I thought this was a good episode—a great ending especially. I also like how Alex is all about birthing these days. But the show seems to be lapsing into formulaic territory. It's the same every week:


  1. ten minutes of humorous banter
  2. ten minutes presenting patients
  3. fifteen minutes of moral/ethical handwringing regarding the patient's procedure and/or any domestic dramas that may be involved therewith
  4. several tense moments spent cutting back and forth between two surgeries that are then interrupted by commercial to provide suspense about which patient(s) live(s)/die(s)
  5. an indirect revelation of which patient(s) died and which one(s) lived
  6. a tidy denoument that ties up loose ends or introduces new twists
  7. and let's not forget the final musical montage.

Anyway, I still really enjoy the characters, but I hope the writers vary the formula a bit, because it's getting a little repetitive. Hopefully the next episode—the great outdoors masculine camping trip—will do so. Anyway, how'd we like it?

Ham! Eggs! HUMPTY!! Sections:  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5 

« Recap: Survivor: White Lies... | Main | Recap: Prison Break: I Know Why The Caged Mahone Sings »

Comments (31)

xojenxo Author Profile Page:

Do you even like Grey's Anatomy? You seem to hate every aspect and every character on the show.

Just wondering : )

tvtvtv Author Profile Page:

I can't believe you just made me look up tumescent. And such excellent multi-uteri creativity. But poor m-ruv, definitely one of the more bitter entries. (Maybe you were hungover while recapping, or just had a bad headache?) Anyway, to answer xojenxo, I think he still gots some love for Montgomery, Callie and Cristina in her ballsy moments. PS: I can't WAIT to hear what you have to say about the camping trip vis a vis real life events (and by this I mean tabloid stories.)

Courtney Author Profile Page:

I'm with xojenxo. You really seem to hate this show. Any chance we can get someone to recap it who isn't a hater?

cherin Author Profile Page:

Not to sound too harsh or anything BUT... I agree 100%... I truly believe that you don't even like this show, which might explain why this entry came 8 days after this episode aired. This is the only show that I don't look forward to the recap for...

KAYDEE0 Author Profile Page:

Oh, come on! Who cares is M_ruv likes the show or not? He/she is an excellent writer, and I laugh everytime I read the recaps. We all know it's a ridiculous show anyway. Why take it so seriously?
M_Ruv, I hope writing is a profession you're considering....

m_ruv Author Profile Page:

FOOLIOS. I can apologize for the lateness only so many times. TVgasm writing is a volunteer enterprise, and given that I also have a full-time job, do freelance work on the side, am in the middle of researching grad school, and have both my parents and several friends currently visiting town, I'm sure you understand. The next recap, though, should be up by Monday.

Incidentally, I do greatly enjoy the show. For gushing, completely uncritical recaps, I'd suggest http://www.greyswriters.com.

Clair Author Profile Page:

I liked your recap - funny as always. :) It was fun to see Miss Honey (from the movie Matilda) as Sister Shepard.

Apple_Candy Author Profile Page:

M_ruv, if you're too busy to recap, maybe you should hand the duties off to someone else. Preferably someone who doesn't capitalize unnecessary things every paragraph.

Tati Author Profile Page:

m_ruv, i don't care if you like or hate the show or if the recaps are late, luv your recaps as always. I thnk u have the GA formula down pat!

Clair Author Profile Page:

m_ruv, I went to greywriters.com (zzzzz) and I gotta tell ya, your recap was WAAAY better... and I happen to LIKE your unnecessary capitalization.

anniedawg25 Author Profile Page:

m_ruv, great recap!

I had never watched this show until about 6 weeks ago. I decided to see what all the damn fuss was about. It's an OK show....but I see it's quickly taking the "Lost" and "Desperate Housewives" route by becoming ridiculous instead of entertaining.

Meredith "getting lost in selfabsorbtionland"....LOVE IT!!

Also, I am soooo sick of the "Mc" this, and "Mc" that...that thing ran it's course loooooong ago!

Thanks for the recaps though! I like 'em!

ckitten Author Profile Page:

I actually missed this episode! Sad! :( But thanks to ur review, i feel all caught up! So where is this week's review?! I can't wait to hear abt what u thought abt the slap fight! Cuz I like ur recaps!!!

Shaz Author Profile Page:

"George, meanwhile, tries to talk to Callie again by way of the failsafe ham/chicken anecdote." Awesome.

I, too, thought the uterusX2 chick looked like Ruthie from 'Real World: Hawaii', perhaps crossed with Michelle Kwan. Don't know why people are complaining about this recap, because a lot of what was stated was EXACTLY what was going through my mind at the time. Cynicism and sarcasm is the lifeblood of tvgasm. And m_ruv is right: although I love GA, the storyline themes are getting repetitive, and sometimes, unrealistic. But I'll still continue to watch.

Bauer's Sweetheart Author Profile Page:

I don't know what some of you guys are smoking, but m_ruv is the BEST and I would hate it if anyone else was recapping this show. Who cares if he doesn't like everyone (cause God knows some of these characters are VERY annoying) and who cares if the recap is a few days late? It is soooooo worth waiting for.

I agree this was not the best recap he has ever done, but maybe the source material was not as great. After all, to go from the previous week's story about a penis piercing stuck to an IUD to this week's story about ham and eggs - the jokes are a little harder to come by.

