Well, in an example of expert timing, we've launched this site just as many of our favorite shows are ending their seasons. It's not too late to comment though. The following are my grades for various shows - some of which are still airing new episodes. Expanded commentary on certain shows' seasons will follow in later posts.

The Apprentice: A
Survivor: All-Stars: B (season finale - A)
Survivor: Pearl Islands: A
The OC: B+
24: B+
Real World: San Diego: A-
Real World/Road Rules Challenge - The Gauntlet: B
Real World/Road Rules Challenge - The Inferno: C+
Average Joe: Hawaii: B-
Average Joe: Adam Returns: C