
The Hollywood Reporter did an article about Carrie Underwood surpassing Kelly Clarkson as American Idol‘s highest earner. As of last year, Kelly Clarkson had sold 15,900,000 digital tracks since 2002, and as of this past May, Carrie Underwood has sold over 18,482,000 digital tracks. WOW! Is that insane, or what? Considering Lee Dewyze couldn’t even get 100,000 albums sold in his first week, it’s crazy that these girls’ numbers are so high. It just goes to show the decline of Idol, and their talent pool. Yes, still a ton of people watch the show, but it’s more about the show these days rather than the talent.
Here’s the Idol album breakdown that The Reporter did (pasted from The Reporter):
1. Carrie Underwood
Season 4 winner
Album sales: 12,296,000
Digital track sales: 18,482,000
2. Kelly Clarkson
Season 1 winner
Album sales: 10,674,000
Digital track sales: 17,254,000
The singer who started it all, Clarkson’s 18 singles, many of them hits, set the Idol bar high.
3. Chris Daughtry
Season 5, 4th place
Album sales: 6,104,000
Digital track sales: 11,127,000
He turned out to be a winner at rock radio with a string of chart-topping singles.
4. Clay Aiken
Season 2, runner up
Album sales: 4,990,000
Digital track sales: 581,000
His debut was a hit, and while Aiken has kept a low profile of late, public outings like his recent co-headlining trek with Ruben Studdard proved successful.
5. Fantasia
Season 3 winner
Album sales: 2,809,000
Digital track sales: 1,325,000
After a 2008 stint on Broadway in The Color Purple, she launched a reality show, Fantasia For Real, which became VH1’s No. 1 rated series.
6. Ruben Studdard
Season 2 winner
Album sales: 2,556,000
Digital track sales: 445,000
Four albums, a Grammy nomination and a co-headlining tour with Aiken has kept Studdard on the radar.
7. Jordin Sparks
Season 6 winner
Album sales: 1,275,000
Digital track sales: 9,547,000
Her massive presence on pop radio translates to 9 tracks sold for every album.
8. Jennifer Hudson
Season 3, 7th place
Album sales: 1,160,000
Digital track sales: 1,964,000
After winning an Oscar and Grammy, she lost over 80 pounds and became the spokewoman for Weight Watchers in 2010.
9. David Cook
Season 7 winner
Album sales: 1,324,000
Digital track sales: 4,196,000
Soon to follow his platinum-selling debut with June 28’s This Loud Morning, Cook also tours regularly and scored a deal with Skechers.
10. Kellie Pickler
Season 5, 6th place
Album sales: 1,322,000
Digital track sales: 3,319,000
Pickler made big waves on the country scene with her 2006 debut album, Small Town Girl. Tours with Brad Paisley (2007) and Taylor Swift (2009) followed.
If you like it, spread it!:
8 Comments
Just as the prophet Simon Cowell predicted all those years ago…=)
Ugh. She annoys me. The first will always be the best!
Carrie Underwood makes my pants feel tight.
I think if you take the different music genres they are in, it shows too. Country is REALLY supportive of its artists compared to pop. But I’m not surprised those 2 are on top. Those two really were the best to come from Idol.
I’m actually surprised it took her this long to pass Kelly, since she’s been raking in album sales nonstop since her win. Kelly has slowed down a lot the past few years.
And I agree completely with jarthon, Carrie and Kelly are by far the best Idols!
jayem – you’re crazy! Carried Underwood is the total package. She deserves every ounce of fame she’s gotten.
Ahh, Carrie: I think she has mediocre singing capability, but that’s perfect for the country music industry (particularly pop/country = no originality, recycled garbage with limited skill). I mean who are we kidding? Blonde hair, big boobs, caucasion, throw in some twang, a pop beat, and generic love themes = recipe country stardom. Too bad her music sucks. I personally think Carrie acts like a phony, entitled brat and has a huge head (to go with her ego). Kelly isn’t much better (talent wise), except she did seem like a genuinly nice girl and not some pre-packaged,cardboard Southern Barbie.
American Idol is pure crap anyway, though.