on FNL over the summer and watched the DVDs in 5 days. It was pretty ridiculous, actually.
Anyways. I wanted to let you all know, if it wasn't mentioned in the recap (as I haven't read it) that nbc.com has CRUCIFICTORIUS shirts available to buy. I will be wearing mine proudly, and hopefully I won't murder anybody.
1 of 14 | Posted by flolover | Posted on October 11, 2007 9:41 AM
My username is actually FNLLOVER, not Flolover. I don't know why it came up as Flolover, but rest assured I have panther pride, not a love of menstrual cycles.
2 of 14 | Posted by fnllover | Posted on October 11, 2007 9:55 AM
OK, great recap! And I finally got my wish, with them putting FNL on FRIDAYS. Hello? That instinctive move alone will increase the show's popularity.
Agreed. That murder from the unlikely "relationship" between Tyra and Landry does not belong here. There's enough pathos in the genaral "teenagery" (I like that word) plus the coach and Mrs. Coach to make this a great show.
Buddy is being made into a more likely character. Ease up on that, writers. We need Buddy to stay the same asshat small town car dealer that loooooves the football team.
The new coach? He's gone by week 3. No problem bringing Taylor back. No way he can leave his girls for long.
3 of 14 | Posted by talma63 | Posted on October 11, 2007 10:34 AM
YAY! People to dicuss the murder plot with who actually care about the show!
I have been bothering everyone I meet about watching season one, and they all make a face like "really, you're dumb".
Anyways. I don't mind the murder plot, but it is all riding on how it plays out. Let's all remember that in the Pilot, a kid was paralyzed. The star quarterback, the guy going pro, the All-American kid. At first, I was like "what,
When I saw Jason get paralyzed, (not having seen the FNL movie) I thought, it was cliche, melodramatic, etc. But what makes this show different it that it handles the stereotypes, the cliches, the melodrama, in a realistic manner.
I have no problem believing that Landry would have killed that guy. And teenagers are dumb. Sure, Julie knows when she is in over her head (when it came to the party and Tyra's mom last season), but some people don't. Tyra is one of them, and Landry, being in love with her, is going to take her lead on this. He probably thought that she was "wiser in the ways of the world" and deferred to her in the situation.
Tyra was probably thinking "no one will believe us, because I am the town slut". That was my immediate thought, anyway. And my other thing is that the murder was not self defense. With the types of blows that were inflicted, it would easily be concluded by the medical examiner that the guy was walking away.
Not defending the choice, really, but I found it understandable enough to trust the writers in this case. They haven't let us down before.
ONE MORE THING: I read that the ratings for the FNL premiere was up 10% from last year's finale. Hopefully there is no where to go but up!
4 of 14 | Posted by fnllover | Posted on October 11, 2007 11:01 AM
fnllover -
First off...I'm so glad you mentioned that about the ratings! I hadn't read that or heard it anywhere, but it's nice to know that's the case. I also hope it continues to rise.
Secondly, before reading your last comment, I was down on the murder storyline. I understand why he killed this guy, but I thought that Landry should've been smart enough to talk Tyra into calling the cops. Sure, it would be rough going for a long time because no one would believe them, mostly because of Tyra's reputation...but Landry and Tyra would stand by each other through the whole thing, and in the end, she'd see him for what he is, etc.
I felt that the way the story actually went down was just too much for FNL.
After reading what you wrote though, I might be a little more receptive to the storyline they have in place. We'll see what happens.
I was a little let down by this last episode, but hopefully they were just trying to touch a little on each storyline, and they'll settle back into a rhythmn with the next episode.
5 of 14 | Posted by ThisShowRocks! | Posted on October 11, 2007 12:29 PM
Hi all!
I am soooo happy the show's back on!! And this Friday is my birthday I get the presie of FNL! ON FRIDAY!!
Thank you for that fabulous recap, ITA on pretty much all points.
More Street!
More Smash!
More Tim Riggens!
More Matt and Julie not being a brat!
MORE COACH!!!!!!
Wierd murder story line.... interesting....
6 of 14 | Posted by Sweetleaf | Posted on October 11, 2007 1:22 PM
Yay FNL is back!! And more great recaps - you picked up right where you left off; really funny, awesome screencaps, and you don't miss anything.