Keep up the great work, m_ruv! If I met you in a bar in Seattle, I'd get drunk on tequila and take you home!

m_ruv Author Profile Page:

Thanks - definitely not the best recap ever, but it was a loooong week. I'll have the next one up in the next couple days. And as a special courtesy to apple_candy, no caps whatsoever.

shannza Author Profile Page:

first of all, can we all recognize that m_ruv has amazing recaps? i crack up every time. and can we please comment now on the episode at hand and not about how timely the posts are? OK. and honestly, i know we suspend our disbelief for this show, but how come NOBODY regonizes that burke, the a-hole egomaniac is not letting anyone watch his amazing post injury comeback? and why is bailey all tough and bossy with izzie, but not supervising cristina whatsoever? doesn't she decide what the interns do everyday? seriously. and by the way, i checked out the grey's writers blog, and it made me want to stop watching the show. you're not writing the declaration of independence people.

tvtvtv Author Profile Page:

I love the caps. And the recaps. And I'd rather have it late and hilarious than on time and boooring. So there.

jash Author Profile Page:

ha, wow. some of you people are total jackasses. its not like these writers get paid anything for their efforts at amusing us.

the recap was hilarious, and i fully agree on the formula you listed at the end. the show has become exactly that, which obviously doesnt venture into any creative territory and for anyone to not realize the show may begin its slide into a staid existence, well thats sad.

i also appreciate the random capitalizations for emphasis...HILARIOUS.

everyone else can suck it, or go read some "hilarious" posts by tabloid baby.

xojenxo Author Profile Page:

Ok.. everyone is taking this way out of hand.

I don't care about the timeliness of the recaps. I understand that everyone is busy and they get posted when there is time.

I merely was asking if m_ruv enjoyed Grey's Anatomy because of his criticism of the show and the characters, it does not come through.

Also, the formula of the show seems to be working since it is consistently one of the top shows every week.

Also, greywriters.com is a recap from the writers of the show (duh). They are just explaining why they took the show in that direction. Not the same purpose of the Tvgasm recaps.

Apple_Candy Author Profile Page:

"And as a special courtesy to apple_candy, no caps whatsoever."

*GASP* Do you mean it?! I would be so very happy ; ;

EdHill Author Profile Page:

Speaking as someone who hated Desperate Housewives while also recapping it, I feel your pain m_ruv.

Stil, it makes for some good recaps. Hate is good!

zoobabe Author Profile Page:

Mc-ruvvy, I'm McHappy to read your McRecap. I found it McFabulous! I look forward to hearing your take on this week's fishing trip episode.

dactyl Author Profile Page:

"Also, the formula of the show seems to be working since it is consistently one of the top shows every week."

xojenxo, are you serious? Are you really saying that the preference of the American people indicates whether a show is good or not?

Tony A. Author Profile Page:

First of all, all of you bitching at m_ruv, cut it out. You don't like the recap, don't read it. It's a quality product at a price you can't beat. His/her points of view are to be respected. If you don't agree, then write your own recap. This person is taking a significant amount of time to watch the show (repeatedly) in order to get all the details, then writing a fairly long review/cap. And you couch potatoes have the nerve to criticize and tell m_ruv to go somewhere else if he/she (this is really annoying, m_ruv, what gender are you?) can't write a recap YOU will like! With all due respect, there are other sites, perhaps you'd like to visit them?

GA is tending to run a theme into the ground. They shoehorned the pig/chicken analogy into so many things they reached the point of saturation. And I think the Izzie thing needs to move on or give her a sabbatical to return with all her screws tightened.

The McSister thing was heavy-handed, with her giving her Waspy approval of McSteamy's doings. And, for the record, Addison is a slut that has no right to ask for Derek back. In fact, she should just step off his life. He. of course, is a wimp that can't make a rational decision as pertains to his love live.

If there's one thing I hate about the Pomp (aside from her annoying tired voice) is her curly upper lip. Makes her look like she has a permanent sneer.

I understand why Christina is doing what she's doing, but I hate the way they have weakened the Nazi's character to where she is suffering the abuse from Burke and Christina. The original Bailey would have bitch-slapped the anorexic Asian back into last week after her shenanigans.

Just watched the following show and I won't comment on it so as not to spoil before the recap and it does get better.

Keep up tyhe good work, m_ruv!

JasonR Author Profile Page:

m_ruv, I'm a big fan, as always. I barely have time to read the recaps, so I don't know how you guys find the time to write them.

One thing that bears mentioning is that once Shepard told his sister that the Addison-Sloan thing was not just a one-time thing but an extended affair, she became much more sympathetic to him and understanding of his decision to end his marriage. I thought it was a pretty decent depiction of the love-hate thing most of us have with our siblings.

I like the show but I do share some concerns many of you have expressed. Makes me think back to "Ally McBeal". Although I was never a regular viewer, I do know the show started out very original but quickly fell into formula and quirkiness for its own sake. Let's hope that doesn't happen to this show.

may1 Author Profile Page:

I love your recapping. Always entertaining. Thank you.

pjtvqueen Author Profile Page:

Just wanted to add to the praise, m_ruv, I love the recaps. And don't get rid of the caps forever, I find them amusing.

xojenxo Author Profile Page:

I also find m_ruv's recaps enjoying. I was just asking if he/she liked Grey's Anatomy because from his/her recaps, I can't tell.

Not commenting on the level of quality of his/her recaps.

Leah3t Author Profile Page:

"Not the same purpose of the Tvgasm recaps."

The purpose of tvgasm recaps is to write sunny, smoke up the ass of the writers, non sarcastic pieces?

Great recap M-ruv!I'm kind of bummed that izzy is getting so shrill and annoying. she was my fav last season.

tvtvtv Author Profile Page:

(and for the love of pete, m-ruv is a HE, people...well, assuming pixelated happy hour pics can be trusted.)

TakingBackSunday Author Profile Page:

It was so funny when they were in that old mans room and he like turned over and made groaned. I was busting out laughing alone.. in my room.. which was really awkward.
Anyway I thought it was a sweet recap. And I can't wait to see Addison and Alex hook up this season!

Post a comment

Post a comment

88