Idol Finale!!! OMG

6 Comments

1. 1
   georgiababe
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 2:13 am

   COOK all the way! Archie was THE SAME last night. The kid looks like a ventriloquist dummy.

   Cook deserves this so much more. I am FURIOUS at Simon for throwing him under the bus like that, but I ended up giving Cookie about 3,000 votes tonight, so I’ve done my bit. Never make a Word Nerd mad.

   More talent? Archie? PUH-lease. The kid has a nice voice, but to be a truly talented musician, you have to have the whole package. Cook has it, Archie does not.

   COOK FTW.

2. 2
   bigjr6633
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 9:46 am

   Maybe I’m missing something, but I wasn’t impressed with Archie last night. I’ve been on many sites and it’s like every recapper is like Archie won that night, he was the best singer, and he gave it his all and Cook didn’t. WTF? I must’ve heard something different because Archie did what he does every week which is bore me to death.

   Seriously, I’ve never liked Archie, he’s a nice kid, but the constant pimping of this child, the fact that he does the same thing every performance, and the fact he’s never given him any criticism at all by the judges really pissed me off.

   Anyway it doesn’t matter, David Cook won and I knew he was going to win matter what he did.

   P.S. This Season Sucked

3. 3
   Nads
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 10:17 am

   Okay, georgiababe and bigjr, I do take the Cook/talent part back from my post. Cook has way better stage presence that Archuleta, but I really do think that Archuleta did the better job last night. My friends are all mad at me today b/c we’ve been arguing about it on email (they all loved Cook last night)…

   Now in Cook’s defense, I thought that his last song was amazing, and Simon hated it, but Simon hates a lot of things. The judges were all for Archuleta last night, I wonder if the votes were down last week and they were trying to bias the voters.

   Cook is the better package, but Archuleta has the better voice. Now, who’s album would i be more likely to buy for my taste in music? David Cook. But, I do have to say that I overlooked Archuleta (and he bugged me the whole season) until last night. I still think that Archuleta did a better job.

   And lol re: making a Word Nerd mad…

   So, last night’s comp. winner (in my eyes): Archuleta

   Overall??? Cook, maybe??? I am disappointed in this season as I want something else from these singers…but to quote U2, “I still haven’t found what I’m looking for. ”

4. 4
   Donna Martin Graduates!
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 5:31 pm

   I predict Archuleta will win — just on last night’s perfs alone.

   I completely agreed with Cowell (I generally, tho reluctantly, do) — esp the fact that Cook should have done Billie Jean again — for the win.

   I agree that Cook has rockstar presence, but Archuleta is a consumate technician, in terms of his virtually flawless singing abilities and his ability to project emotion and connect with his audience — something that Cook has yet to master — and he also has a far broader range of appeal.

   Mark my words — somebody of the calibre of Burt Bacharach or Elton John + Bernie Taupin or Diane Warren will write Archuleta a series of killer and major hit songs and he’ll be be wowing crowds at Vegas well into his twilight years, with tonnes of legit fame in the long years inbetween now and then.

   Fetus for the win.

5. 5
   georgiababe
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 7:59 pm

   AND Cook takes it – like I always knew he would. Can’t base the champion on one night.

   Fetus has a contract with Disney. He’ll be starring in the next HSM sequels, mark MY words.

   COOKIE FTMFW!

6. 6
   Donna Martin Graduates!
   Posted May 21, 2008 at 11:34 pm

   D’OH!

   “And the American Idol is———”

   tivo out………….