I was shocked that Tami and Coach had a girl - i was sure it would be the little boy that Coach always wanted. I guess the murder wasn't the only thing that ruined this first episode! GRACE!! (in Ed Rooney voice)
I really hate the murder. I don't think it's in Landry's character and I don't want them to stray away from the realism that everyone loves about this show. I hope it wasn't just a ploy to increase ratings. I also read somewhere else that a writer said that it makes so much more sense and gets so much better in episodes 2 and 3.... but what is he going to say -- "Episode 1 was our peak, don't even bother watching again."
I did read that it wasn't a dream or anything like a fantasy that didn't really happen so I am interested to see what happens.
7 of 14 | Posted by DP Hooker | Posted on October 11, 2007 9:17 PM
Great recap, but your's always are.
Okay, I became an FNL fan this summer with the DVDs. I come from a small town like this, where I quit the football team, and my father was a local cop. How scary is that.
Two things about this show and it's recent plot lines.
First: Landry was just in the side stories last season, so to say this doesn't fit his character? Well, how do we know. He may be a very violent person on his free time. Just look at his music. Also, I think it is unfair to call this a ratings game. All of the characters involved have motivation behind their actions, and why did they drop the body in the river? THEY ARE HIGH SCHOOL KIDS!!!!!!!!! They didn't know how to react.
Second: Julie. I'm glad we get to see her being a brat. If your family was split up wouldn't you act out?
At least this season premiere didn't have a doctor trying to bring a deer back to life. This show is all about realistic build up, and the fallout from dramatic situations.
8 of 14 | Posted by neillfilm | Posted on October 12, 2007 7:23 AM
Hi All.
I think that the issue that people are taking with the murder plot is that there was no build up. Yes, there was the rape storyline from last season, but as far as the guy stalking Tyra, it didn't go on for a couple of episodes, so it didn't have time to "scare uss" enough to make us want Landry to kill the guy.
However, I do think that people like Landry may be the most prone to killing people. He is a Christian, sure, but are Christians (Texas especially) more likely to use violence? (Don't hate me from bring up this angle, I am too VERY religious, and am not trying to bash it). Lyla is a part of "Jesus Warriors", so that could play a part. He is a rather subtle character that we don't really know anything about, so it could be in his character, we don't know.
He made fun of the football team last year, but does that mean he wouldn't try out for the team? No. Maybe he made fun of them because he wanted to be a part of it all, but wasn't. So, because of his attempts to become a "leading man" (something from last season) he has taken to doing these things, and branching out in an attempt to gain Tyra's affection.
The first time we really saw Tyra last season, outside of her interactions with other characters, there was a REALLY intense fight between her mom and her mom's boyfriend. She was violent in that situation. She was also violent when she fought off the rapist. So, it is natural that some of that would rub off on Landry. Especially if they have been close over the the months since, and she has told him everything. Landry would know that violence is effective in situations such as this, and then he would kill the guy.
I think that since Landry was there through the "fallout" of the attempted rape, and saw how it affected Tyra, he would be violently protective of her, and worry about her getting into that situation again. Hence, Landry killing the guy. Even having to fight off the guy herself would have been "too much" for Tyra to handle at this point. So Landry became the "leading man" that he talked about last season.
9 of 14 | Posted by fnllover | Posted on October 12, 2007 7:45 AM
Hi All.
I think that the issue that people are taking with the murder plot is that there was no build up. Yes, there was the rape storyline from last season, but as far as the guy stalking Tyra, it didn't go on for a couple of episodes, so it didn't have time to "scare uss" enough to make us want Landry to kill the guy.
However, I do think that people like Landry may be the most prone to killing people. He is a Christian, sure, but are Christians (Texas especially) more likely to use violence? (Don't hate me from bring up this angle, I am too VERY religious, and am not trying to bash it). Lyla is a part of "Jesus Warriors", so that could play a part. He is a rather subtle character that we don't really know anything about, so it could be in his character, we don't know.
He made fun of the football team last year, but does that mean he wouldn't try out for the team? No. Maybe he made fun of them because he wanted to be a part of it all, but wasn't. So, because of his attempts to become a "leading man" (something from last season) he has taken to doing these things, and branching out in an attempt to gain Tyra's affection.
The first time we really saw Tyra last season, outside of her interactions with other characters, there was a REALLY intense fight between her mom and her mom's boyfriend. She was violent in that situation. She was also violent when she fought off the rapist. So, it is natural that some of that would rub off on Landry. Especially if they have been close over the the months since, and she has told him everything. Landry would know that violence is effective in situations such as this, and then he would kill the guy.
I think that since Landry was there through the "fallout" of the attempted rape, and saw how it affected Tyra, he would be violently protective of her, and worry about her getting into that situation again. Hence, Landry killing the guy. Even having to fight off the guy herself would have been "too much" for Tyra to handle at this point. So Landry became the "leading man" that he talked about last season.
10 of 14 | Posted by fnllover | Posted on October 12, 2007 7:47 AM
Fine recap. The writers are stuck with some "grade" problems.
At first, I was put off by the Landry homocide plot, for many of the same reasons others noted. I do think that his actions, including his over-use of force, were "logical" for his character. He is not a violent person, surpressing his anger or venting it with sarcasm. When a guy like that does "go off", he can do some real damage.
In fact, I was hoping for a "Waterboy" moment with Landry, except on the gridiron. (Maybe we will still see that.)
Bring Coach back to Dillon!
11 of 14 | Posted by fire@will | Posted on October 12, 2007 12:01 PM
I am sooo happy this show is back, and can't wait for tonight.
Screampillar - you missed the best line, and delivery, of the entire show. When Coach picks up Julie at the bar: "You've got to be kidding me." The way he delivered that line was hilarious, and perfectly in character for him. Kyle Chandler is the best.
I am a little worried about the murder storyline - but, here's the thing: teenagers do totally stupid, rash things all the time without thinking things through. And everytime Tyra and Landry took a step down that road - moving the body, putting it in the trunk, etc - they moved further and further toward the point of no return. SO, I think it is plausible that they are on that bridge with the body and toss it over. The real trick, for the show, is how they handle the fall out from it.
We'll see - of course, all of us will be watching regardless.
12 of 14 | Posted by lawyergal | Posted on October 12, 2007 1:11 PM
SOOOO glad FNL is back! Oh how I missed Coach Taylor and his sheepish-adorable self! He belongs in Dillon 24/7 - i can't even stand it!
Screampillr, I loved your recaps last season and this one didn't disappoint. Lots of LOL moments! Welcome back!
So yeahhh, the Landry-Tyra plot line...what??? Why wouldn't they report it as a self-defense situation? it's not like they were doing anything bad then it all went down. i don't get it.
Anyway....just so glad FNL is back!
13 of 14 | Posted by lucygirl | Posted on October 13, 2007 4:01 PM
I have to agree with everyone that I was absolutely ecstatic to see not only the show renewed but for the second season to start. I even put an alarm on my cell in the VERY off chance that I would forget. I do have to say though that I am extremely happy that your recaps came back. I got a little scared there when it went a bit without it that you wouldn't be covering it anymore.
I think the controversy over the murder is a little too much to be honest. I don't think Landry or Tyra are violent people like some people have suggested. I really think Landry was just acting on instinct, knowing that this man had attacked the woman he loves. He's obviously been around her for the last eight months in addition to seeing how Tyra dealt with it in the very real and soon aftermath. The dumping of the body was a bit off the wall, but I am hoping the writers are going to give more insight to that as time goes on. Not to mention, like everyone says it's not the action (murder, rape, dealing with a soldier in Iraq, race) that makes the show what it is. It's the human emotions and fall out that really pulls at your heart.
I remember watching the first few episodes of season one and thinking that it was a great show, but it wasn't until a few more in where I was completely emotionally hooked. So I'm going to assume that likewise the writers will build in their own way.
Great recap. I love your balance of hilarity with recognition of awesomeness of the camera work, the writing, and of course the supreme acting ability. And who can forget the awesomeness that is Coach Taylor's hair.
14 of 14 | Posted by bentley1101 | Posted on October 14, 2007 9:42 PM